Choosing between Pella and Andersen windows depends on what works best with your home’s design, project budget, and installation requirements. Andersen offers durable, energy-efficient windows with professional installation through Renewal by Andersen. Pella stands out for its high-end design flexibility, modern features, and wider range of shopping options, including online and showroom purchases.
Our guide compares both brands based on cost, materials, warranties, and customer satisfaction to help you choose the right fit for your home.
Key Takeaways
- Andersen has five durable window frame materials for long-term strength, while Pella provides three materials with greater design flexibility. Both brands offer 14 window styles to suit a range of home designs.
- Andersen windows typically cost $200–$1,200 per window, while Pella windows range from $150–$1,800, according to pricing from the Home Depot and Lowe’s.
- Andersen fits homeowners focused on window durability and value, while Pella appeals to those seeking customization and high-end style.
Renewal by Andersen
Buy One Window or Door, Get One 40% Off
Pros and Cons
What We Liked
- Features proprietary window frame material that is stronger and more durable than vinyl
- Includes a transferable 20-year warranty on glass and a 10-year warranty on non-glass materials
- Provides full-service window replacement services
Keep in Mind
- Doesn’t sell aluminum, fiberglass, or wood frame windows
- Provides fewer window styles than other brands
Window Styles Offered
Renewal by Andersen offers up to eight window styles, which you can customize to fit your home’s aesthetic. Here is the full list of window styles Renewal by Andersen offers:
- Specialty
- Awning
- Bay
- Bow
- Casement
- Double-hung
- Picture
- Sliding
Is Pella or Andersen Better?
When comparing Pella and Andersen windows, the better choice depends on your design, budget, and installation preferences. Andersen is ideal for homeowners who want durable, high-performing windows and professional installation through the company’s Renewal by Andersen division. The company offers five frame materials and delivers long-term value across multiple window series. Although Andersen windows can cost more to install than some other options, and the company has mixed customer reviews, the brand remains a reliable choice for homeowners focused on quality and longevity.
Pella, on the other hand, is a strong option for homeowners who value design flexibility and the convenience of online ordering. The company stands out for its variety of styles and finishes. Pella offers three frame materials, including fiberglass, wood, and vinyl, as well as 14 window styles available through its website, Lowe’s, and local dealers. While Pella has slightly shorter warranties and reviews note occasional service inconsistencies, its smart-home integration features and modern designs make it a favorite among homeowners who want customization and convenience.
Choose Andersen if You:
- Want a full-service installation experience managed from start to finish
- Prefer more frame material options and higher durability across different climates
- Prioritize long-term reliability and a professional installation process
Choose Pella if You:
- Want to customize window styles and finishes for greater design flexibility
- Prefer the convenience of online ordering and nationwide availability
- Value smart-home integration and contemporary styling
What Types of Windows Do Pella and Andersen Offer?
Both Pella and Andersen offer a wide selection of window types and product lines that can suit different budgets and home designs. Andersen provides a broader material range, while Pella focuses on craftsmanship and high-end finishes.
Pella Window Options
Pella has seven window series made from fiberglass, wood, and vinyl. The company’s premium Reserve and Architect lines emphasize detailed wood craftsmanship, while the Lifestyle and Impervia collections balance performance and design flexibility. The 250 Series, 350 Series, and Encompass lines offer durable, low-maintenance vinyl options. Pella has 14 window styles, from standard double-hung and casement models to custom and specialty shapes.
Andersen Window Options
Andersen offers six window series made from wood, composite, aluminum, fiberglass, and vinyl. The 200 Series targets budget buyers, while the 100, 400, A-Series, and E-Series add customization and premium design options. Renewal by Andersen focuses on replacement windows built with Fibrex composite for long-term durability. Andersen also offers 14 window styles, similar to Pella, with a slightly wider range of material options.
Overall, Andersen has a wider range of materials and storm window options, while Pella stands out for its refined wood options, detailed finishes, and versatile design choices.
