clock menu more-arrow no yes
SimpliSafe home security device Courtesy SimpliSafe

ADT Home Security has long been a major name in home security, but you may have heard a lot about SimpliSafe in recent years. Both companies offer a similar range of home security and smart home equipment, but their business models work very differently.

Keep reading this SimpliSafe vs. ADT comparison to decide which is the best home security for your home.

Here’s our comparison of ADT Home Security and SimpliSafe, including their plans, costs, and equipment. We break down the differences between the two home security companies and make recommendations on who might benefit most from each one.

ADT vs. Simplisafe: Side-by-Side Comparison

Factor ADT SimpliSafe
Factor ADT SimpliSafe
This Old House Score 9.1 / 10 9.9 / 10
24/7 Monitoring ✔ Included ✔ Available
Contract Length 36 months 1 month
Installation Professional DIY or professional
Mobile App Access
Motion Detection
Smart Home Compatibility
Video Surveillance Available With SimpliCam purchase
Video Streaming Capability Available With SimpliCam purchase
Money-Back Guarantee 6 months (installation and monitoring fees)* 60 days
BBB Rating A+ A+

*Certain restrictions apply

SimpliSafe vs. ADT Overview

SimpliSafe Overview

SimpliSafe is a relative newcomer to the home security industry, and it offers a different paradigm from traditional companies like ADT. The founders of SimpliSafe couldn’t find a good security solution for renters, so they pioneered their own wireless hardware that’s easy to install and remove.

Here are a few SimpliSafe benefits:

  • Clear and inexpensive pricing
  • Portable equipment
  • No long-term contract required for professional monitoring services

ADT Overview

ADT Home Security is one of the most experienced and best home security companies in the industry. Originally founded as a telegraph company, the business expanded into security alarms in the early decades of the 20th century, and it now serves over six million homes throughout the United States.

Here are some top selling points of ADT-Monitored Home Security from Protect Your Home:

  • Longevity and a good reputation in the industry
  • ADT has the largest nationwide network of monitoring centers
  • Six-month money-back guarantee on installation and monitoring fees*

*Certain restrictions apply.

SimpliSafe vs. ADT Packages

SimpliSafe Packages

Feature The Foundation Package The Essentials Package The Hearth Package The Knox Package The Haven Package
Feature The Foundation Package The Essentials Package The Hearth Package The Knox Package The Haven Package
Base Station
Keypad
Entry Sensor ✔ 1 included ✔ 3 included ✔ 3 included ✔ 6 included ✔ 4 included
Motion Sensor ✔ 1 included ✔ 1 included ✔ 1 included ✔ 2 included ✔ 2 included
Siren - -
Key Fob - -
Smoke Detector - -
Panic Button - - - -
Temperature Sensor - - - -
Water Sensor - - - -

SimpliSafe offers five equipment packages, ranging from the basics to a full smart home suite. You can learn more about these packages on the company’s website.

Once you buy the equipment, you can choose to monitor it yourself, using it as a simple alarm system with no monthly fees. SimpliSafe also offers two professional monitoring options:

  • The Standard Plan connects the base station to a monitoring center.
  • The Interactive Plan gives you full control over the system with the mobile app, alert notifications, and the ability to stream video camera footage.

ADT Packages

Feature "The Essentials" Package "ADT Pulse® Remote" Package "ADT Pulse® + Video" Package "ADT Pulse® Home Automation + Video" Package
Feature "The Essentials" Package "ADT Pulse® Remote" Package "ADT Pulse® + Video" Package "ADT Pulse® Home Automation + Video" Package
Keypad panel
Motion sensor
Remote keyfob
Life Safety Equipment
Wireless door and window sensors
Mobile app integration
Indoor camera
Outdoor camera
Doorbell camera
Smart lock
Smart plug

ADT-Monitored Home Security from Protect Your Home bundles its equipment and monitoring services together. If you want the hardware, you’ll need to pay for 24/7 professional monitoring.

Customer’s can get a quote and learn about plans by filling out a quick form or by calling 855-388-0208. All plans include the following items:

  • Digital control panel
  • Entry sensors
  • Wireless keychain remote
  • Motion detectors
  • 24/7 professional monitoring
  • Yard signs and window decals

Additionally, Protect Your Home offers a variety of upgraded equipment depending on your security needs:

SimpliSafe vs. ADT Pricing

SimpliSafe Pricing

Pricing "The Foundation" Package "The Essentials" Package "The Hearth" Package "The Knox" Package "The Haven" Package
Pricing "The Foundation" Package "The Essentials" Package "The Hearth" Package "The Knox" Package "The Haven" Package
Equipment Cost $229.00 $259.00 $374.00 $449.00 $489.00

You can purchase SimpliSafe security hardware on its own, but the company offers a 20% discount if you sign up for professional monitoring at the same time. With any of these packages, the Standard Plan is $14.99 a month and the Interactive Plan is $24.99 a month. This monitoring fee is paid month-to-month and can be cancelled anytime; there is no long-term contract required.

