We may be compensated if you purchase through links on our website. Our Reviews Team is committed to delivering honest, objective, and independent reviews on home products and services.More
A white house vinyl window with glass, green curtain decoration on the small light green wooden resident with copy space, view from outdoor.

Best Vinyl Window Brands in 2024

Compare quotes from local window installers

Invalid Zip Code
Enter details in under 3 minutes

Join more than 6,755 people who have received a free, no-obligation quote in the last 30 days

Powered by Home Service Quotes

Author Image Written by Jessica Wimmer Updated 05/24/2024

Vinyl is one of the most popular window materials for good reason. It’s durable, affordable, and low-maintenance. We’ve spent over 400 hours researching the top-rated window brands to find which offer the best vinyl windows. We chose Renewal by Andersen as our top pick due to its impressive energy performance, warranty coverage, and in-house installation. 

Our guide also lists Champion, Castle, Milgard, and Harvey as close competitors. We evaluated each company’s product selection, average window costs*, warranty coverage, customer reviews, and more to see which have the most to offer for vinyl window shoppers. We’ve also provided shopping tips to help you narrow down your choices.

*Unless otherwise noted, brand-specific window pricing was sourced from brand websites.

Key Takeaways

Our favorite vinyl window producer is Renewal by Andersen for their top-tier installation services and warranty coverage.
The average vinyl window replacement costs between $100–$900 per window with an average cost of $500.
The Department of Energy reports that 25%–30% of your home’s heating and cooling use goes toward combating heat gain and loss through windows, making upgrading to energy-efficient windows a good investment.

Who Are the Best Vinyl Window Replacement Brands?

According to our detailed methodology and industry research, these are the best vinyl window brands:

Most Hands-Free Experience: Renewal by Andersen
Best Financing and Discounts: Champion Windows
Best Warranty: Castle Windows
Best Fiberglass Windows: Milgard
Best Hardware Customization: Harvey

How Do Top Vinyl Window Companies Compare?

See how we rated each brand’s products and services compared to its average price. 

Providers
Star Rating
Average Cost
$500–$3,000
$350–$800
$300–$600
$300–$600
$500–$1,350
Star Rating Best For Price Range Link
Renewal by Andersen Renewal by Andersen
Most Hands-Free Install $400–$1,850 Visit Site
Champion Champion
Best Financing $300–$1,700 Visit Site
Castle Windows Castle Windows
Best Warranty $300–$2,325 Visit Site
Milgard Milgard
Best Fiberglass Windows $300–$1,700 Visit Site
Harvey Harvey
Best Custom Hardware $500–$2,350 Visit Site
Renewal by Andersen
Logo Renewal by Andersen
Star Rating
Best For Most Hands-Free Install
Price Range $400–$1,850
Visit Site
Champion
Logo Champion
Star Rating
Best For Best Financing
Price Range $300–$1,700
Visit Site
Castle Windows
Logo Castle Windows
Star Rating
Best For Best Warranty
Price Range $300–$2,325
Visit Site
Milgard
Logo Milgard
Star Rating
Best For Best Fiberglass Windows
Price Range $300–$1,700
Visit Site
Harvey
Logo Harvey
Star Rating
Best For Best Custom Hardware
Price Range $500–$2,350
Visit Site
Why Trust Us? Our review and rating process for the best window replacement companies
16
companies reviewed We carefully considered 22 companies to find the best window replacement providers available.
2500
people surveyed We surveyed 2,500 home owners to see what they care about most when in comes to windows.
3000
reviews analyzed We went through 3,000 customer reviews of window replacement companies to see what people had to say about each provider.
600
research hours conducted We spent over 600 hours researching the windows industry to find the best window offerings on the market.

Who Are Our Top Picks for Best Vinyl Windows?

These five brands rated highest for best vinyl windows when testing against our methodology. We looked at the number of styles offered, customization options, energy performance, warranty coverage, customer service, reviews, Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating and more to make our selections. 

Renewal by Andersen

Most Hands-Free Install
4.7

Price Range: $500–$3,000
Warranty: Limited warranty on parts, labor, and installation

Overview

Renewal by Andersen is a division of the reputable Andersen Corporation. The company creates custom vinyl windows using a unique composite material called Fibrex. This material combines wood’s strength and stability with vinyl’s low-maintenance features. The company claims its Fibrex vinyl is twice as strong as standard vinyl. Many customers mentioned Renewal by Andersen’s impressive build quality in the reviews we read. 

