Gutters keep water out of your home, but they can clog and stop working if you don’t regularly clean them. Homeowners who don’t want to constantly climb up a ladder to do this cleaning can invest in gutter guards. These products don’t eliminate the need for maintenance but significantly decrease how often you have to do it.

The This Old House Reviews Team has researched the best gutter guards and compiled our findings. This guide compares our top eight recommendations.


 

Top 8 Gutter Guards of 2022

VIEW MORE

 


 

LeafFilter

LeafFilter’s stainless steel micro-mesh gutter guard is installed by professionals using a three-step process. First, structural hangers are attached to the fascia board, or the trim that runs along your roof’s edge. They then add a frame across your gutters to create a platform for the gutter guard to lay on. This installation method ensures that your gutters stay protected for years to come.

It should be noted that gutter guards do not eliminate the need for gutter cleaning. However, they greatly reduce the frequency.

Pros and Cons of LeafFilter

✔ Includes a transferable lifetime warranty 

✔ Made with 275-micron stainless steel mesh

✔ Offers new gutter installation if needed 

✘ Available in only 43 states 

✘ Must be professionally installed

 

Key Features

  • Stainless steel guard material
  • uPVC frame
  • Metal hanger
  • Customizable sizes
  • Rustproof
  • Lifetime warranty

What Customers Are Saying

LeafFilter’s products and services have an average rating of 3.2 stars out of 5 from top consumer review websites, including the Better Business Bureau (BBB), Trustpilot, and Yelp. The company also has an accreditation and A+ rating from the BBB.

Overall, customers were pleased with LeafFilter’s gutter guard and installation process. Reviewers said the installation teams arrived on time and efficiently installed the gutter covers, which have since prevented debris buildup. Some customers were displeased with the company’s sales tactics, saying that they quoted them an expensive price and continued to lower the price until the customers agreed to pay that amount. Others mentioned issues with freezing water accumulating in the filters and gutters during winter. 

*BBB scores are current as of August 2022.

Learn more: LeafFilter review

 


 

HomeCraft

HomeCraft’s guards use patented, diamond-raised technology that performs better than hooded or reverse-curve options. The guards are made from a combination of marine-grade stainless steel and finely woven micro-mesh to block debris while allowing water to flow through.

Pros and Cons of HomeCraft

✔ Unique raised-screen design for improved debris filtration

✔ Family-owned and operated business 

✔ Metal roof compatibility

✘ Only available in 10 states

✘ No pricing information online

 

Key Features

  • Uses 304 marine-grade stainless steel
  • Attaches to the gutter’s front lip
  • Works with metal roofs
  • Includes a lifetime warranty
  • Estimates are good for one year

What Customers Are Saying

HomeCraft has fairly high customer review scores of 3 out of 5 or higher across popular sites such as Yelp, TrustPilot, and the BBB. The gutter guard company the BBB are holds a B rating.*

Customers praise HomeCraft’s family-owned and operated business for its friendly and knowledgeable sales staff. Reviews also highlight the company’s transferable warranty and well-executed installation process. Some reviews mention difficulty with scheduling and confusion about pricing involving a deposit, but clear communication should resolve this issue.

All American Gutter Protection

All American Gutter Protection installs micro-mesh gutter guards custom-fit to your gutters. They come in more than 30 color options to match your home’s aesthetic. All American also installs new gutters if your current ones aren’t in good condition.

Pros and Cons of All American Gutter Protection

Customized installation for each home 

30+ colors options available 

Ongoing discounts for military and seniors 

No DIY options

Service limited to 15 states

 

Key Features

  • Stainless steel guard material
  • Aluminum frame
  • Customizable sizes
  • More than 30 color options
  • Rustproof
  • Lifetime warranty

What Customers Are Saying

All American Gutter Protection has an average rating of 3.6 out of 5 stars on Yelp, Trustpilot, and other consumer review websites. The company is also BBB-accredited with an A+ rating.

Customers were pleased with the company’s professionalism. They said that the salespeople thoroughly explained the product, installation, and warranty and that the technicians installed the gutter guards in a timely manner. A handful of people experienced leaks or other issues after installation, though some customers noted that the company was willing to remedy them if contacted.

A-M Gutter Guard

A-M Gutter Guard’s covers have a screen that lays across the top of your gutters to prevent debris from reaching the bottom while allowing water to flow through. The screen also comes with a lifetime warranty that states A-M Gutter Guard will replace the product if it stops working at any time.