ADT Pricing

Pricing "The Essentials" Package "ADT Remote" Package "ADT Video Lite" Package "ADT Video + Home Automation" Package
Pricing "The Essentials" Package "ADT Remote" Package "ADT Video Lite" Package "ADT Video + Home Automation" Package
Weekly Cost $7/week $13/week $15/week $15/week
Monthly Cost $27.99/month $53.99/month $59.99/month 59.99/month

ADT-Monitored Home Security costs $99.00 for base package installation for qualified customers, but upgraded packages will require additional installation fees; additional fees may apply for customers requiring a cellular system. Monthly monitoring prices range between $36.99–$59.99 with credit card or automatic bank withdrawal.

SimpliSafe vs. ADT: How Does It Work?

How Does SimpliSafe Work?

SimpliSafe systems can all be purchased online or over the phone. You choose the equipment you need and have it delivered to your door. While the equipment should be easy to install on your own, SimpliSafe does offer professional installation, as well.

Learn more about installation options by visiting SimpliSafe’s website.

How Does ADT Home Security Work?

After you speak to a sales representative and purchase a plan, a professional will come to your house to install the system. The technician will help you set up and test your system, after which you’ll be able to operate everything from the control panel and, for many systems, the mobile app. Note: Protect Your Home doesn’t offer a self-installation option.

Our Conclusion

ADT-Monitored Home Security and SimpliSafe are both excellent choices for home security. SimpliSafe may be best for people who want a DIY, portable security system, those who are on a budget, or renters, considering the company has a la carte options and requires long-term contract.

Alternatively, ADT-Monitored Home Security from Protect Your Home is probably the best choice for homeowners who want a traditional, professionally monitored home security system and have a little extra room in their budget. Protect Your Home monitoring prices tend to be on the high side, but you’ll get an established name with a nationwide resource network.

This Old House readers can view plans and get a free quote for ADT-Monitored Home Security from Protect Your Home by completing a quick form or by calling 855-388-0208. You can also learn more about SimpliSafe’s plans on the company’s website.

SimpliSafe vs. ADT: Similarities & Differences

SimpliSafe & ADT Similarities

While ADT-Monitored Home Security and SimpliSafe tackle home security very differently, they are still similar in some ways. Both offer the latest technology in home security equipment, including sensors, security cameras, smoke and flood detectors, and more. Both also allow you to control your entire home security system via mobile app, as well as receive alerts and stream video.

SimpliSafe & ADT Differences

Factor ADT SimpliSafe
Factor ADT SimpliSafe
Connectivity options Cellular, broadband, and landline monitoring options Cellular, broadband, and landline monitoring options
Wireless options Wired or wireless Wireless
Contract 3-year contract required on professionally installed systems Month-to-month payments for monitoring
Self-monitoring option Unavailable Available

More on Home Security Systems

Our Rating Methodology

The This Old House Reviews Team is committed to providing comprehensive and unbiased reviews to our readers. This means earning your trust through transparent reviews and having the data to back up our ratings and recommendations. Our rating system for home security providers is on a 100-point scale based on 10 factors:

  • Number of systems (5)
  • Special features (10)
  • Installation options (5)
  • Connectivity and smart home automation (15)
  • Pricing (15)
  • Contract period (5)
  • Warranty (15)
  • Trial period (15)
  • Usability (5)
  • Trustworthiness (10)

Our team reviewed 32 companies and spent 744 hours researching and testing out products to help us compare home security systems on key factors such as package options, cost, reliability, and ease of use. Read more on our methodology here.

*Money Back guarantee only applies after ADT has made attempts to resolve a system related issue and has not been able to resolve that issue within the first six months of your contract. Equipment must be fully removed before a refund will be processed. Conditions preventing normal system operation cannot be caused by the customer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do Protect Your Home and SimpliSafe provide professional installation services?

All ADT-monitored systems from Protect Your Home require installation by a professional. SimpliSafe’s security equipment is designed to be self-installable, but the company does offer professional installation for a separate fee.

Do Protect Your Home and SimpliSafe require contracts?

ADT-Monitored Home Security from Protect Your Home requires a 36-month contract for its equipment and professional monitoring options. SimpliSafe’s equipment must be paid for upfront, but its monitoring services don’t require a long-term contract.

What types of packages do SimpliSafe and Protect Your Home provide?

ADT-Monitored Home Security from Protect Your Home provides four different packages, while SimpliSafe offers five packages based on the size of your home and the amount of equipment you need, as well as two monitoring plans.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.