Leaf Solution vs. LeafFilter (2024)
Compare quotes from local gutter experts
Join the 6,755 people who have received a free, no-obligation quote in the last 30 days
Written by
Choosing the right gutter guard can make all the difference in keeping your gutter system clean and flowing smoothly. There are many gutter guard brands to choose from, and some are of higher quality than others. We’ve researched the best gutter guard brands on the market and identified Leaf Solution and LeafFilter as two solid choices. To help you decide which of these gutter guards is right for your home, we’ve analyzed their product designs, performance, price, history, and customer reviews in this review.
How Do Leaf Solution and LeafFilter Compare?
Both LeafFilter and Leaf Solution provide high-quality gutter guards composed of a stainless steel micro-mesh set inside durable aluminum frames. However, there are distinct differences between these two popular gutter guards.
Leaf Solution provides a small selection of options for gutter guard installations, whereas LeafFilter focuses on a single, well-honed product. Leaf Solution’s warranty lasts 20 years compared to LeafFilter’s limited lifetime warranty. While Leaf Solution has been around longer, its brand presence isn’t as well established as LeafFilter. We compare these and other differences in the table below.
| Provider | Leaf Solution | LeafFilter |
|---|---|---|
|
Gutter Guard Design |
Stainless steel “hemmed” micro-mesh |
Stainless steel micro-mesh |
|
Warranty |
20-year |
Limited lifetime |
|
Pricing |
Price not listed on website |
$3,000 – $6,800 |
|
State Availability |
State availability is not listed on website; representative stated that products are sold through vendors in all 50 states and parts of Canada |
47 (all but Alaska, Hawaii, South Dakota, and Vermont) |
|
Year Founded |
2002 |
2005 |
|
BBB Score* |
N/A |
A+ |
*BBB ratings are accurate as of February 2024.
What Are the Features of Leaf Solution and LeafFilter?
Leaf Solutions was founded in 2002 as an innovative approach to gutter cover design. Leaf Solution gutter guards have a stainless steel “hemmed mesh” screen set with indentations along the length and fitted into a heavy-duty aluminum frame. This creates a strong gutter guard that stands the test of time, which Leaf Solution backs up with a 20-year product warranty.
Leaf Solution offers three products to give customers more options for their gutter protection. The first is its standard Leaf Solution or Evelyn’s Leaf Solution gutter guard, followed by the Xtreme gutter guard and the New Wave gutter guard. Here’s a more in-depth look at these products:
- Leaf Solution gutter guard: This is the standard gutter guard offered by Leaf Solution. It uses a surgical-grade stainless steel micro-mesh with a triple-dip capillary diverter. This design slows water flow atop the gutters, capturing more rainwater and preventing clogs—even during heavy downpours. This mesh is hemmed into an aluminum frame, making it sturdy and resistant to dislodging. It comes in 5- or 6-inch-wide, 5-foot-long panels, allowing it to fit over most gutter systems.
- Xtreme gutter guard: This model is similar to the standard model but with a sleeker design and larger screen openings. These alterations allow the Leaf Solution’s Xtreme gutter guard to repel larger debris while letting in more water. Leaf Solution states this model of gutter guard can withstand up to 60 gallons of water per minute. However, the larger gaps in the mesh may allow smaller particles, such as shingle grit or sediment, to bypass the guard.
- New Wave gutter guard: The New Wave guard is Leaf Solution’s cost-effective option for gutter protection. Unlike the standard and Xtreme guards that use a stainless steel mesh and frame system, the New Wave gutter guard is a single sheet of rigid gauge aluminum that screws directly into the gutter. This aluminum sheet is perforated with teardrop-shaped holes that allow water passage but block larger debris such as leaves, sticks, roof shingles, and pinecones. These guards don’t stop smaller debris, such as shingle grit, insects, or pine needles, from making their way inside your gutters.
LeafFilter is one of the premier gutter guard brands. It handles the entire process, from the initial inspection and quote to placing the guards on your gutter system. In addition to its gutter guard services, it handles gutter installations and repairs. This suite of services makes it an excellent choice for homes that lack gutter systems.
LeafFilter stands behind the quality of its gutter guards, offering a limited lifetime warranty on all parts of the system. If any part of the gutter guard system fails, either from a product fault or improper installation, it’s covered by the warranty. LeafFilter’s warranty does not cover any damage to the gutter system or surrounding structures. Additionally, the warranty can become void if the guard is damaged by structural changes to the house or random acts of nature.
