The 9 Best Gutter Guards (2023 Reviews)

• Materials: Unplasticized polyvinyl chloride (uPVC), stainless steel
• Design: Micro-mesh
• Multiple color options: Yes
• Financing available: Yes
• Warranty: Lifetime, transferable

The LeafFilter gutter guard is a three-piece design that includes a durable uPVC frame, stainless steel micro-mesh filter, and hidden internal hangers. These hangers attach to your home’s fascia board to reinforce the entire gutter system. LeafFilter’s ultra-fine mesh can block debris as small as shingle grit and pollen. 

You can request a no-obligation estimate from LeafFilter over the phone or via its online contact form. When we requested an estimate, LeafFilter notified us that a home inspection would be required before providing any pricing information. Below, we’ve outlined the general inspection and installation process:

1. A LeafFilter technician will inspect your home, measuring the gutters and looking for defective sections that may need repair or replacement.
2. After you sign the contract, an installer or team of installers will come on the scheduled date to install the gutter guard system and clean up any debris.
3. You may register your lifetime warranty on LeafFilter’s website once the installation is complete.

After analyzing LeafFilter customer reviews published with the Better Business Bureau (BBB), we found that many customers were pleased with LeafFilter’s gutter guard and installation process. Some customers were displeased with the company’s sales tactics, mentioning that they felt pressured to sign a contract to lock in a lower price than originally quoted. Here are two recent LeafFilter reviews: 

“The LeafFilter system is working perfectly; only water gets into the gutters. The system was installed the day after the sale was finished. One person cleaned the gutters and down spouts, added diverters, and installed the drip edge and the leaf guard filters in 2 days (Saturday and Sunday). The installer was knowledgeable and courteous, and kept me posted on his progress throughout the installation. I recommend the LeafFilter system for anyone who wants to eliminate cleaning their gutters for the rest of their life (guaranteed and transferrable to the next owner as well, by LeafFilter).” —Bob N, May 6, 2023, on BBB

“I requested to get a quote so I would be able to compare companies on the product and prices. When the sales person did not like that we wanted to review and compare quotes from other companies he would not leave us a written scope of work or quote. He just left some numbers on a piece of paper. Very unprofessional in my opinion. He wanted an answer at that time for the lowest price on the piece of paper. I wanted to find out how he came up with the price and what material is being used in writing.” —Kenneth R, September 7, 2022, on BBB

• Materials: Aluminum
• Design: Reverse-curve
• Multiple color options: Yes; 12 colors listed on website
• Financing available: Yes
• Warranty: Lifetime finish warranty, transferable

LeafGuard has been in the gutter guard industry for more than 30 years, and its gutter system is backed by the Good Housekeeping Institute. The company offers a unique rain gutter and gutter guard combination seamlessly constructed from a single piece of aluminum. Its reverse-curve gutter guard blocks debris while routing water into your gutters using the scientific principle of liquid adhesion. Professional installers custom-fit the product to each home during installation.

You can call LeafGuard’s toll-free number or fill out its online form to request an estimate. When we filled out the online form, we learned that LeafGuard will not provide an estimate without visiting the home. A representative contacted us shortly after submitting the form and confirmed this information. Here is what the estimate and installation process looks like: 

1. A LeafGuard representative will visit your home to assess and measure the existing gutter system, providing an estimate on-site. 
2. On the scheduled installation day, a LeafGuard technician will return to your home and custom-fit the one-piece LeafGuard gutter and gutter guard system to your home.
3. The technician will fine-tune the new gutter system, installing structural hangers and adjusting the pitch before cleaning any debris from your property.
4. Once the LeafGuard system is installed, you should register your lifetime finish warranty on the company’s website.

LeafGuard has mixed customer reviews on sites such as BBB and Trustpilot. Satisfied customers mention the company’s professionalism and the effectiveness of the product after years of use. More critical customers focused on unsatisfactory salesmanship of LeafGuard representatives or performance issues after installation. Here are two recent LeafGuard reviews:

“Excellent product, had Leafguard on our house in PA and just had them installed here in SC. Two guys, [LeafGuard installer] and [LeafGuard installer] completed the install in one day, took away the old gutters and took time to explain the system as there have been several upgrades since we first had them installed in PA. Expensive, yeah, but you get what you pay for. Top mount gutter filters sound good but when soggy leaves accumulate on them, they need to be cleaned off. Not with LeafGuard.” —Bob J, April 13, 2023, on BBB

“This is a very expensive system that says you don’t have to get up on a ladder anymore. This is not true. Also my gutter has an awful leak after spending big money on the system. My gutter is worse than when I started. I do not recommend LeafGuard.” —Denise S, August 9, 2022, on BBB

• Materials: Stainless steel, aluminum
• Design: Micro-mesh
• Multiple color options: Yes; 12 colors listed on website
• Financing available: Yes
• Warranty: Lifetime, transferable

The HomeCraft gutter guard uses patented, diamond-raised technology that performs better than hooded or reverse-curve options. The guards are made from a combination of marine-grade stainless steel and finely woven micro-mesh to block debris while allowing water to flow through.

