We may be compensated if you purchase through links on our website. Our Reviews Team is committed to delivering honest, objective, and independent reviews on home products and services. More

5 Best Flooring Companies in Lancaster, NY

Get matched with a top local pro
Join the 6,755 people who have received a free, no-obligation quote in the last 30 days
  1. Home
  2. Find Local Pros
  3. Flooring Near Me
  4. New York
  5. Lancaster
  6. Lancaster Flooring
Written By Max Peterson | Last Updated: February 05, 2024

Installing new flooring is a major project, and it's easy to get lost in all the plentiful design and material options. A local contractor in Lancaster can help you choose the right floor and install it to last. These Lancaster, NY flooring installers offer excellent value, a knowledgeable team, and a comprehensive selection.

Best for Eco-Friendly Options
4.5
  • International product catalog
  • In-home consultations
  • Highly positive reputation among customers
Most Convenient
4.5
  • Complementary in-home consultations
  • Wide variety of product choices
  • Products for every budget/style/need
Best for Hardwood
4.5
  • Hundreds of locations across U.S. and Canada
  • DIY-friendly
  • Affordable prices and special financing options

5 Best Flooring Companies in Lancaster

Lifetime Concrete Coatings Logo

Lifetime Concrete Coatings

4.7/5
Based on 47 customer reviews.

Services Offered

Tiles Concrete Residential Flooring Commercial Flooring

Highlights

  • Free quote
  • Informative resources
  • Clear pricing policy
960 French Rd, Buffalo, NY 716-418-8800 lifetimeconcretecoatingswny.com
M P Caroll Hardwood Logo

M P Caroll Hardwood

4.5/5
Based on 88 customer reviews.

Services Offered

Refinishing Residential Flooring Tiles Hardwood Flooring

Highlights

  • Clear pricing policy
  • Accessible customer support team
  • Free quote
4822 Genesee St, Cheektowaga, NY 716-683-8520 mpcaroll.com
CJ Construction Service Inc Logo

CJ Construction Service

4.5/5
Based on 16 customer reviews.

Services Offered

Residential Flooring Basement Transformation

Highlights

  • Accessible customer support team
  • Free quote
  • Clear pricing policy
2129 Broadway, Buffalo, NY 716-440-0607 cjconstructionsvc.com
Carpet Factory Outlet Logo

Carpet Factory Outlet

4.5/5
Based on 32 customer reviews.

Services Offered

Carpets Residential Flooring Commercial Flooring Vinyl Laminate Flooring Tiles Hardwood Flooring

Highlights

  • Free quote
  • Clear pricing policy
5599 Transit Rd, East Amherst, NY 716-304-2149 carpetfactoryoutlet.net

More Local Flooring Companies

National Lumber Co. Inc.

User Reviews: 4.4/5 

7 Embry Pl
Lancaster, NY 14086

Mario & Son Tile & Linoleum

User Reviews: 4.4/5 

2755 Harlem Rd
Cheektowaga, NY 14225

New York Kitchen & Bath

User Reviews: 4.4/5 

4955 Broadway
Depew, NY 14043

Custom Carpet Centers

User Reviews: 4.3/5 

5085 Transit Rd
Williamsville, NY 14221

Best Tile Cheektowaga

User Reviews: 4.3/5 

2800 Walden Ave
Cheektowaga, NY 14225

Tontine Carpet One

User Reviews: 4.2/5 

1071 Union Rd
West Seneca, NY 14224

Carpets Unlimited

User Reviews: 4.2/5 

1900 Ridge Rd
West Seneca, NY 14224

Kenny Carpets & Floors

User Reviews: 4.1/5 

2995 Sheridan Dr
Amherst, NY 14226

Outlet Carpet and Flooring

User Reviews: 4.5/5 

2260 Niagara Falls Blvd
Tonawanda, NY 14150

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviewsteam@thisoldhousereviews.com.

Get Your Flooring Project Quote Today

Get matched with a top local pro

Please enter a valid 5-digit zip code!

Facts about Lancaster
Average Max Temp: 54°F
Average Min Temp: 40°F
Average Monthly Precipitation: 3.42"
Median Home Size: 1616 sqft
Homeownership Rate: 65%
Most Popular Flooring Type: Tile

Expert Tips By

This Old House empowers homeowners with the knowledge and tools they need to tackle various projects and navigate the complexities of homeownership.

Popular Types of Flooring

Whether you're looking for something elegant and subtle or bold and lively, there's a floor for you. Discover the most essential details about each type to guide your decision making.

Hardwood Flooring

The appeal of hardwood floors stands the test of time. With options including maple, oak, cherry, walnut, and more, it can fit any design without sacrificing durability. However, it's among the priciest of flooring materials and requires consistent maintenance. At a minimum, you'll need to use specialty cleaning products regularly and refinish the floor every few years. Since it's susceptible to water damage, it's also not suitable for bathrooms, basements, or laundry rooms.

Engineered Wood Flooring

Engineered wood provides you the look and durability of hardwood without the extra maintenance. Typically, it uses a layer of real hardwood fused with a plywood substrate. Despite the lower retail cost, it might feel more hollow to walk on, and the slender hardwood layer can only be refinished a single time. That said, its lower propensity to warp could still make it a sound investment.

