We may be compensated if you purchase through links on our website. Our Reviews Team is committed to delivering honest, objective, and independent reviews on home products and services.
Toilets may not be the first thing that comes to mind when talking about remodeling your bathroom, but as an item that will be used multiple times every day, finding a high-quality model can make a huge difference. The cost of a new toilet is generally between $200 and $500, although some high-end models with features such as built-in bidets, light features, and automatic cleaning can cost several thousand dollars.
To help you narrow down your choices and find the toilet that’s right for you, I researched the top models on the market. Overall, my top toilet choice is the American Standard H2Option, which features powerful flushing technology and sits at a comfortable height for most people. Read the buying guide below for more of my top picks.
Best Toilets: My Top 7 Picks
- Best Overall: American Standard H2Option
- Best for the Money: WOODBRIDGE Dual-Flush
- Easiest To Clean: DeerValley Ally Dual-Flush
- Best Compact Toilet: HOROW Small Dual-Flush
- Best Finish Options: Swiss Madison St. Tropez
- Best Smart Features: Kohler Numi 2.0 Comfort Height Smart Toilet
- Best Two-Piece: KOHLER Corbelle Comfort Toilet
Compare Top Toilets
| Product | Height | Shape | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|
| American Standard H2Option Toilet | 31.5 inches | Elongated | 1 year parts, 5 years finish |
| WOODBRIDGE Dual-Flush Toilet | 28 inches | Elongated | 1 year |
| DeerValley Ally Dual-Flush Toilet | 27 inches | Elongated | 1 year |
| HOROW Small Dual-Flush Toilet | 28.4 inches | Round | 2 years |
| Swiss Madison St. Tropez Toilet | 31 inches | Elongated | 1 year |
| Kohler Numi 2.0 Comfort Height Smart Toilet | 26.2 inches | Oblong | 1 year |
| KOHLER Corbelle Comfort Toilet | 31.3 inches | Elongated | 1 year |
| Product | Height | Shape | Warranty |
Best Overall
American Standard H2Option
- $275.08
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Good For: Homeowners seeking a straightforward, affordable toilet with powerful flushing.
Key Features
- Glazed trapway
- Seat sold separately
- 31.5 inches tall
What Are People Saying About the American Standard H2Option?
I found that customers loved the flushing mechanism on this toilet, reporting fewer clogs. In addition, they mentioned its extra height, which meant less squatting to sit. However, I also saw some reviewers give this toilet low ratings, citing frustration that the seat wasn’t included, and others were confused by the sound it made when flushing.
“….Comfortable height for a six-foot dude, easy to keep clean, compatible with standard seats (not included, but that’s okay), plus the top mount buttons make it look more expensive than it is. Can’t speak to the install, but my contractor had no complaints!” — Hallway via Amazon
“This toilet is more narrow than some, which is a bonus for a small bathroom/water closet. It works well and looks nice. I give it only three stars because it has a flush button on top of the tank (I prefer a handle on one side or the other so spare tp can be kept on the tank!) and, more importantly, it makes a kind of clunk sound when it flushes that I’m not used to. I open the lid to make sure everything goes down every time after I flush.” — Rubies481 via Amazon
Best for the Money
WOODBRIDGE Dual-Flush
- $304
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Good For: Customers seeking luxury features in their toilet without paying a premium price.
Key Features
- Dual flushing
- Stainless-steel hinges
- 28 inches tall
What Are People Saying About the WOODBRIDGE Dual-Flush?
In my review of customer feedback for this toilet, I learned that most buyers were very happy with the unit’s ease of installation and high-quality craftsmanship. For most buyers, the toilet arrived intact with no scratches or dents. The small percentage of buyers who I found to have received a defective product reported poor customer service to get the issue resolved. Others had some issues with this toilet’s flushing ability.
“Without hesitation, I will recommend this toilet to anyone in the market for a new toilet. It’s beautiful, comfortable, and affordable…. The elongated bowl gives you a bit more reach around room than the round bowl toilet does. It has two flush options, one slightly more powerful than the other…. It flushes great and it’s quiet in comparison to others I’ve had. One push of the button takes care of any situation I’ve come across.” — Bryce via Amazon
“….These are easy to clean, but the trap within the toilet clogs as easily as the old ones. There seems to be very little difference in the flush between the main flush and the urine only flush. It took two plumbers four hours to install both toilets. The contractor sent one plumber. He soon called for help. These toilets are very heavy, and one person cannot align while lifting.” — John Brown via Amazon
Easiest to Clean
DeerValley Ally Dual-Flush
- $229
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Good For: Customers looking for a low-maintenance toilet that’s easy to clean.