Window Style Comparison
The table below shows the available window styles each brand offers.
| Window Type | Andersen | Pella |
|---|---|---|
| Awning | ✔ | ✔ |
| Bay | ✔ | ✔ |
| Bow | ✔ | ✔ |
| Casement | ✔ | ✔ |
| Custom | ✔ | ✔ |
| Double-hung | ✔ | ✔ |
| Hopper | — | ✔ |
| Hurricane | ✔ | ✔ |
| Pass-through | ✔ | ✔ |
| Picture | ✔ | ✔ |
| Single-hung | ✔ | ✔ |
| Skylight | — | — |
| Sliding | ✔ | ✔ |
| Specialty | ✔ | ✔ |
| Storm | ✔ | — |
| Transom | ✔ | ✔ |
How Much Does Pella and Andersen Cost?
The cost difference between Pella and Andersen windows largely depends on the level of customization and materials you choose. Andersen is generally more affordable, providing durable, high-quality windows at a moderate price point. You’ll pay more for Pella windows, but that higher price reflects the company’s wide range of design options and luxury look.
While researching both companies, we found some online pricing available. Andersen doesn’t list prices directly on its website, but you can find detailed pricing through Home Depot’s online catalog. Pella, on the other hand, lists pricing for select models on its own site and through Lowe’s.
If keeping replacement window costs manageable is your top priority, Andersen is the better choice for overall value. Pella is worth considering if you prefer more design options and high-end finishes, even at a higher price point.
The table below shows the average cost that each brand charges for several popular window types.
| Window Type | Andersen Cost Range | Pella Cost Range |
|---|---|---|
| Casement | $400–$1,200 | $450–$1,800 |
| Double-hung | $250–$1,100 | $200–$1,200 |
| Sliding | $200–$1,000 | $150–$1,300 |
| Single-hung | $300–$950 | $300–$1,100 |
To provide context beyond retail pricing, we surveyed 1,000 homeowners in 2025 who replaced their windows within the past five years. On average, respondents spent $7,586 on Andersen windows and $8,506 on Pella installations. These findings suggest that Andersen typically offers more budget-friendly options, while Pella’s higher pricing often reflects greater customization and premium finishes.
Comparing Pella vs. Andersen Warranty Coverage
Both Pella and Andersen offer comprehensive window warranties that cover materials, hardware, glass, and labor across their product lines. Each company clearly lists its warranty terms online, making it easy for homeowners to review coverage details before purchase. Both warranties are transferable, allowing coverage to continue if you sell your home after replacing the windows.
Andersen Warranty
Andersen’s window warranty website lists the terms and conditions for each door and window the company offers.
Andersen provides long-lasting coverage that varies slightly by product series, but warranties generally include:
- A 20-year glass warranty
- A 20-year exterior color finish warranty
- A 10-year hardware and nonglass warranty
- A 2-year labor warranty
Pella Warranty
Like Andersen, Pella has a dedicated page for its window warranties online.
Pella’s warranty coverage is similar to Andersen’s, with additional protection for certain materials and finishes. Coverage includes:
- A 20-year glass warranty
- A 10-year exterior powder coat finish warranty
- A 10-year fiberglass frame warranty
- A 10-year hardware and nonglass warranty
- A 2-year interior factory finish
- A 2-year labor warranty
Comparing Pella vs. Andersen Warranties
Both brands offer strong coverage, but Andersen gives you longer protection for exterior finishes, while Pella adds extra coverage for fiberglass frames and interior finishes. If you prioritize long-term exterior durability, you may prefer Andersen. If you’re purchasing fiberglass or wood windows, you’ll likely get more value from Pella’s added finish warranties.
Our Experience Shopping for Pella and Andersen Windows Online
According to our 2025 windows survey, nearly 73% of homeowners researched window companies online before buying, either through the brand’s website or customer review platforms. To better understand the buying experience, we looked at each company’s website ourselves and compared what we found.