Like other professional installers, HomeCraft has a contact form on its website for requesting estimates, or you can call a live agent. Either way, you will need to schedule a home inspection before HomeCraft will provide a quote. The company called us to set up an appointment within minutes after we requested a quote online. Here is what to expect from the inspection and installation process:

1. 1. During the inspection, the HomeCraft representative will measure your gutters, demonstrate the company’s gutter guard, and provide a quote that remains valid for up to one year. 
   2. Prior to installation, HomeCraft will clean, seal, and repair your existing gutter system as necessary.
   3. The installer will attach the gutter guard and clean any debris. 
   4. You will need to speak to the representative to discuss any necessary steps for registering for the lifetime, transferable warranty. 

HomeCraft has positive customer feedback across sites such as Yelp, Trustpilot, and the BBB. Customers praise HomeCraft’s family-owned and operated business for its friendly and knowledgeable sales staff. Negative reviews frequently mention excessive, ongoing sales calls after the prospective customer declined service. Here are two recent HomeCraft reviews:

“I had a terrific experience with [HomeCraft sales representative]. [HomeCraft sales representative] was very knowledgeable about the product and explained to me just why HomeCraft gutter protection is the best. I know that I bought a product that will last a very long time.” —Ronald C, May 15, 2022, on BBB

“This business has been harassing me with telemarketing calls for weeks now. 5+ calls a day, 7 days a week sometimes as late as 10pm. [I] told every single employee on the line that they have the wrong number, there is no one with the name they are asking for and to please not call back and yet here they are calling me again at 2:30 pm on a Sunday.” —Rhi L, January 15, 2023, on BBB

• Materials: Stainless steel, aluminum
• Design: Micro-mesh
• Multiple color options: No
• Financing available: Yes
• Warranty: Lifetime

All American Gutter Protection installs micro-mesh gutter guards custom-fit to your gutters. All American offers seamless gutter installation services if your gutters aren’t in good condition and need to be replaced. These gutters are a single sheet of metal measured and cut to fit your home and come in various color opinions. We also like that All American offers fascia repair and replacement when necessary.

To start your All American quote, you will need to request an estimate over the phone or on its website and provide basic contact information. We requested an online estimate through All American. The representative informed us that someone would reach out within 12 hours to schedule an in-person inspection. Here is what to expect from the All American installation process: 

1. On the day of your scheduled appointment, All American will measure your home’s gutters to provide a gutter guard estimate.
2. You can discuss the gutter guard’s lifetime performance guarantee, military and senior discounts, and the available financing options with your sales representative before signing the contract.
3. The company will typically schedule the gutter guard installation within two to three days of you signing the contract.

All American Gutter Protection has overall positive reviews on the BBB. Satisfied customers noted the company’s professional and timely gutter guard installations. We found negative reviews that cited issues with the company honoring its warranty. Here are two All American customer reviews from the BBB:

“I had gutter guards that were placed in one day, the crew that installed them were professional and quick. That was 4 months ago and I am so happy that my gutters no longer get trash or debris in them. Thank you, All American Gutter Protection LLC.” —Monica N, October 23, 2022, on BBB

“Worst warranty ever. Called repeatedly for service with no response. Sales person sold me on the no questions warranty. My gutter performance is now worse than before All American Gutter installed the new system. It’s been almost 2 months since the initial installation with no call back to set up a warranty visit for repair. Do not be fooled as I was. I’ve been chasing them for weeks. The water overflow has repeatedly damaged my property.” —Elias H, July 29, 2022, on BBB

• Materials: Stainless steel, aluminum
• Design: Micro-mesh
• Multiple color options: No
• Financing available: Yes
• Warranty: Lifetime, transferable

Gutter Guards America uses a micro-mesh gutter guard with a surgical-grade stainless steel screen and a seamless aluminum frame. These materials make its gutter guard ultra-durable, long-lasting, and corrosion-resistant. Gutter Guards America backs up its products with a transferable lifetime warranty and a 100% money-back guarantee.

You can call Gutter Guards America or submit your contact information online to request a call back from a representative. Gutter Guards America reached out to us within one hour of our online request. Similar to other professional installers, Gutter Guards America will first inspect your home’s existing gutter system before providing your estimate. Here’s how the process works from start to finish: 

1. Gutter Guards America will inspect your existing gutter for potential repair or cleaning needs and to take measurements.
2. A representative will provide you with an estimate for gutter guard installation and any necessary gutter sealing, reinforcement, or repair.
3. The company will return to perform your requested gutter services on the agreed-upon date, and you will receive a lifetime, transferable warranty for your new gutter guards. 