The LeafFilter gutter guard is a stainless steel micro-mesh gutter guard set into an unplasticized polyvinyl chloride (uPVC) frame via a series of hidden hangers. Here is a quick rundown of this three-piece system:
- Micro-mesh: LeafFilter gutter guards use a 275-micron micro-mesh screen made from surgical-grade stainless steel. This corrosion-resistant screen is fine enough to keep small debris, such as shingle grit, pine needles, and pollen, out of your gutter systems while letting water pass through.
- uPVC frame: The uPVC frame is installed with a built-in pitch, allowing heavy debris to slide off more easily. This frame is heavy-duty and warp-resistant while also being lightweight and durable.
- Hidden hangers: These small brackets sit within the gutter and connect the system to your fascia board.
How Much Do Leaf Solution and LeafFilter Cost?
Both Leaf Solution and LeafFilter are professionally installed only, meaning you must go through certified suppliers to get them. Like any home improvement project, a professional installation will be more expensive than a DIY one.
Leaf Solution Cost
To get a quote from Leaf Solution, call the provider or head to its website and fill out a form. Leaf Solution will connect you with a local certified installer. From there, you’ll schedule an appointment for a quote detailing the installation’s exact cost. Due to its work with third-party contractors, Leaf Solution does not supply direct pricing information on its website.
LeafFilter Cost
LeafFilter does not have options for DIY installation but doesn’t require you to go through a third-party installer. Instead, LeafFilter handles all its installations, taking care of projects from the initial consultation to the final day on the job. Like Leaf Solution, LeafFilter does not provide pricing information on its website. From our research, we estimate that LeafFilter costs can range between $3,000 and $6,800, depending on the scope of the project.
Fill out this form if you want a free quote from LeafFilter.
What Do Customers Say About Leaf Solution and LeafFilter?
Sites such as the Better Business Bureau (BBB), Yelp, and Google can provide valuable information regarding a company’s quality and performance. Even well-established brands like LeafFilter may have branch locations with mixed customer reviews. We searched for reviews on third-party sites to compare LeafFilter and Leaf Solution on customer experience.
“Knowledgeable sales rep and quick installation of quality product. I now feel much safer knowing that my home is not going to be compromised due to old worn out gutter product that was in place when I purchased the home.” — Terri, July 13, 2023, on BBB
“Scheduled estimate. Showed up, signed contract, had install date. Then called, needed more pictures and finally was told can’t do the job because they had to walk on the roof and they would tear it up. Not sure why my metal roof is different from other metal roofs. Talk about a runaround. Would not recommend just because of shady business practices like this.” — David B, July 4, 2023, on BBB
Should You Choose LeafFilter or Leaf Solution?
Leaf Solution and LeafFilter offer similar products, but key details set them apart. LeafFilter screens have a tighter mesh, especially compared to the standard Leaf Solution gutter guard. This means LeafFilter may be better able to keep out smaller particles. Leaf Solution’s guards filter 60 gallons per minute, which could make them a good choice for areas with heavy rainfall. If you want the peace of mind of a lifetime warranty, LeafFilter is an excellent choice.
LeafFilter and Leaf Solution offer high-quality products, but we recommend getting quotes from at least three providers before booking. Request free quotes from our top picks below to learn more and set pricing expectations.
FAQ About Gutter Guard Companies
What is the downside of LeafFilter?
The biggest downside to LeafFilter is that you need to clean your gutters after installing them. While LeafFilter makes cleaning gutters easier and reduces the number of times you need to clean them, it doesn’t eliminate the need for gutter cleaning altogether. We recommend cleaning your gutters once every year or two.
What is the difference between LeafFilter and Leaf Solution?
LeafFilter and Leaf Solution are similar but have a number of key differences. LeafFilter provides a single product, while Leaf Solution offers multiple gutter guard systems. LeafFilter also offers gutter repair and replacement services, while Leaf Solution is only a gutter guard supplier.
How much does LeafFilter cost?
LeafFilter does not list prices on its site. After thoroughly researching customer reviews, we estimate LeafFilter gutter guards installation costs $2,000 and $9,900 per project.
How does LeafFilter work?
LeafFilter uses a 275-micron stainless steel micro-mesh screen and a sloped uPVC frame. This system works by creating a barrier that keeps even the smallest debris, such as shingle grit and pine needles, out of your gutters. The steep angle of the frame allows water flow and surface tension to push the debris off the gutter guards. Together, these systems create an impressive filter that stops the buildup of gunk in your gutters and downspouts, preventing water damage
Our Rating Methodology
We back up our gutter guard recommendations with a detailed rating methodology to objectively score each gutter guard product and provider. We conduct research by reviewing product specifications and provider website information, speaking with customer representatives, and analyzing customer reviews. We then score each provider against our review standards for gutter guard design, customer support, the quote process, services, and reviews to arrive at a final score on a 5-point rating scale.
To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.