Laminate Flooring

Laminate floors come in tile and wood finishes, but they all have a particle board base. A strong plastic coating gives them resilience against scratches and simplifies cleaning. However, it's more susceptible to water damage and chipping.

Vinyl Flooring

Vinyl flooring has excellent water and fading resistance and requires minimal upkeep. Popular options include luxury vinyl plank (LVP) and luxury vinyl tile (LVT), with both having equal durability and longevity depending on the model you buy. Their price point sits comfortably between wood and laminate.

Tile Flooring

Tile flooring is excellent for kitchens, bathrooms, and other moisture-prone areas. It provides years of life with minimal maintenance needs, and is available in many materials, patterns, and colors. However, it requires intensive prep work before installation and can be cold and sleek to walk on. Pricing relies on the material you pick, with porcelain being more expensive than ceramic.

Stone Flooring

Stone floors are among the most waterproof available. You can choose from a variety of bold design options, including marble, travertine, granite, and sandstone. Despite its unique flair, it's not easy to clean, and long-term maintenance could be a bit more expensive.

Linoleum Flooring

With proper maintenance, linoleum floors can endure for years. It is a cost-effective choice with various alternatives for personalization. However, it can readily become damaged and has been known to lose its original coloring when exposed to the sun's rays. Direct sunlight also leads linoleum to fade over time, and it might not work well for moisture-prone spaces.

Carpet

Carpet is the most affordable flooring option. It can make a space feel more cozy and is great for reducing sound. You don’t have to worry about scratches or dents, and the cushioning makes it a safer choice for babies and toddlers. However, the fibrous material easily holds onto odors, moisture, and stains, which isn't ideal for pet owners or allergy sufferers.

How to Choose a Lancaster Flooring Company

Choosing a flooring company is just as critical as choosing a design. To ensure you get the most value, consider each of the following criteria.

Reputation and Reviews

The most crucial thing to research about any flooring company is its reputation. Check review sites like the Better Business Bureau (BBB), Google, Trustpilot, and Yelp to see what previous clients have to say. Even the most reliable flooring installers will have both positive and negative reviews. Look for how a business deals with complaints and interacts with others. If it strives for a satisfactory resolution and acts in good faith, that's an encouraging sign. However, if it's combative or has a high negative-to-positive review ratio, it's advisable to avoid working with it.

Portfolio and References

A good flooring company will be happy to show you portfolios of its previous work. Take a careful look at each listed project and ask questions as you have them. It's also good practice to ask for references from former customers. Once you have their contact information, contact them to ask about their experiences.

Specialization and Services

Look for a business that specializes in the type of flooring you're interested in. For example, a crew might be experienced with carpet but not hardwood. Equally important is a company's service offerings. At the very least, it should offer cleanup and haul-away for your old flooring materials. However, if you're feeling lost in all the color, material, and style choices, you can also look for contractors with design teams.

Cost

While price shouldn't be the most important factor when choosing a flooring company, it's still important to find one that matches your budget. We recommend getting quotes from multiple companies to compare labor costs. You can do this fully online or by requesting complimentary on-site estimates.

Warranties and Guarantees

Flooring services typically come with a pair of warranties. The first one, issued by the manufacturer, covers the materials. The other backs the installation company's workmanship. Depending on the installer and flooring brand you choose, warranty coverage could be limited to a fixed term. Other times, it continues for the life of the floor. Ask a company about its warranty terms, including extensions that could give you longer coverage.

Estimated Timeline

You don't want your flooring project to last longer than necessary. Request an estimated timeline up-front and ask about potential delays. Communicate your expectations clearly and secure any guarantees in writing.

Ready to Get a Quote on Your Flooring Project?

Get matched with a top local pro

Please enter a valid 5-digit zip code!

Frequently Asked Questions About Flooring in Lancaster

How much will it cost to install a new floor in Lancaster?

Generally, flooring installation costs in Lancaster range from $0.60 to $4.00 per square foot. An estimate will factor in your space's size, the type of floor you'd like, and the job's complexity. You can discover the best price by getting multiple estimates and comparing them side by side.

See our guides to how much each flooring type typically costs:

What's the most popular flooring material in Lancaster?

According to local data, the majority of Lancaster homes use more than one flooring material. However, tile is ultimately the most popular choice.

Do Lancaster flooring companies need to be licensed?

New York doesn't require flooring companies to get a state license, but cities often choose to require licenses of their own. We encourage you to contact your local government office for more information on contractor licensing. If your city doesn't require licensure, ask each company about its private certifications, each of which can demonstrate professionalism and skill in the trade.

Who is the largest flooring manufacturer?

As of 2023, Mohawk is the country's largest flooring manufacturer. They produce engineered wood, laminate, carpet, and vinyl coverings.

How do I decide which flooring material is right?

To choose the right flooring material for your space, consider your financial plan and lifestyle. Some people prefer to reduce maintenance, while others don't mind the upkeep of a more traditional design.

Just as well, consider the nature of the space itself. Is it exposed to moisture or high foot traffic? What look would pair well with the walls, furniture, and trim?

A Lancaster flooring installer can discuss all these considerations and more to help you make an informed decision.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviewsteam@thisoldhousereviews.com.

Other Flooring Resources

Sources