clock menu more-arrow no yes

Your Guide to Finding the Best Innerspring Mattress

Today’s innerspring mattresses offer advanced cooling, motion isolation, comfort, responsiveness, and more. Take a look at some of the best innerspring mattresses on the market today.

Best Innerspring Mattress
Adobe

Most folks have experienced sleeping on innerspring mattresses, and they are considered the most traditional mattress of the various options available today. But just because they’ve been around awhile, that doesn’t mean innerspring beds are out of style. The best innerspring mattresses offer robust support for your body and are topped with a soft layer of padding. Innerspring mattresses tend to fare extremely well with motion isolation, making them great for couples. And, because they don’t trap heat the way memory foam does, they also tend to be great for hot sleepers.

The question is, with so many innerspring options available, which is the best mattress for you? Here’s our guide to selecting a new mattress that fits your sleeping position.

Best Innerspring Mattress - Our Top Picks

Saatva - Best Overall

Saatva Classic mattress
Saatva

If you’re looking to crash into a five-star, hotel-quality bed, Saatva is the luxury innerspring mattress you’ll want to try. Saatva’s foam and coil mattress is highly durable, incredibly supportive, and sleeps cool. Plus, the company will set up the mattress for you, in the room of your choice–a nice, luxurious perk of buying the Saatva mattress.

  • Made of eco-friendly materials
  • Great for side sleepers
  • Supports heavyweight sleepers

Related: Recreate the hotel-style experience at home with the best mattress for a guest room guide.

WinkBeds - Best Luxury Innerspring Mattress

WinkBeds mattress
WinkBeds

Handmade in Wisconsin, the WinkBeds Luxury Firm mattress was quite literally made to emanate luxury. There is not just one, but two innerspring layers in this mattress that help keep it responsive and supportive. This innerspring mattress got a perfect durability score and tested high for edge support. If you choose to invest in this luxury innerspring mattress, it is built to offer years of comfortable, luxurious rest.

  • Cooling cover and innerspring systems resulted in a high cooling score
  • Sleepers with back pain will appreciate its high spine alignment score
  • Especially supportive for stomach and back sleepers

Casper Wave Hybrid - Best Innerspring Mattress for Back Pain

Casper Wave Hybrid mattress
Casper

Casper is a famous online mattress brand, and we especially love their Wave Hybrid mattress. Its coil system is particularly designed to offer the ideal blend of pressure relief, responsiveness, and lumbar support, which means it’s a soothing option for back pain sufferers. A contouring memory foam layer goes a long way toward enhancing comfort, while coils keep sleepers uplifted.

  • Backed by the American Chiropractic Association for superb spine alignment and support
  • Near-perfect scores in cooling make it great for hot sleepers
  • Excellent motion isolation for couples

DreamCloud - Best Innerspring Mattress for Couples

DreamCloud mattress
DreamCloud

One of the perks of innerspring mattresses is that the coil system within the mattress tends to excel in motion isolation, making it super appealing for couples. What this means is that even if you move around or get up in the night, it’s unlikely to disrupt your partner. The DreamCloud is especially good for couples thanks to its near-perfect score in motion transfer testing. It also works very well for all sleep positions and body types, including heavyweight sleepers and seniors.

  • Works to keep the spine supported as you rest
  • Solid cooling score in testing
  • One of the best affordable mattresses

Helix Midnight Luxe - Best Innerspring Mattress for Hot Sleepers

Helix Midnight Luxe mattress
Helix

Innerspring mattresses are known for being highly breathable to help you stay cool. That’s certainly true of the Helix Midnight Luxe, which we’ve found to be one of the best mattresses for hot sleepers. This mattress accomplished an almost perfect score in cooling, which can be attributed to its cooling cover, gel memory foam layers, and innerspring system.

  • Compatible with all sleep positions
  • Top scores in spine support and alignment
  • Supports heavyweight sleepers

Brooklyn Bedding Signature - Best Innerspring Mattress for Customizable Firmness

Brooklyn Signature mattress
Brooklyn Bedding

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature is a universal favorite, supporting side sleepers, back sleepers, and stomach sleepers alike. A big part of that is thanks to the customizable firmness options. When you order your mattress, you can take your pick between a soft, medium-firm, or firmer mattress option. The Brooklyn Signature proved to be highly responsive and adapt at relieving pressure around the hips and shoulders during testing, all tribute to its supportive innerspring layer.

