Vinyl is one of the most popular window materials. It’s sturdy, affordable, and provides excellent curb appeal.

We’ve spent hundreds of hours researching the top-rated window brands to find the ones that offer the best vinyl windows. Our guide covers each company’s product selection, average window costs, and other essential information. We’ve also provided shopping tips to help you narrow down your choices.

Top Vinyl Window Replacement Brands for Your Home

Compare Window Brands

Star Rating
Best For
Price Range
Most Hands-Free Install
Best Financing and Discounts
Best Warranty
Best Fiberglass Windows
Best Custom Hardware
Star Rating Best For Link
Renewal by Andersen Renewal by Andersen
Most Hands-Free Install Visit Site
Champion Champion
Best Financing and Discounts Visit Site
Castle Windows Castle Windows
Best Warranty Visit Site
Milgard Milgard
Best Fiberglass Windows Visit Site
Harvey Harvey
Best Custom Hardware Visit Site
Renewal by Andersen
Logo Renewal by Andersen
Star Rating
Best For Most Hands-Free Install
Visit Site
Logo Champion
Star Rating
Best For Best Financing and Discounts
Visit Site
Castle Windows
Logo Castle Windows
Star Rating
Best For Best Warranty
Visit Site
Logo Milgard
Star Rating
Best For Best Fiberglass Windows
Visit Site
Logo Harvey
Star Rating
Best For Best Custom Hardware
Visit Site

Renewal by Andersen

  • Our rating: 4.7 out of 5
  • Warranty: Limited and limited lifetime warranties 
  • Price range: $500–$3,000*
  • State availability: 50 states but varies by ZIP code

Renewal by Andersen is a division of Andersen Windows, a reputable window brand with more than 115 years of experience. It offers a hands-free, white-glove installation experience, beginning with a personalized consultation.

The company creates custom vinyl windows using a unique composite material called Fibrex. This material combines wood’s strength and stability with vinyl’s low-maintenance features. The company claims its Fibrex vinyl is twice as strong as standard vinyl. Many customers mentioned Renewal by Andersen’s impressive build quality in the reviews we read.

Renewal by Andersen offers 35 different window styles, including specialty shapes. You can select from various exterior colors, interior colors, hardware colors, glass types, and grille patterns. You can also add an optional Truscreen insect screen. We browsed various options on Renewal by Andersen’s website and appreciated its user-friendly interface that lets you design windows with these options on one page.

Andersen backs its products with a limited or limited lifetime warranty, depending on the product. This is impressive compared to the industry-standard 10-year frame warranty. 

*All cost figures in this article have been averaged from 2023 reports from 5Estimates and Window Price Guides.

Pros and Cons of Renewal by Andersen

✔ Provides a hands-free experience for vinyl window replacement
✔ Has one of the largest selections of window customization options
✔ Includes a 20-year warranty for glass and 10-year warranty for nonglass components

✘ Handles financing through a third party, which may include hidden fees
✘ Is more expensive than many competitors

Types of Windows Available

Here are the vinyl window styles Renewal by Andersen offers: 

  • Awning windows 
  • Bay windows 
  • Bow windows 
  • Casement windows 
  • Double-hung windows 
  • Gliding windows 
  • Pass-through windows 
  • Picture windows 
  • Specialty windows 

Top Product Recommendation

Renewal by Andersen’s product line only uses its signature Fibrex composite material. Its most popular window style, the double-hung window, has a classic design and easy operation.

Free quote: Get your quote from Renewal by Andersen today

Champion Windows

  • Our rating: 4.4 out of 5
  • Warranty: Limited lifetime warranty
  • Price range: $350–$800
  • State availability: 26 states*

*Available in Alabama, Colorado, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, Nebraska, New Mexico, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, Utah, Washington, and Wisconsin.

Founded in 1953, Champion Windows offers multiple window lines in 26 states. Its windows and doors include Energy Star-certified Comfort 365 Window Glass, which has a specialized low-emissivity (low-e) coating and insulating argon gas. This design blocks roughly 94% of ultraviolet (UV) rays, ensuring your home stays cool during summer and warm in winter.

The company’s vinyl windows use its ColorBond exterior paint. This paint uses heat-reflective and impact-resistant technology to prevent fading, warping, and energy loss. In addition to incorporating energy-efficient features that increase your long-term savings, Champion offers ongoing discounts on its website. We noted offerings such as buy two windows, get two free. The company also offers various financing options to fit different budgets.