Key Features
- Dual flushing
- Soft-closing seat
- 27 inches tall
What Are People Saying About the DeerValley Ally Dual-Flush?
I found that customers often mentioned this toilet’s water efficiency, stating that it saved them money on their water bills. They also frequently mentioned its easy cleaning and its sleek, stylish design. However there were also some reviews that said this toilet’s smaller seat wasn’t as comfortable to sit on as a full-size seat, and others had issues with parts of the seat rusting.
“I live with all boys, and this toilet is literally so easy to keep clean. It has a soft close lid and the seat is so easy to remove for cleaning. I’m really happy with this purchase and how beautiful it looks in our bathroom.” — Shanna Walker via Amazon
“I had previously written a five-star review, but I’m knocking it down because the cap for the seat release bracket is metal and rusts. This wouldn’t be a big deal if it was possible to buy an inexpensive replacement cap or even better a replacement cap that wasn’t metal and didn’t rust! When I contacted the company to inquire about replacement parts, I was told it wasn’t possible to just purchase the metal caps. Instead, they recommended replacing the entire seat … I certainly don’t want to spend that amount of money for a seat with parts that will just rust again.” — AprilM via Amazon
Best Compact Toilet
HOROW Small Dual-Flush
- $336.14
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Good For: Those with limited space who still want a high-quality toilet.
Key Features
- Dual flushing
- Self-cleaning glaze
- 28.4 inches tall
What Are People Saying About the HOROW Small Dual-Flush?
According to my verified-buyer research, most customers said this toilet’s one-piece design made it easy to install and clean, and others liked its dual-flush design. However, the model had mixed reviews on the chair height. Some people liked how compact it was, while others couldn’t sit comfortably. Other negative reviews mentioned that they felt this toilet was too small.
“What I like most about this toilet is that is designed with a powerful and quiet dual flush system, which is a great feature for a compact toilet. It also has a 12″ rough-in, so is compatible with most standard bathrooms. In terms of aesthetics, the modern design makes this toilet a stylish addition to any bathroom. The included soft-closing seat is a nice touch, adding to the sleek and contemporary feel of the product.” — c’est la vie via Amazon
“The toilet fits our small bathroom well, but the seat is awful. It doesn’t stay hinged properly, wobbles and is off-center. I wouldn’t buy it again.” — John H via Amazon
Best Finish Options
Swiss Madison St. Tropez
- $283
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Good For: Customers re-modeling their bathroom that want flexibility when selecting a toilet’s finish.
Key Features
- Removable seat
- Dual flushing
- 31 inches tall
What Are People Saying About the Swiss Madison St. Tropez?
I noticed that satisfied buyers cited how easy this toilet was to clean, especially with its detachable seat. Others were impressed with its modern-looking design. However, I also saw some customers complain about complicated installation, saying that the parts were defective or the instructions were confusing. Others were disappointed by this toilet’s seat.
“…It installed easily, came packed in nearly bulletproof packaging and is the easiest-to-clean toilet I’ve ever seen. With one push of a button, the toilet seat lifts off to clean in those difficult spots. The sides are flat, and no deep divots to try and get cleaned out. It came complete and has a small footprint but full ADA-compatible height.” — J Wells via Amazon
“I had this toilet installed by my contractor. He said it was very heavy and required two to install. The toilet seat itself is the worst thing about this toilet. Super, super cheap feeling. The hinges broke for some reason after a couple of uses. The flush is also mediocre, I’ve had to unclog the toilet multiple times.” — Eric Tran via Amazon
Best Smart Features
Kohler Numi 2.0 Comfort Height Smart Toilet
- $9,937
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Good for: Customers seeking a high-end toilet with all of the latest technology.
What Are People Saying About the Kohler Numi 2.0 Comfort Height Smart Toilet?
Customers who gave this product positive reviews were impressed with its variety of features, specifically the heating element and light-up feature. Others commented on its strong flushing ability. However, others had issues with the remote not working properly, and some found the price to be far too high.