Another perk of Renewal by Andersen is that it offers certified, in-house installation services beginning with a personalized consultation.

Pros and Cons

Pros Includes a 20-year transferable warranty on glass and 10-year coverage on nonglass materials Has an in-house installation team certified to install its windows Offers an augmented reality tool that lets you visualize new windows in your home Cons Has higher pricing than most competitors Handles financing through a third-party that may charge hidden fees Has long installation wait times according to customer reviews

Window Styles

Renewal by Andersen manufactures vinyl replacement windows in the following styles:

  • Awning 
  • Bay and bow 
  • Casement 
  • Double-hung 
  • Gliding 
  • Pass-through
  • Picture 
  • Specialty

Champion

Best Financing
4.3

Price Range: $350–$800
Warranty: Limited lifetime warranty

Overview

Champion’s vinyl windows use its ColorBond exterior paint. This paint uses heat-reflective and impact-resistant technology to prevent fading, warping, and energy loss. The brand also uses Energy Star-certified Comfort 365 glass with a specialized low-emissivity (low-e) coating to improve performance and increase your long-term savings.

Champion offers ongoing discounts. We noted offerings such as buy two windows, get two free. The company also has various financing options to fit different budgets.

Pros and Cons

Pros Is a full-service installer, so you won’t need to hire an outside contractor Has a 0% financing option Frequently offers generous discounts Cons Has some customer reviews mentioning slow timelines and poor communication Varies pricing by location Isn’t sold nationwide

Window Styles

You can get Champion windows in the following styles:

  • Basement hopper
  • Bay and bow 
  • Casement 
  • Double-hung 
  • Garden
  • Glass block
  • Picture 
  • Shaped

Castle Windows

Best Warranty
4.5

Price range: $300–$600
Warranty: Lifetime warranty

Overview

Castle offers high-quality vinyl windows, including double weather-stripping for durability and a tilt-sash (the part of the window that opens) for easy cleaning. Like Renewal by Andersen and Champion, Castle creates made-to-order vinyl windows rather than offering specific lines. This gives you complete control over your window’s specifications and features.

Castle’s transferable lifetime warranty is one of the industry’s best. It covers all window parts, such as screens, glass, and other components. It also covers installation, with free labor on Castle’s services.

Pros and Cons

Pros Provides a true lifetime warranty Is a full-service installer, so you’ll get in-house installation services Custom-builds specialty window shapes Cons Varies price by location Doesn’t sell budget-friendly single-hung windows Isn’t available nationwide

Window Styles

Castle windows come in the following styles:

  • Awning 
  • Basement hoppers
  • Bay and bow
  • Casement 
  • Double-hung 
  • Garden 
  • Slider 
  • Specialty

Milgard

Best Fiberglass Windows
4.1

Price range: $300–$600
Warranty: Full lifetime and limited lifetime warranty depending on product line

Overview

Milgard offers four vinyl window lines. We recommend its Style Line Series for homeowners on a budget, as it offers simple window design options at lower prices. If you want a more elevated vinyl window, consider the company’s V450 HomeMaker Series, which includes unique window styles such as radius windows.

When browsing Milgard’s website, we appreciated the support and assistance provided throughout the window replacement process. We especially liked its online chat feature and the resources on its support tab, such as its do-it-yourself (DIY) service library and video guides for ongoing window care.

Pros and Cons

Pros Provides a full lifetime warranty on some vinyl window lines Has some of the least expensive vinyl window prices in the industry Includes SmartTouch hardware for easy locking and unlocking Cons Doesn’t provide in-house installation services Isn’t sold nationwide Doesn’t make custom specialty-shaped windows

Window Styles

Milgard makes the following types of windows:

  • Awning 
  • Bay and bow
  • Casement 
  • Double-hung 
  • Garden 
  • Picture
  • Radius 
  • Slider 
  • Single-hung

Harvey

Best Custom Hardware
4.4

Price range: $500–$1,350
Warranty: Lifetime and 10-year warranties

Overview

bronze vinyl windows with a UV Tough paint coat that’s 10 times stronger than the industry standard. You can also choose from five BetterGrain interior finishes that mimic the look of natural wood windows. This window line includes a lifetime warranty.

We recommend Harvey if durability is your top priority. The company uses sturdy, Energy Star-certified glass and offers options for dual-action locks, limit latches, and multiple glass panes. These features make Harvey’s vinyl windows withstand the elements more effectively than many other brands.