Online Shopping
Pella offers homeowners several ways to shop for windows. You can buy directly through its website, visit a Pella showroom to see samples in person, or purchase through Lowe’s. The company’s site makes it easy to shop by window style or material, and an online quiz helps narrow down the best match for your home. Pella also includes a “Window Inspiration” gallery and a virtual design tool that lets you upload a photo of your house and preview how new windows will look before you buy.
During our testing, we started by choosing a double-hung window and found the process straightforward. You can customize almost every detail, including the glass type, interior and exterior finishes, color, energy efficiency features, and smart upgrades, and see updates live as you make changes. You can also choose between replacement or new construction installations.
Andersen’s website offers a similar interactive experience but takes a more guided approach. Its design tool helps you compare product lines based on your project type, preferred materials, and even local climate. You can also look at extensive photo galleries for design inspiration and see completed projects that fit your home’s style.
Like Pella, Andersen allows you to customize window features like the size and glass type with a live visual preview. However, unlike Pella, you can’t check out or save your custom design for later. Instead, you will get directed to connect with an Andersen representative to complete your purchase. While this limits the full online buying experience, Andersen’s detailed guidance makes it a strong resource for homeowners still exploring their options.
Requesting a Consultation
When requesting a consultation with Pella, you start by entering your project details, including your address. From there, the site takes you to an interactive calendar that shows available appointment dates and times. We were offered four weeks of scheduling options, with time slots in the morning, afternoon, and evening. The final step asks for your contact information and a short project description. The ability to book an appointment instantly is a standout feature, as most companies only provide a submission form and require customers to wait for a callback to schedule.
Pella says that its consultations last about 90 minutes and include reviewing design options like materials and colors, taking window measurements, explaining the installation process, and providing a free project quote.
Andersen’s quote process, by comparison, begins with selecting your project type, a step Pella doesn’t include in its initial process. After you make your selection, you’re prompted to enter your contact information and submit your request. Unlike Pella, Andersen doesn’t offer immediate scheduling. Instead, you must wait for a representative to reach out and arrange your consultation and pricing details. Andersen doesn’t provide details about what its consultation includes, but it likely follows a similar process to Pella’s, with design discussions, measurements, and a project estimate.
This approach makes sense for Andersen, as many of its replacement window projects are managed through its sister company, Renewal by Andersen, which handles in-home consultations and installations.
Comparing the Pella vs. Andersen Shopping Experience
Pella makes online shopping easy with tools that let you design, visualize, and buy windows all in one place. Andersen, on the other hand, takes a more guided approach that helps homeowners explore their options and connect with an expert before making a decision.
While Pella’s consultation process is faster and more self-directed, Andersen’s structure allows for more specialized guidance and coordination through its dedicated service network.
What Homeowners Say About Pella and Andersen Windows
To better understand customer satisfaction, we reviewed ratings and feedback for both Andersen and Pella on the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Trustpilot. While both brands have strong business ratings, customer reviews suggest a more mixed experience.
Pella Corporation holds an A+ rating with the BBB and is not accredited. Its headquarters page has limited online reviews, since most customers leave feedback on local branch listings across the U.S. The headquarters listing shows an average rating of 1.54 out of 5 stars, based on 65 reviews, while Trustpilot reports a similar score of 1.5 out of 5 stars, based on 99 reviews.
Andersen Corporation also holds an A+ rating with the BBB and is not accredited, with a review structure similar to Pella’s. Because Andersen operates through nationwide branches, most feedback appears on local dealer pages rather than the main company listing. The headquarters page currently holds an average rating of 1.29 out of 5 stars from 97 customer reviews. On Trustpilot, Andersen has a 1.5 out of 5-star rating from 41 reviews.
Pella Customer Reviews
Pella received positive reviews for its wide range of window styles, customization options, and appealing designs. Customers appreciated the in-home consultation process and the overall quality of its products. However, many reported issues with service follow-up, measurement mistakes, and warranty handling.