  • Top scores in spine alignment for all sleep positions
  • Innerspring construction helps this bed stay cool
  • One of the best mattresses under $1,000

Layla Hybrid - Best Hybrid Innerspring Mattress

Layla Hybrid mattress
Layla

Hybrid mattresses utilize responsive innerspring coils and plush foams to result in a supportive, high-quality bed. The Layla Hybrid is special because it’s flippable, offering two firmness levels to choose from. This mattress proved to be both responsive to movement while keeping the spine in alignment. With its customization and great testing scores, this hybrid mattress is hard to beat.

  • Great motion isolation for couples
  • Provides ample cooling
  • Highly durable

Avocado Green - Best Organic Innerspring Mattress

Avocado Green mattress
Avocado

If you’re looking for an organic innerspring mattress, the Avocado Green rises to the occasion. This mattress is entirely made of recycled and organic materials, resulting in a more hypoallergenic and green sleep space. Just because these materials are natural doesn’t mean they skimp on support–the Avocado excelled at spine alignment, durability, and responsiveness. The Avocado also shines when it comes to cooling thanks to moisture-absorbing cotton, wool, latex, and coils.

  • Spine alignment support particularly attractive for the stomach, back, and combination sleepers
  • Natural materials help with cooling
  • American-made mattress, constructed in California

Selecting the Best Innerspring Mattress

Generally speaking, modern innerspring mattresses can be relied on to provide a cool, supportive sleep experience, typically with good motion isolation and pressure relief. It’s important to understand that there are many different types of innerspring mattresses, and the materials used can determine how ultimately the mattress feels. Some coil systems are topped with gel memory foam, others with a latex support layer. Coil layers, coil type, and the number of steel coils also play a major role in the mattress feel.

Types of Coils

Open Coils (Bonnell Coils): Considered the most “traditional innerspring,” these hourglass-shaped coils are joined together with wire in a row. If the pressure is applied to one area, the entire coil network will compress and then expand.

Pocketed Coils: Unattached from the other coils in this system, each singular coil is enveloped in material to assist with isolating motion. Pocket coils also yield contouring to the shape of your body.

Continuous Coils: Made entirely of a single piece of wire that is shaped into multiple coils, creating a whole layer.

Offset Coils: Also implements an hourglass shape, but uses small wires called helicals to link them together. This system puts the coils closer together to aid in long-term durability and to stifle motion transfer.

Coil Gauge

Equivalent to how thick the wire used for coils is. The higher a number is, the softer a mattress will feel, while a lower number indicates thicker coils. 12 is the thickest coil available.

Coil Count

An innerspring mattress can contain anywhere to a couple hundred to over a thousand coils. Depending on the coil gauge and amount of coils used can help determine a mattress’s durability and overall quality.

Pros and Cons of Innerspring Mattresses

Pros Cons
Pros Cons
Price: There is an innerspring mattress for every kind of sleeper and budget. It boils down to your sleep needs and finding the best mattress in your price range. Innerspring beds can be easily found for under $1,000 and can climb in price based on their features. Sagging: If an innerspring is not made of quality materials meant for the long run, the mattress can dip down where pressure is constantly applied. Sagging then creates an uneven sleep surface.
Cooling: Innerspring mattresses naturally excel with breathability, because there is space within the mattress to let body heat flow through. Typically with foam mattresses, heat can be trapped within various comfort layers. Innerspring beds naturally are permeable. Noise: Unlike foam or latex mattresses, the metal used in innerspring can make noise as sleepers move around. If this is a concern, look for a hybrid that uses coils and layers of foam to stifle any possible noise.
Responsiveness: If you’re looking for a mattress that easily bounces back as you get comfortable, make sure to pay attention to the number of coils and coil thickness in your innerspring.

Final Thoughts

As you embark on your innerspring mattress shopping, use this guide to weigh all factors on selecting the right one for you. Keep in mind that all the mattresses listed here come with a trial period and various warranties, so you rest knowing you’re making the right call on your new mattress.