“Nice improvements to the original (very good) Numi excellent features; it would be even better if it supported Apple Homekit! …All in all, very good purchase.” — Gozur via Google
“Installation shows a plug and a short lead? There is no outlet that close to any toilet unless you plan it when you build. Better to have an IP65 connection box on the side. What is the remote function and speaker for? The price is outrageous — to get a bidet attachment installed it costs less than $100.” — Grabbeus via Google
Best Two-Piece
KOHLER Corbelle Comfort Toilet
- $543.33
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Good for: Homeowners that prefer a two-piece toilet with an elongated bowl design.
What Are People Saying About the KOHLER Corbelle Comfort Toilet?
I found that reviewers who were happy with this toilet liked that it used minimal water and was energy efficient. Others were pleased with its easy installation and sleek, modern design. However, other customers were disappointed that this product didn’t come with a seat, and others claimed it did not always flush properly.
“Updating our 40 year-old home and started with the downstairs half bathroom. That toilet is used the most, so wanted something comfortable, reliable and attractive. I knew I wanted something taller than the standard toilet so when I saw this one, I was impressed. My husband, who is no handyman, was able to install it himself… Very pleased with the purchase and will be purchasing a second one for the master bathroom.” — Tom Thomason via Amazon
“Bought this toilet a couple of months ago since we had been having problems with the Toto toilet we’d had for years. I was so excited to get this new Kohler toilet after reading so many positive reviews. I love the height, and that is about the best thing I can say. Half the time, solid waste does not flush, and the water level rises to the rim of the toilet. Have to use the plunger several times to get things back in order. This toilet has been a huge disappointment..” — LVAN via Amazon
What To Know Before Buying a Toilet
If you’re searching for the best toilet for your full or half bathroom, there are several important factors you’ll need to consider to ensure you’re finding the best option for your home.
Consider first what toilet bowl shape you prefer and what height is most comfortable for all members of your household. Then, consider factors such as the toilet’s flushing mechanism, design, and extra features to help you narrow down your options.
Read the buying guide below for more information on how to select the best toilet for your home.
What shapes do toilet bowls come in?
Most toilet seats are either round or elongated. I find that elongated toilet bowls are spacious and comfortable to sit on, while round bowls fit better in smaller bathrooms. There is a third option: compact elongated. Compact elongated bowls split the difference, providing the comfort of an oval shape without taking up too much room.
How do you determine the best height for your toilet seat?
I recommend measuring the height of your current toilet seat; most likely, you have a standard height toilet. If that works for you, stick with that height when shopping for a new one. If you’re looking to make your bathroom ADA-compliant, comfort height toilets sit higher off the ground, making them more accessible for people with disabilities or limited mobility.
What are the different types of flushing mechanisms in toilets?
Most modern toilets have a gravity flush system, which creates flushing pressure by releasing the tank water into the bowl and forcing the contents through the drain and into the pipe. The other option is pressure-assisted flushing. Pressure-assisted toilets use the flushing power of siphoned air to create a more powerful flush.
What should you look for in the design of a toilet?
Many newer toilets have a unified tank and bowl design, which looks seamless and makes the toilet relatively easy to clean.
However, according to my research, there are still many two-piece toilets that feature a tank separate from the bowl. This is the classic build, but it can be more difficult to rough in and clean.
What are some other features you should consider in a new toilet?
As technology advances, so do toilets. You can now find high-efficiency toilets, wall-mounted toilets, and quality commodes with the following features:
- Automatic flushing
- Bidets
- Built-in deodorizers
- Dual flushing
- Heated seats
- Night lights
- Remote control
- Slow-close hinges
- Touchless flushing
How To Keep Your Toilet Clean
Now that you have a new toilet, its recommended you take the following steps to keep it in pristine condition. Here are some easy cleaning tips.
Research Toilet Bowl Cleaners
There are many toilet bowl cleaners on the market. You can go for a wand, liquid, or tablet. Toilet wands use single-use heads that come presoaked in a cleaning solution. Liquid toilet bowl cleaners come in a squirt or spray bottle. Toilet tablets sit in the bowl and flush down the pipe.
Identify Stains
Most toilet bowl cleaners treat limescale buildup. However, if you notice hard water or rust stains along your toilet bowl, you may want to invest in a specialty bathroom cleaner.