We analyzed recent customer reviews for Gutter Guards America on Trustpilot. The overall feedback was positive, with many customers complimenting the company’s professionalism and efficiency. Some mixed and negative reviews mentioned scheduling and communication issues. Here are two recent Gutter Guards America reviews:

“Gutter Guard America got back to me quickly upon my initial inquiry. Within a week, an initial quote and installation occurred. They were professional and got the job completed during the stated time frame. The guards have been performing as advertised.” —Brian J, April 30, 2023, on Trustpilot

“The job was not completed. They ran into a problem. Mr. Yarnell said he would call me on Wednesday, the 4th. No one has called. We are waiting.” —Linda H, May 5, 2022, on Trustpilot

• Materials: Stainless steel, aluminum
• Warranty length: 25 years
• Fit: 5-, 6-, and 7-inch gutters

This gutter guard has an ultra-fine mesh to keep out small debris such as seeds and pine needles. The mesh is made from stainless steel and is rust- and corrosion-resistant. Raptor’s gutter guard is available on Amazon and has overall positive customer feedback from more than 4,000 customer reviews.

Raptor Gutter Guard is available on Amazon with a listed price of $2.60 per linear foot. For a home with a total gutter length of 200 linear feet, expect to pay $520.  

Raptor Gutter Guard comes with a detailed installation guide and the self-tapping screws you need to attach the guard to your home’s fascia board. Note that you may need to bend or cut the gutter guard and should have tin snips on hand.

Based on more than 100 Amazon reviews we read, satisfied customers said these gutter guards were easy to install because of the instructions, drill bit head, and surplus screws included with the product. The main complaint was that the holes in the mesh were so small they wouldn’t allow all of the water to pass through during a downpour, causing water to flow over the gutters instead.

• Materials: Aluminum
• Warranty length: Lifetime
• Fit: 5- and 6-inch gutters

A-M Gutter Guard’s covers have a screen that lays across the top of your gutters to prevent debris from reaching the bottom while allowing water to flow through. The screen also comes with a lifetime warranty that states A-M Gutter Guard will replace the product if it stops working at any time.

A-M Gutter Guard is available on Amazon for approximately $1.32 per foot for the 200-feet package. For a home with 200 linear feet of gutter length, expect to pay around $264.

Your A-M Gutter Guard will come with an installation guide, but the necessary zip screws must be bought separately. You will need a drill or screwdriver on hand to attach the gutter guard. Tin snips are also necessary in case you need to cut a section to fit your gutters.

Several Amazon reviewers in wooded areas said this gutter guard kept leaves, twigs, and branches out of their gutters. However, some customers said that it required more maintenance than they expected. For example, the gutter guard formed a valley that collected debris and caused pine needles to get stuck in the holes, forcing customers to clean their gutters multiple times per year. (Most gutter guards require cleaning every one to two years.)

• Materials: Powder-coated steel
• Warranty length: 10-year limited warranty
• Fit: 4-, 5-, and 6-inch gutters

This gutter guard is similar to Raptor’s micro-mesh guard except its holes are much bigger, minimizing water overflow. The Amerimax gutter guard comes in 3-foot long sections, but you can order various pack sizes to ensure you have enough guards to fill all of your gutters. Amerimax manufactures its product in the U.S. 

Amazon lists the Amerimax Lock-In Gutter Guard at approximately $1.33 per foot. For a home with a 200-feet gutter length, expect to pay around $266.

You install this product by sliding it under the outermost shingles and clipping the guard onto the front of your home’s gutter. You will not need extra tools, fasteners, or additional hardware.

Though these guards can be challenging to install, several Amazon customers said they were easier than types requiring fasteners and tools. Some reviews said water rushed right over the gutter cover instead of going through it because of how slick the paint coating is on the steel.

• Materials: Plastic, steel wire
• Warranty length: 10-year material warranty
• Fit: 5- and 6-inch gutters

This gutter guard has plastic bristles wrapped in steel wire and slides directly into your gutter, blocking large debris from getting in while allowing water to seep through. Installation for this guard is quick and simple—it comes in 3-feet sections like the Amerimax mesh guard and easily slides into the gutter.

GutterBrush is available on Amazon for approximately $3.65 per foot. Expect to pay $730 for a home with 200 total feet of gutter length.

Brush-style gutter guards are among the easiest to install. You simply drop the brush sections into your existing gutter. No fasteners are needed. If the length of the last gutter guard section extends past the gutter, you can simply bend the excess back into the gutter.

Multiple Amazon customers were realistic about how well these gutter covers would work, understanding that they could only keep out large pieces of debris. Because of this, customers occasionally had to rinse smaller debris from the guards. Several customers complained the gutter guard didn’t work well in yards with many trees and became easily clogged by leaves and twigs.