We may be compensated if you purchase through links on our website. Our Reviews Team is committed to delivering honest, objective, and independent reviews on home products and services.More

American Home Guard Review

American Home Guard was a home warranty company that closed down in 2018. Keep reading this review to learn which top home warranty alternatives we recommend.

Author Image Written by Dana Getz + 1 other Reviewer Icon Reviewed by Jacquelyn Kfoury Updated 06/20/2024

American Home Guard was a Pennsylvania-based company that opened in 2013 and shut its doors abruptly in 2018 after a flood of complaints and negative reviews revealed the company to be a scam. Customers who had committed to policies before American Home Guard closed were unable to successfully contact the company or receive refunds. This is a worst-case scenario for home warranty customers.

Choosing a home warranty company that’s trustworthy can be challenging, especially if you’ve never bought one before. To help you out, we did the work for you—we’ve reviewed a variety of recommended home warranty providers and selected ones that offer comprehensive coverage, have affordable plans, and provide quality customer service. Liberty Home Guard is our top pick because of its extensive list of more than 40 add-ons and its high customer ratings on independent review sites such as BBB—the highest scores of any home warranty provider we’ve reviewed.

This review will dive into American Home Guard’s reputation, plans, and customer ratings and offer alternative home warranty companies to homeowners looking for coverage.


Top-Rated Home Warranty Picks

Since American Home Guard is no longer in business, here are our top-rated home warranty alternatives.

Star Rating BBB Rating Monthly Cost Service Fee Response Time Link
Liberty Home Guard Liberty Home Guard
NR $49–$59 $65–$125 Up to 48 hours VISIT SITE
American Home Shield American Home Shield
B $29–$89 $100–$125 Up to 48 hours VISIT SITE
Select Home Warranty Select Home Warranty
B- $44–$47 $60–$75 48-84 hours VISIT SITE
First American Home Warranty First American Home Warranty
B $42–$82 $75–$125 4-48 hours VISIT SITE
AFC Home Warranty AFC Home Warranty
B $35–$94 $75–$125 24-48 hours VISIT SITE
Elite Home Warranty Elite Home Warranty
A+ $44–$58 $70 Up to 48 hours VISIT SITE
Cinch Home Services Cinch Home Services
B+ $30–$56 $100–$150 2-24 hours VISIT SITE
2-10 Home Buyers Warranty 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty
A $27–$70 $65–$100 Up to 48 hours VISIT SITE
Liberty Home Guard
Logo Liberty Home Guard
Star Rating
BBB Rating NR
Monthly Cost $49–$59
Service Fee $65–$125
Response Time Up to 48 hours
VISIT SITE
American Home Shield
Logo American Home Shield
Star Rating
BBB Rating B
Monthly Cost $29–$89
Service Fee $100–$125
Response Time Up to 48 hours
VISIT SITE
Select Home Warranty
Logo Select Home Warranty
Star Rating
BBB Rating B-
Monthly Cost $44–$47
Service Fee $60–$75
Response Time 48-84 hours
VISIT SITE
First American Home Warranty
Logo First American Home Warranty
Star Rating
BBB Rating B
Monthly Cost $42–$82
Service Fee $75–$125
Response Time 4-48 hours
VISIT SITE
AFC Home Warranty
Logo AFC Home Warranty
Star Rating
BBB Rating B
Monthly Cost $35–$94
Service Fee $75–$125
Response Time 24-48 hours
VISIT SITE
Elite Home Warranty
Logo Elite Home Warranty
Star Rating
BBB Rating A+
Monthly Cost $44–$58
Service Fee $70
Response Time Up to 48 hours
VISIT SITE
Cinch Home Services
Logo Cinch Home Services
Star Rating
BBB Rating B+
Monthly Cost $30–$56
Service Fee $100–$150
Response Time 2-24 hours
VISIT SITE
2-10 Home Buyers Warranty
Logo 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty
Star Rating
BBB Rating A
Monthly Cost $27–$70
Service Fee $65–$100
Response Time Up to 48 hours
VISIT SITE
Company BBB Rating Monthly Cost Service Fee Visit Site
NR $49–$59 $65–$125 VISIT SITE
B $29–$89 $100–$125 VISIT SITE
B- $44–$47 $60–$75 VISIT SITE
B $42–$82 $75–$125 VISIT SITE
B $35–$94 $75–$125 VISIT SITE
A+ $44–$58 $70 VISIT SITE
B+ $30–$56 $100–$150 VISIT SITE
A $27–$70 $65–$100 VISIT SITE
No results were found.