Don’t Neglect Crevices
While the bowl is the most important part to clean because it sees the most germs, don’t forget the other surfaces. Wiping the tank and post with a paper towel soaked in a cleaning solution typically gets the job done.
Treat Overnight
If you have tough stains, try soaking them overnight in a cleaning solution or white vinegar, then wipe it away in the morning.
Clean Frequently
My advice is to clean your toilet bowl at least once a week. This keeps it looking and smelling fresh by eliminating germs.
Frequently Asked Questions About Toilets
What is a toilet’s MaP score?
A toilet’s MaP score is its maximum performance according to the protocol put forth by Maximum Performance Testing (MaP Testing), an independent evaluation program. It refers to the number of grams of waste a toilet can discard in a single flush. An ideal score is between 600 and 1,000 grams. Learn more about the testing protocol at MaP Testing’s What is MaP? page.
How much do toilets weigh?
Most toilets weigh between 80 and 120 pounds. As such, moving and installing most toilets takes at least two people.
Who should I buy a toilet from?
There are several reputable toilet sellers out there. My research indicates the top brands include:
- Delta
- Glacier Bay
- Kohler
- TOTO
Besides these, I also recommend the brands listed in this review.
What is the WaterSense label on a toilet?
The WaterSense label on a toilet is a label from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that designates the toilet as water-efficient and eco-friendly.
Water-efficient toilets can use 1.28 GPF, or gallons of water per flush, instead of the standard 1.6 GPF, which is 20% less water usage.
Can I install a toilet by myself?
If you have rudimentary plumbing experience and a basic kit of essential plumbing tools, you can probably install a toilet yourself. But keep in mind that most toilets are quite heavy and cumbersome, so having two people on the job is typically safer and easier.
To proceed with a DIY toilet installation, refer to our How to Install a Toilet in 8 Steps and How to Change a Toilet guides.
Also, if you have a smart toilet with a built-in bidet and other features, it’s usually best to hire a professional plumber for the installation.
Other Bathroom Resources
We’ve reviewed many bathroom products for customer reputation, longevity, ease of use, and more features. Read our top resources below:
- Best toilet bowl cleaners
- Best toilet papers
- Best over-toilet bathroom organizers
- Best shower shelves and caddies
- Best bathroom mirrors
How We Selected the Best Toilets
To provide our readers with the best toilet recommendations possible, we rely on several key sources of information to help guide our selection process.
Initial Research: Our research process began by generating our list of top picks. To do this, we isolated toilets with a significant number of verified-buyer reviews and an average customer review rating of 4–5 stars. We looked at positive and negative reviews alike, focusing on information from both satisfied and critical buyers.
Expert Insights: Through our years of experience, we’ve learned that listening to what others have to say is key to building accurate, well-rounded articles. To complement our in-house expertise, our team looked at reviews from trusted publications and independent testers, learned from subject matter experts, and drew insights from reader contributions.
Final Product Selection: We then began fine-tuning our list by replacing older models with the latest versions and eliminating any discontinued models. From there, we pared the list down further by comparing each model’s feature set and selecting the best-in-class options for a variety of buyers, budgets, and scenarios.
Our Methodology
This Old House has empowered homeowners and DIY-ers for more than four decades with top-notch home improvement advice in the form of television programs, print media, and digital content. Our team focuses on creating in-depth product and service review content. To date, we’ve published over 1,600 reviews on products in the home space, including power tools, outdoor equipment, major appliances, kitchen gadgets, electronics, and more that focus on product quality and helpfulness to our readers.
To provide our readers with the best recommendations possible, we rely on several key sources of information to help guide our selection process.
Initial Research: Our research process began by generating a list of toilets with a significant number of verified buyer reviews and an average customer review rating of 4–5 stars. We looked at positive and negative reviews alike, focusing on information from both satisfied and critical buyers.
Expert Insights: To complement our in-house expertise, our team looked at reviews and videos from trusted publications and independent testers, spoke with subject matter experts, and drew insights from reader contributions.
Final Product Selection: We then began fine-tuning our list by replacing older models with the latest versions and eliminating any discontinued models. From there, we compared each model’s feature set to create a final short list, selecting the best-in-class options for various buyers, budgets, and scenarios.
Once we conclude our research, we craft a comprehensive, user-friendly article of recommended products and additional information to help our readers make the right purchase.
Questions or Comments?
To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.