Pros and Cons of Champion Windows

✔ Uses nontoxic, heat-reflective materials
✔ Offers Energy Star-certified glass
✔ Provides ongoing deals on its website, including on vinyl windows

✘ Has higher-than-average pricing, according to customer reviews
✘ Limits pricing information online

Types of Windows Available

Here are Champion’s available vinyl window styles, which are all made-to-order: 

  • Basement hoppers
  • Bay windows
  • Bow windows
  • Casement windows
  • Double-hung windows
  • Garden windows
  • Glass block windows
  • Picture windows
  • Shaped windows

Top Product Recommendation

We recommend any of Champion’s vinyl windows paired with its Comfort 365 Glass. This combination makes even the simplest casement window an energy-efficient, worthwhile investment. We suggest opting for one of the company’s seven ColorBond colors to further enhance the window’s performance.

Free quote: Get your quote from Champion Windows today

Castle Windows

  • Our rating: 4.4 out of 5
  • Warranty: Transferable lifetime warranty
  • Price range: $300–$600
  • State availability: 11 states*

*Available in Connecticut, Indiana, Maryland, Michigan, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Virginia, and West Virginia.

Castle Windows offers high-quality vinyl windows, including double weather-stripping for durability and a tilt-sash—or the part of the window that opens—for easy cleaning. Like Renewal by Andersen and Champion Windows, Castle creates made-to-order vinyl windows rather than offering specific lines. This gives you complete control over your window’s specifications and features.

Castle’s transferable lifetime warranty is one of the best in the industry. It covers all window parts, including screens, glass, and other components. It also covers installation, with free labor on Castle’s services.

Pros and Cons of Castle Windows

✔ Custom-builds vinyl windows
✔ Includes one of the best transferable lifetime warranties in the industry
✔ Offers siding services for a comprehensive vinyl window replacement

✘ Doesn’t provide online pricing information
✘ Has less window variety than some competitors

Types of Windows Available

Castle Windows offers the following vinyl window options:

  • Awning windows
  • Basement hoppers 
  • Bay windows 
  • Bow windows
  • Casement windows
  • Double-hung windows
  • Garden windows
  • Slider windows
  • Specialty windows 

Top Product Recommendation

Castle makes custom vinyl windows to fit each home’s unique design. Its popular double-hung design includes double-pane glass and energy efficiency upgrades to help reduce your energy bills. Additionally, its tilt-in sashes make cleaning easier and improve air circulation in your home.

Free quote: Get your quote from Castle Windows today

Milgard Windows and Doors

  • Our rating: 4.5 out of 5
  • Warranty: Limited lifetime and full warranties
  • Price range: $300–$600
  • State availability: 16 states*

*Available in Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, Utah, and Washington.

Milgard offers four vinyl window lines. We recommend its Style Line Series for homeowners on a budget, as it offers simple window design options at lower prices. If you want a more elevated vinyl window, consider the company’s V450 HomeMaker Series, which includes unique window styles such as radius windows.

When browsing Milgard’s website, we appreciated the support and assistance provided throughout the window replacement process. We especially liked its online chat feature and the resources on its support tab, such as its do-it-yourself (DIY) service library and video guides for ongoing window care.

Pros and Cons of Milgard

✔ Creates simple yet stylish vinyl windows with four different window lines
✔ Provides tons of support tools and online resources to make window replacement easier
✔ Uses SmartTouch Hardware for easy locking and unlocking

✘ Doesn’t offer pricing information online
✘ Customer reviews mention communication difficulties

Types of Windows Available

Milgard’s vinyl windows options include the following:

  • Awning windows 
  • Bay windows
  • Bow windows
  • Casement windows
  • Double-hung windows
  • Garden windows
  • Horizontal slider windows
  • Picture windows
  • Radius windows
  • Single-hung windows

Top Product Recommendation

We recommend Milgard’s Tuscany series. This window line offers Milgard’s signature vinyl material, Energy Star-certified options, and patented SmartTouch lock technology. It includes windows with traditional looks and those designed to resemble wooden windows at a more affordable price.

Harvey Windows and Doors

  • Our rating: 4.2 out of 5
  • Warranty: 10-year and lifetime warranties 
  • Price range: $500–$1,350
  • State availability: 16 states*

*Available in Alabama, Connecticut, Delaware, Georgia, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, and West Virginia.