Pros and Cons of A-M Gutter Guard

Affordable, DIY option

Low-profile design that sits below the gutter edge 

Heavy aluminum is sturdy and rustproof   

Installation screws not included 

Smaller debris can slip through the filter

 

Key Features

  • Aluminum material
  • Five inches wide
  • Available in 23-, 50-, 100-, or 200-foot lengths
  • Rustproof
  • Lifetime warranty

What Customers Are Saying

More than 3,200 customers have reviewed this gutter guard on Amazon. It’s average rating is 4.7 out of 5 stars, with 94% of customers giving it an above-average rating. Nearly 80% of customers gave the product 5 stars and 15% gave it 4 stars

Several customers living in wooded areas said that this gutter guard kept leaves, twigs, and branches out of their gutters. However, some customers said that it required more maintenance than they expected. For example, the gutter guard formed a valley that collected debris and caused pine needles to get stuck in the holes, forcing customers to clean their gutters multiple times per year. (Most gutter guards require cleaning every one to two years).

 


 

Raptor

This micro-mesh gutter guard has ultra-tiny holes to keep out small debris such as seeds and pine needles. The mesh is made from stainless steel and is rust- and corrosion-resistant.

Pros and Cons of Raptor

DIY micro-mesh stainless steel guards

Various installation styles

25-year product warranty  

Guards can be hard to cut for installation

Smaller mesh holes can cause overflow issues

 

Key Features

  • Stainless steel material
  • 5, 6, or 7 inches wide
  • 48 feet long
  • Rustproof
  • 25-year warranty

What Customers Are Saying

More than 3,900 Amazon customers have reviewed this product. It has an average of 4.6 out of 5 stars, with 91% of customers rating it 4 or 5 stars.

Satisfied customers said that these gutter guards were easy to install because of their included instructions, drill bit head, and surplus of screws. The main complaint was that the holes in the mesh were so small they wouldn’t allow all of the water to pass through during a downpour, causing water to flow over the gutters instead.

 


 

GutterStuff

This gutter guard is a foam wedge. Its longest side goes into the gutter, while its shortest side lays across the top, leaving a triangle of open space at the bottom of the gutter where the water can flow through. The guard comes in three widths and four lengths.

Pros and Cons of GutterStuff

Germicide and UV protectant to prevent mold

Tools-free installation 

5-year warranty

Foam deteriorates quicker than other guard options

Freezing issues can occur during winter

 

Key Features

  • Foam material
  • 4, 5, and 6 inches wide
  • Available in 32-, 96-, 144-, or 192-foot lengths
  • 5-year warranty

What Customers Are Saying

These gutter guards have more than 550 customer reviews on Amazon. They have an average rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars, with 81% of customers leaving a 4- or 5-star review.

Most customers purchased these gutter guards because they were easy to install. It took only a few minutes for customers to climb a ladder and push the foam into their gutters. However, several customers said the foam either became soaked with water or filled with smaller pieces of debris.

 


 

Amerimax

This gutter guard is similar to Raptor’s micro-mesh guard except its holes are much bigger, minimizing water overflow. The Amerimax gutter guard comes in 3-foot long sections, but you can order various pack sizes to ensure you have enough guards to fill all of your gutters.

Pros and Cons of Amerimax

Easy to cut for customized fitting

Guards work with most gutter styles and sizes 

Rust-resistant 

Paint coating can cause overflow issues  

Small debris may still pass through

 

Key Features

  • Steel material
  • 4, 5, and 6 inches wide
  • 3 feet long
  • Available in multiple pack sizes
  • Rustproof
  • 10-year warranty

What Customers Are Saying

Amerimax’s guard has an average rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars from over more than 1,200 Amazon reviews, with 90% of customers giving it a 4- or 5-star review.

Though these guards can be challenging to install, customers said that they were easier than types that require fasteners and tools. Some reviews said that water rushed right over the gutter cover instead of going through it because of how slick the paint coating is on the steel.

 


 

GutterBrush

This gutter guard has plastic bristles wrapped in steel wire and slides directly into your gutter, blocking large debris from getting in while allowing water to seep through. Installation for this guard is quick and simple—it comes in 3-feet sections like the Amerimax mesh guard and easily slides into the gutter.

Pros and Cons of GutterBrush

Available through many retailers including Amazon, Home Depot, and Lowe’s

Quickest installation compared to other guards 

Universal fit with most gutter styles

Filters large debris only 

Frequent clogs

 

Key Features

  • Polypropylene bristle material
  • 5 inches wide
  • Available in 6-, 15-, 30-, 60-, or 120-foot lengths

What Customers Are Saying

About 750 customers have reviewed this guard on Amazon. It has a score of 4.4 out of 5 stars, with 85% of customers giving it 4 or 5 stars.

Customers were realistic about how well these gutter covers would work, understanding that they could only keep out large pieces of debris. Because of this, customers had to rinse smaller debris from the guards occasionally. Several customers complained the gutter guard didn’t work well in yards with a lot of trees and became clogged by leaves and twigs easily.