Preferred Provider: Liberty Home Guard

Unlike American Home Guard, Liberty Home Guard is a reputable business that offers quality services and a wide range of plans. Additionally, while American Home Guard offered coverage in only 38 states, Liberty Home Guard provides coverage in all 50 states. You can learn more in our expert review of Liberty Home Guard.

Liberty Home Guard offers generous coverage limits of $2,000 for most essential systems and appliances and 42 unique add-on options so you can customize your plan. It also boasts the highest customer review scores across third-party review sites of any home warranty company we’ve reviewed.

To get a free quote from Liberty Home Guard, call 866-452-9107 or fill out a simple online form with your zip code.


American Home Shield

American Home Shield (AHS), not to be confused with American Home Guard, is a veteran in the home warranty industry and one of the best home warranty companies available. AHS offers three coverage options—ShieldSilver™, ShieldGold™, and ShieldPlatinum™—with plans ranging between $40-$58 a month.

American Home Shield is ideal for those who want to customize their coverage, have generous coverage caps, and receive 24/7 customer service. AHS may not be a good option for you if you want to choose your own technician or live in Alaska.

Get a free AHS quote by filling out this online form or by calling 844-529-9298.


First American Home Warranty

First American (FAHW) offers two coverage plans and has been a leader in the home warranty industry for over 35 years. What distinguishes it from other home warranty companies is its First Class Upgrade optional coverage, which covers systems and appliances if they were improperly installed, maintained, or modified.

First American may be a good choice for people who own an older home and are unsure about their system and appliance health. It may not be the best option if you own a new home with brand new appliances and systems that are covered under a manufacturer’s warranty.

Get a free FAHW quote by filling out this online form or by calling 800-891-9778.


American Home Guard Reviews

American Home Guard had very negative customer reviews on its Better Business Bureau (BBB) page. In 2017, the BBB identified a pattern of complaints against the company. American Home Guard never resolved the underlying problems that upset customers.

Here are a few reviews from American Home Guard customers:

This company denied my claim because they said they don’t cover electrical. What?!!! My AC quit working in the summer heat of Florida and I had a licensed contractor affidavit that the issue was NOT electrical even though there is no indication that electrical is not covered. Run from this Company, RUN!” — Larry C. on 1/17/2017

Total scam!!! Was offered a discounted warranty but was never sent a confirmation or any policy. After multiple attempts and layers of false statements promising to send the policy, it to date has never arrived. This goes back to May of 2018. It is now August 29. These people are professional scammers. Buyer beware! Have filed [a] dispute with MasterCard.” — Boze on 8/29/2018


American Home Guard Warranty Plans and Pricing

American Home Guard offered three coverage plans: one for systems, one for appliances, and a comprehensive plan, plus optional add-ons. Since the company has closed, plans and cost breakdowns are no longer available.


Our Rating Methodology

The This Old House Reviews Team backs up our home warranty ratings and recommendations with a detailed rating methodology to objectively score each provider. We conduct research by speaking with company representatives, requesting quotes, analyzing sample contracts from each company, and conducting focus groups and consumer surveys. We then score each provider against our review standards for coverage, value, trustworthiness and transparency, availability, and customer service to arrive at a final score on a 5-point rating scale. 

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.