We recommend Harvey Windows if durability is your top priority. The company uses sturdy, Energy Star-certified glass and offers options for dual-action locks, limit latches, and multiple glass panes. These features make Harvey’s vinyl windows withstand the elements more effectively than other brands. 

Harvey’s Classic Vinyl window line provides strength at affordable prices. It includes black and bronze vinyl windows with a UV Tough paint coat that’s 10 times stronger than the industry standard. Additionally, you can also choose from five BetterGrain interior finishes that mimic the look of natural wood windows. The window line also includes a lifetime warranty.  

Pros and Cons of Harvey

✔ Provides long-lasting windows with UV Tough paint
✔ Allows customers to add custom hardware to vinyl windows
✔ Has an inspiration tab on its website to generate home improvement ideas

✘ Customer reviews mention scheduling difficulty
✘ Prices can vary by location

Types of Windows Available

Below are Harvey’s vinyl window options:

  • Awning windows
  • Bay windows
  • Bow windows
  • Casement windows
  • Custom shaped windows 
  • Double-hung windows
  • Garden windows
  • Gliding windows
  • Hoppers
  • Picture windows
  • Single-hung windows
  • Rolling windows

Top Product Recommendation

Harvey’s Tribute Vinyl Windows are its flagship window line. These premium vinyl windows mimic the look of traditional wood windows but are as affordable as vinyl. We encourage you to take advantage of Harvey’s additional security and performance hardware options.

Compare Quotes from Window Experts in Your State

Factors To Consider When Choosing Vinyl Windows

There are a lot of factors to consider when window shopping. We’ve broken down the most important ones below to help you better understand the different component and material selections you’ll need to make. See a breakdown of window parts in the diagram below.

Diagram of parts of a window. Credit: Robert Hardin

Type of Window

Vinyl window manufacturers create windows in various styles to match all kinds of homes. For example, contemporary homes often use casement or sliding windows for open-concept designs, while historic homes often have double-hung and awning windows. Double-hung and casement are the most common choice for vinyl windows. 

Below are some of the popular window types:

  • Awning windows: These windows have hinges at the top of the frame and swing outward from the bottom. They often have a crank or a type of glide hardware. 
  • Basement hoppers: These small basement windows increase natural light and airflow. They run across the top of your home’s foundation and are hinged at the bottom to open at the top.
  • Bay and bow windows: These windows have a 3D shape that curves outward from your home. Adding a box seat or ledge can transform them into a bookshelf or additional seating area. Bay windows are angular, while bow windows are more curved. 
  • Casement windows: This popular window style has a hinge on the side and swings open to the left or right via a crank. Casement windows are often placed in hard-to-reach areas, such as over a kitchen sink or in a bathroom. 
  • Double-hung windows: These windows have two locks and open at the top and bottom. They’re often found on high floors.
  • Garden windows: Garden windows protrude from your home, creating a space to grow plants and herbs. They’re ideal for a kitchen window. 
  • Glass block windows: These windows are translucent, thick blocks of glass. They allow light into the room but obscure the view, making them popular for bathrooms and basements. 
  • Picture windows: These oversized windows are floor-to-ceiling accents. They cannot be opened but provide a lot of natural lighting.
  • Shaped windows: Sometimes called geometric windows, shaped windows provide an accent that lets light in where standard windows might not work. Popular shapes include half-round, round, eclipse, triangles, and trapezoids. 
  • Single-hung windows: These windows function similarly to double-hung windows, but they only open from one end instead of both. They tend to be smaller than double-hung windows. 

Energy Efficiency

Vinyl windows provide a certain level of energy efficiency due to their material. However, you should seek out other features to improve your window’s energy efficiency. The Department of Energy reports that 25%–30% of your home’s heating and cooling use goes toward combating heat gain and loss through windows. Selecting energy-efficient vinyl windows will help to decrease your monthly energy bills. 

One feature to search for is better filtration between the window frames and glass panes. Better filtration reduces sun damage to your home’s furniture, flooring, and walls. Low-emissivity (low-e) glass is a common filtration feature. This glass uses a coat of invisible metallic oxide that allows natural light inside while blocking UV rays and infrared light.