Pros and Cons

Pros Lets you add custom hardware to vinyl windows Makes long-lasting windows with UV Tough paint to resist fading Includes a lifetime warranty for many of its vinyl windows Cons Doesn’t provide in-house installation Isn’t sold nationwide Has higher pricing for vinyl windows than many competitors

Window Styles

Harvey manufactures the following window types:

  • Awning 
  • Basement hopper
  • Bay and bow
  • Casement 
  • Double-hung 
  • Garden 
  • Gliding 
  • Picture
  • Rolling 
  • Single-hung

Compare Quotes from Window Experts in Your State


How Much Do Vinyl Windows Cost?

The average vinyl window replacement cost is $100–$900 per window. The price primarily depends on the window’s style and glass type. Higher-grade vinyl costs roughly $300 more than lower-grade options. Though price is important, we recommend balancing cost with quality. Cheaper options may not last as long and will need more frequent replacing, costing you more money in the long run.


What Should You Consider When Buying Vinyl Windows?

Even if you’ve narrowed the window material you want to vinyl, there are still so many other factors to look at to pick the best windows for you and your home. Here’s what we recommend looking at to determine your best fit. 

Window Style and Appearance

First, if the brand you’re looking at doesn’t have the style you’re after, there’s no point in considering those windows any further. If you’re set on a certain window type and look, start there. See common window types and their descriptions below.

Common Window Types and Their Functions

The dropdown tabs below provide a look at how common window types function:

Awning windows have hinges at the top of the frame and swing outward from the bottom. They often have a crank or a type of glide hardware.

These small basement windows increase natural light and airflow. They run across the top of your home’s foundation and are hinged at the bottom to open at the top.

basement hopper window icon

These windows have a 3D shape that curves outward from your home. Adding a box seat or ledge can transform them into a bookshelf or additional seating area. Bay windows are angular, while bow windows are more curved.

bay window icon

This popular window style has a hinge on the side, and swings open to the left or right via a crank. Casement windows are often placed in hard-to-reach areas, such as over a kitchen sink or in a bathroom.

casement window icon

These windows have two locks and open at the top and bottom. They’re often found on high floors.

double hung window icon

Garden windows protrude from your home, creating a space to grow plants and herbs. They’re ideal for a kitchen window.

These are translucent, thick glass blocks. They allow light into the room but obscure the view, making them popular for bathrooms and basements.

glass block window icon

These oversized windows are floor-to-ceiling accents. They don’t open but still provide lots of natural lighting.

picture window icon

Sometimes called geometric windows, shaped windows provide an accent that lets light in where standard windows might not work. Popular shapes include half-round, round, eclipse, triangles, and trapezoids.

These windows function similarly to double-hung windows, but they only open from one end instead of both. They tend to be smaller than double-hung windows.

single hung window icon

Energy Efficiency

The next feature to look for is energy efficiency. This is arguably the most important element to look for in a window because it can give you the most impactful return on investment. The Department of Energy reports that 25%–30% of your home’s heating and cooling use goes toward combating heat gain and loss through windows. A highly energy-efficient window not only keeps your home more comfortable year-round, but it lowers your heating and cooling costs and prevents your HVAC system from having to work so hard. 

Look for energy-saving additions that help windows perform better, such as low-e glass coating and argon-gas filling. Both will help control how heat leaves and enters your home. Also, avoid single-pane windows. Invest in triple-pane windows for maximum insulation if you live in a particularly cold area. If your climate stays moderate most of the year, go with double-pane windows. 

Always check that a window has an Energy Star label. This ensures it’s undergone rigorous testing to meet performance standards for your climate.

Warranty Coverage

Don’t overlook warranty coverage. Most window brands have a sample policy linked on their website, so you can check out the fine print. 

Common warranty types include:

  • Lifetime warranties: These cover all window parts for a predetermined time designated by the manufacturer, typically between three and 15 years. 
  • Double lifetime warranties: This warranty type is rare, but as the name suggests, you’re covered by your warranty for double the expected lifetime of your window.
  • Limited lifetime warranties: Limited lifetime warranties are also determined by the window manufacturer but only cover some aspects of the window.
  • Transferable warranties: These are helpful if you ever plan to sell your home because you can transfer the warranty to the new homeowner. Coverage may be limited for nonoriginal warranty holders.
  • Labor warranties: The warranties above protect the windows themselves. Labor warranties protect the workmanship. Also known as contractor warranties, these cover issues related to workmanship as long as a licensed, manufacturer-approved company installs the windows.