 


 

VIEW MORE

 


 

Types of Gutter Guards

There are many different types of gutter guards, from DIY brush guards to professionally installed micro-mesh. Here’s a breakdown of each kind and their pros and cons.

Screen

Screen gutter guards are installed by lifting the bottom row of roof shingles and sliding the edge of the screen underneath. They have large holes that keep out leaves and other large debris. Screen gutter guards are affordable and easy to install on your own, but they can blow off in windy conditions and become brittle over time.

Mesh

Mesh guards are typically made of metal or plastic and have small holes that filter water while blocking debris. They can be slipped under the bottom row of your roof shingles, snapped directly onto the top of the gutter, or attached to the fascia.

These gutter guards are slightly more expensive and difficult to install than screen guards, but their holes are usually smaller, preventing more debris from clogging your gutters. Some mesh gutter guard varieties are flimsy and can be easily torn or damaged by extreme weather conditions.

Micro-mesh

These are similar to mesh guards, using small holes to keep out debris and allow water to flow through. However, the holes on micro-mesh guards are much smaller, allowing them to keep out even small debris. They require professional installation and cost more than DIY gutter guards, but need less maintenance.

Reverse-curve/Surface tension

This type of gutter guard is made from metal or plastic. Unlike other gutter guards that allow water to flow through the gutter, this gutter guard forces water to flow over the gutter and around a downward curve before dropping into the gutter beneath. Leaves and debris slide off and onto the ground below.

Reverse-curve gutter guards are more difficult to install on your own because they have to be positioned at the same angle as your roof, which can be especially tricky for steep roofs. They’re also expensive and visible from the ground. However, they come in a variety of colors and keep out most debris, even in the toughest of weather conditions.

Brush

Brush gutter guards resemble large pipe cleaners that fit into your gutter. When these guards are in place, large debris collects on top and water trickles down and out through the gutter spout. While this type of gutter guard is easy to install, small debris such as pine needles can easily get stuck in the bristles, forcing you to completely remove the gutter guard to shake those pieces out.

Foam

Foam guards are another inexpensive and easy-to-install DIY option. They require sticking a wedge of foam into the gutter to keep out large debris. However, debris can easily build up on top of the gutter guards instead of inside of the gutters, and they have to be completely removed to clean.

 


 

Buying Guide

Consider the following factors before buying gutter guards.

Warranty

This refers to both your roof warranty and your gutter guard warranty. Your roof comes with a warranty that lasts 20–50 years. However, you could potentially void your warranty if you purchase a gutter guard that requires you to lift up the bottom row of your roof shingles.

DIY gutter guards, such as foam and brush guards, don’t typically come with a warranty because they’re designed to be a temporary solution. Professionally installed guards, such as micro-mesh ones, usually come with a warranty that lasts multiple years.

Installation

Decide if you want a temporary gutter guard with easy installation or a high-quality, permanent solution that requires professional help.

Size

Gutters are most commonly 5 or 6 inches, though 7-inch gutters are sometimes used in locations with heavy rainfall. Measure your gutters before buying a gutter guard to ensure it will fit properly.

Appearance

Choose a guard that can’t be seen from the ground or that comes in a wide range of colors to match your home’s exterior if curb appeal is important to you.

 


 

Our Conclusion

The best gutter guards provide efficient filtration and protect your home from possible water damage. Though gutter guards don’t completely eliminate the need for cleaning, they do reduce the frequency. We recommend LeafFilter as our top pick for the best professional installation. HomeCraft also tops our list thanks to its innovative diamond-raised technology. Finally, American Gutter Protection is a great option for a custom-fitted guard system with a large variety of colors to match your home. 

We recommend comparing at least three different gutter guards to find the right option for your gutter system. Use the tool below to find the best gutter guard experts in your area.

 


 

Frequently Asked Questions

 

Why Trust The This Old House Reviews Team

This Old House has empowered homeowners for more than four decades with top-notch home improvement content in the form of television programs, print media, and digital content on its website and social media platforms. The This Old House Reviews Team focuses on creating in-depth product and service review content to help inform your purchasing decision for just about any item or resource that you might need for your home. The This Old House Reviews Team has written over 1,000 reviews on products in the home space, from cordless drills to kitchen trash cans, lawn mowers, leaf guards for gutters, and dining room decorations.

We recommend products in each review using an intensive research process, spending hours combing through the best available models on Amazon. For a product to make our list of top picks, it must hold a solid sales record on Amazon, have consistently positive customer reviews, and offer unique features, among other factors. After narrowing down our list of recommendations, we conduct additional research and sometimes in-person testing to ensure that the products meet our standards. Once we conclude the research phase, we craft a well-rounded, user-friendly article that includes our recommended products and additional information to help homeowners like you make the right purchase.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.