Energy-efficient windows won’t provide many benefits if they’re not installed properly, so work with a reputable contractor to get a precise installation and tight seal.


When vinyl window shopping, check what warranties a manufacturer and installer offer to protect your investment. The length and stipulations of these warranties vary by product. Most vinyl windows have warranties as short as one to two years, but high-end vinyl replacement windows may feature warranties that exceed five years. 

Here are standard warranties you might encounter while shopping:

  • Lifetime warranties: These cover all window parts for a predetermined time designated by the manufacturer, typically between three and 15 years. 
  • Double lifetime warranties: This warranty type is rare, but as the name suggests, you’re covered by your warranty for double the expected lifetime of your window.
  • Limited lifetime warranties: Limited lifetime warranties are also determined by the manufacturer but only cover some aspects of the window.
  • Transferable warranties: These are helpful if you ever plan to sell your home because you can transfer the warranty to the new homeowner. Coverage may be limited for nonoriginal warranty holders.
  • Labor warranties: The warranties above protect the windows themselves. Labor warranties protect the workmanship. Also known as contractor warranties, these cover issues related to workmanship as long as a licensed, manufacturer-approved company installs the windows.


The average vinyl window replacement cost is $100–$900 per window. The price depends on the window’s style and glass type. Higher-grade vinyl costs roughly $300 more than lower-grade options. Though price is important, we recommend balancing cost with quality. Cheaper options may not last as long and will need more frequent replacing, costing you more money in the long run.


We recommend reading customer reviews on popular sites such as the Better Business Bureau (BBB), Trustpilot, and Google for each window brand and installer you’re interested in. This will help you gain insight into customers’ experiences with the window brand and learn more about pros and cons, especially the windows and installation quality. 

We advise you to take note of each customer’s scheduling experiences. We surveyed 1,000 homeowners and found that 69% of respondents had their windows installed within three weeks of placing an order. 68% said the installation was completed within two to four hours on their scheduled day. Reviews should align with this timeline for a reputable and efficient provider.

Finding a Local Window Installer

Our survey showed that most homeowners (71%)  opted to hire a professional window installation company. Their reasons varied, but many said they were scared to make a mistake, wanted to protect their windows with a warranty, or simply didn’t want to deal with the hassle of taking on the project themselves.

You can streamline your search for reliable window companies by looking for installers who are certified for the brand you want. Many window brands provide a page on their websites to search for certified installers near you.

Use our tool below to quickly connect with reputable, certified window installers that service your ZIP code.

Get Estimates from Window Experts in Your Area
Compare quotes in as little as 5 minutes

Our Conclusion

Vinyl windows provide a balance between style and performance unmatched by many other materials. They’re also relatively affordable, but if budget is a concern, we encourage you to read our guide to cheap replacement window brands.

We recommend Renewal by Andersen for a white-glove window replacement experience. Champion Windows offers a wide selection of quality windows, and Castle Windows has durable yet affordable windows with a robust warranty. We suggest requesting at least three quotes from different window installers before deciding. 

Use our tool below to request quotes from our top companies.

FAQ About The Best Vinyl Windows

Our Rating Methodology

The This Old House Reviews Team is committed to providing comprehensive and unbiased reviews to our readers. This means earning your trust through transparent reviews and data to support our ratings and recommendations. Our rating system for window brands is on a 100-point scale based on five factors:

  • Installation process and provider benefits (15 points): We consider each provider’s overall installation process, including whether it offers in-home consultations, customization options, or other services such as roofing. We also consider whether the provider is available at easy-to-access retailers, such as The Home Depot or Lowe’s.
  • Warranty (15 points): We consider whether or not the provider offers a warranty, as well as if that warranty is limited or lifetime. 
  • BBB rating (10 points): We evaluate each company’s Better Business Bureau rating. Companies with higher scores receive more points. 
  • Pricing (10 points): We consider each provider’s average price range. Providers with a lower average price range receive more points than those with higher ones. 
  • Customer service (10 points): Does the company offer helpful customer service tools, such as an online request form or phone number? The more tools it offers, the higher its score.
  • Window features (15 points): We consider which window features a company offers, such as low-e coating, tilt-in sashes, and customization options. The more features a company provides, the higher the score. 
  • Window variety (10 points): The more window types a company offers, the higher the score.

Total scores are divided by 20 for a final 5-point rating scale.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews team at