Customer Reviews 

Always check customer reviews on sites such as BBB, Trustpilot, Best Company, Yelp, and Google Reviews before making such a large purchase. Most of these reviews will be regarding the brand’s customer service or general quality, which is still good to see, but you can find window-specific reviews on retailer sites such as Home Depot and Lowe’s. Read at least a few dozen reviews from the past year to note any patterns in poor window performance, warranty issues, or unexpected costs. 

Customization Options

Next, you can look for window options that allow the customizations you want, such as specialty glass, color, grid layout, hardware, etc. When buying a window, these are less important features since they don’t contribute much to performance or ROI, so you may need to compromise here to ensure you get higher-priority features. 

Cost

Lastly, once you’ve whittled down your options in all other categories, go with the windows that offer the most for the lowest price. Consider which features are necessary for you and which you can compromise on while staying within your budget. Ask your manufacturer and installer if they’re running any discounts or about financing options if the windows you want are just outside your budget.


Vinyl is a popular window material among homeowners for a few reasons. It’s typically more affordable than wood, composite, and fiberglass windows. Second only to aluminum windows, it’s one of the most budget-friendly window materials out there. But you don’t have to sacrifice quality to get an affordable window. Vinyl is also highly durable, long-lasting, and low maintenance. While it’s less energy-efficient than fiberglass or composite windows, it still performs well in most climates. It’s easy to find in top brands’ inventory and won’t warp, rot, or rust. 


How To Find a Local Vinyl Window Installer

Our survey of 1,000 homeowners showed that most (71%) opted to hire a professional window installation company. Their reasons varied, but many said they were scared to make a mistake, wanted to protect their windows with a warranty, or didn’t want to deal with the hassle of taking on the project themselves. If you’re curious about what professional installation entails, one of our team members joined a Renewal by Andersen crew on the job to learn what a typical installation day is like. See step by step what to expect during professional window installation.

You can streamline your search for reliable window companies by looking for certified installers for your desired brand. Many window brands provide a website search function to search for certified installers near you.

Use our tool below to quickly connect with reputable, certified window installers that serve your ZIP code.

Get Estimates from Window Experts in Your Area
Compare quotes from local pros

What’s the Best Vinyl Window Brand for Your Home?

Vinyl windows provide a sought-after balance between affordability and performance. We recommend Renewal by Andersen’s vinyl windows due to their highly tested and awarded energy efficiency and for the brand’s white-glove window replacement experience. Though Renewal by Andersen costs more on average than most competitors, it comes with a high return on investment, so you’ll save money in the long run thanks to lower energy bills. 
When buying vinyl windows, prioritize the option that offers the best energy efficiency at the maximum price you can afford. If budget concerns you, check out our guide to cheap replacement window brands. We suggest requesting at least three quotes from window installers before deciding.


FAQs About Vinyl Windows

How can you tell if a vinyl window is good quality?

Look for vinyl windows with premium-grade polyurethane for maximum energy efficiency. Check that the window has an Energy Star label to ensure it’s been tested and meets strict standards for superior energy performance. A good way to see how customers feel about a window’s quality is to check customer reviews for feedback on the window’s operation, durability, and performance.

Are there different grades of vinyl windows?

Yes, there are different grades of vinyl windows. Building-grade vinyl windows typically have two to three internal chambers, while premium-grade vinyl windows have five to seven chambers. Premium-grade vinyl windows provide superior energy efficiency, as they often use polyurethane insulation to make up their vinyl frames.

How long do vinyl windows last?

According to Glass Doctor, vinyl windows can last 20–40 years, depending on how well they’re cared for. 

Should I buy black or white vinyl windows?

We recommend buying white vinyl windows. White provides a simple and clean look paired with excellent energy efficiency and performance. Black vinyl windows are a great way to add contrast to your home, but they will absorb more heat and make your home warmer in summer. 


Our Rating Methodology

We back up our window ratings and recommendations with a detailed rating methodology to objectively score each provider. We conduct research by speaking with company representatives, browsing product selections, analyzing window line specifications, and conducting focus groups and consumer surveys. We then score each provider against our review standards for window variety, value, trustworthiness and transparency, window features, and customer service to arrive at a final score on a 5-point rating scale. 

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.