Read two sample reviews for Pella below:
“I had 28 windows replaced by Pella … The salesman was helpful in showing us options, and we’re happy we followed his suggestions. The installation was a major project and it went off without a hitch. The team did a perfect job and left the house immaculate … They were extremely professional and took pride in their work. We did have an issue with some glass, but they were quick to respond and resolved it promptly. Our experience was very positive.” —Richard A. via the BBB, August 2025
“I hope you never have to replace a part for a Pella Window. Customer service is beyond bad. They promised to send a quote for a simple part over a month ago. I have had no response back from anyone, even though three people said they would escalate this to a manager. Meanwhile, I cannot open my window. I have emailed, texted, and hung up the phone for over an hour.” —I.S. via Trustpilot, April 2025
Andersen Customer Reviews
Homeowners praised Andersen for its durable, high-quality products and attractive designs. Many reviews mentioned professional installation teams and clear communication during the sales process. However, several customers reported slow responses from customer service, warranty delays, and scheduling issues.
Below are sample reviews for Andersen:
“Quality of product is best in [the] industry and customer service is professional, responsive, knowledgeable, and resolved my issues. I have over $26,000 of their windows installed and they keep the house cool in the hot [weather] and warm in the cold [weather].” —Scott G. via the BBB, June 2025
“Purchased $45,000 in windows. On one window, the locking hardware did not line up correctly. I put in a request to have [someone] come out and fix it, and they wanted me to take pictures holding a level and a square to prove that the window was installed correctly. It’s very alarming [that] they offer no warranty.“
—Lori N. via the BBB, November 2025
Homeowner Insights
- Despite mixed online reviews, our most recent survey shows strong satisfaction for both Pella and Andersen. Among respondents who chose either brand for their most recent window replacement, more than 95% reported being satisfied, with similarly high ratings for installation quality and customer service.
Should You Choose Pella or Andersen Windows?
Choosing between Pella and Andersen comes down to your project priorities, but both brands perform well based on homeowner feedback. In our survey, more than 95% of homeowners who chose either brand reported being satisfied with their windows, and nearly all said their homes felt more comfortable after installation.
If you want a more guided, full-service experience with a focus on durability and long-term value, Andersen is a reliable choice. Its professional installation network makes it a strong fit for homeowners who prefer a hands-off process. Pella is better suited for homeowners who value customization, modern features, and design flexibility.
Your installer and contract details will play a major role in your overall experience, particularly when it comes to warranty coverage and long-term performance.
FAQs About Pella vs. Andersen
What is the difference between Andersen and Pella?
The main difference between Andersen and Pella is their available window frame materials. Andersen offers up to five frame materials (vinyl, fiberglass, aluminum, wood, and composite), while Pella provides up to three (fiberglass, wood, and vinyl). Also, Andersen provides in-house installation services via its Renewal by Andersen line. Pella requires you to find an authorized contractor to install their windows.
Are Pella windows considered high-end?
Pella offers high-end window models, such as its fiberglass Impervia and wood Reserve lines. It is one of the few window brands that integrates smart-home technology into some models. In addition to its high-end window lines, Pella offers solid vinyl windows for those with limited budgets.
What installation services do Andersen and Pella provide for their windows?
Andersen has several window installation service options: full-service installation via its in-house Renewal by Andersen brand, authorized dealer installation, and certified contractor installation. Pella offers similar installation services except for full-service installation.
Is Pella or Andersen cheaper?
Based on our research, Andersen windows range from $200–$1,200, while Pella windows range from $150–$1,800. Overall, Pella offers more premium options at higher price points, while Andersen’s pricing is more consistent across styles.
Our Rating Methodology
Our team backs up our window ratings and recommendations with a detailed rating methodology to objectively score each provider we review. Our research included speaking with company representatives, browsing product selections, reviewing window details, and conducting consumer surveys. We then scored each provider against our review standards based on window variety and features, cost, value, trustworthiness, and customer service to determine a final score on a 5-point rating scale.
