We may be compensated if you purchase through links on our website. Our Reviews Team is committed to delivering honest, objective, and independent reviews on home products and services. More

Best 5 Painters in Lancaster, NY

Get matched with a top local pro
Join the 6,755 people who have received a free, no-obligation quote in the last 30 days
  1. Home
  2. Local Pros
  3. Painting
  4. NY
  5. Lancaster
Written By Callie Marsalisi|Last Updated: February 05, 2024

A fresh coat of paint can greatly enhance a home's appearance, whether you're preparing to sell or just want a change of scenery. However, painting is an exhausting and time-consuming project. Our guide features the best painting contractors in Lancaster to help you select experts who can get the job done.

5 Best Painters in Lancaster, NY

Classic Renovations of Buffalo Logo

Classic Renovations of Buffalo

4.7/5
Based on 15 customer reviews.

Services Offered

Interior PaintingDecksWallpaperExterior PaintingCabinets

Highlights

  • Clear pricing policy
  • Accessible customer support team
  • Informative resources
8 Millrace St N, Williamsville, NY 716-870-0999 classicrenovationsofbuffalo.com
Gould Painting WNY Logo

Gould Painting WNY

4.7/5
Based on 23 customer reviews.

Services Offered

Exterior PaintingDecksPower WashingInterior Painting

Highlights

  • Informative resources
  • Accessible customer support team
  • Clear pricing policy
320 Reist St, Buffalo, NY 716-271-7775 gouldpaintingwny.com
Fresh Wall Paint Logo

Fresh Wall Paint

4.5/5
Based on 26 customer reviews.

Services Offered

Exterior PaintingInterior Painting

Highlights

  • Free quote
  • Clear pricing policy
  • Informative resources
9735 Main St Suite 1cb, Clarence, NY 716-601-9201 freshwallpaint.com
Paint of WNY Logo

Paint of WNY

4.5/5
Based on 79 customer reviews.

Services Offered

Exterior PaintingWallpaperCabinetsInterior Painting

Highlights

  • Prompt service delivery
  • Informative resources
  • Free quote
2205 Hopkins Rd, Getzville, NY 716-219-0801 paintofwny.com

More Local Painting Companies

Carrigan Painting

User Reviews: 4.7/5 

12303 Rapids Rd
Akron, NY 14001

Northeast Pro Painting LLC

User Reviews: 4.7/5 

78 College St
Buffalo, NY 14201

JRB Painting Unlimited

User Reviews: 4.5/5 

414 W Ferry St
Buffalo, NY 14213

Rhino Pro Painting

User Reviews: 4.2/5 

392 Ellicott Creek Rd
Tonawanda, NY 14150

Advantage Paint Services

User Reviews: 4.7/5 

60 Fredericka St
North Tonawanda, NY 14120

Accuracy Painting

User Reviews: 4.7/5 

99 Victory Ave
Hamburg, NY 14075

Painters Plus Home Decorating Inc.

User Reviews: 4.1/5 

800 Walck Rd
North Tonawanda, NY 14120

Queen City Painting & Wash

User Reviews: 4.6/5 

71 Waterford Park
Grand Island, NY 14072

Buffalo Paint Services

User Reviews: 4.7/5 

4379 Lake Ave
Lockport, NY 14094

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviewsteam@thisoldhousereviews.com.

Get Your Painting Project Quote Today

Get matched with a top local pro

Please enter a valid 5-digit zip code!

Facts about Lancaster
Average Max Temp:54°F
Average Min Temp:40°F
Average Daily Sunlight:49%
Average Painting Cost Per Foot:$0.84
Median Year Houses Built:1967

Expert Tips By

This Old House empowers homeowners with the knowledge and tools they need to tackle various projects and navigate the complexities of homeownership.

Services Offered by Professional Painters

Most professional painting companies provide both interior and exterior painting, as well as extra services.

Interior Painting

Professional interior painting contractors can help you decide on interior paint types, textures, and finishes, and can educate you on maintenance requirements to determine what works best where. They can prep, prime, and paint windows, cabinets, door frames, moldings, and trim. Some professionals provide wallpaper or textured finish stripping for an extra fee.

Exterior Painting

Exterior work starts with painters fixing weather damaged areas, stripping paint, plugging leaks with caulk, and cleaning. They then apply paint to window frames, doors, fences, trim, siding, decks, and other outdoor features.

Additional Services

Painters may also offer the following services, depending on their training and experience:
  • Concrete staining
  • Crown molding installation and repair
  • Drywall and plaster repair
  • Popcorn ceiling removal
  • Pressure washing
  • Wallpaper hanging or removal

How To Choose a Painter in Lancaster

When searching for a residential painting company, consider these key factors.
  • Cost: Talk to a few companies to get price estimates. Be wary of exceptionally cheap prices compared to the average.
  • Guarantees: Ensure that you get all guarantees in writing, and that you understand what’s covered and for how long.
  • Paint types: Your painting pro can walk you through the different paint options and their pros and cons to help you determine the best one for your needs. Certain paints, for instance, withstand weather damage more effectively or are more eco-friendly.
  • Qualifications: Verify the company you hire has the licensing required in Lancaster and in the state of New York. Make sure your painter is properly bonded and insured, especially if they’re working with power equipment or on ladders. If your home was built before 1978, and you're concerned about the presence of lead, you may want to look for a contractor who is licensed by the EPA to work with lead-based paint.
  • Reputation and reviews: Ask for references from friends and neighbors, and check the Better Business Bureau (BBB) pages of providers you’re considering. You can also find reviews on sites such as Google Reviews or Trustpilot.

How Much Does Painting Cost in Lancaster?

What you'll pay to paint your house varies depending on its square footage, the kind of paint, and the timing of the job. Paint companies usually charge higher prices between June and August. Both interior and exterior painting jobs typically cost between $0.84 and $3.37 per square foot. Most homes have more interior surface area than exterior surface area, which means the cost to paint inside will be more expensive than the cost to paint outside. The average price to paint a 2,000-square-foot home in Lancaster is $4,207 for outside work and $1,683 to $6,731 for interior work. Some painters in Lancaster may offer alternative rates of $17.75 to $29.58 per hour. Bundling services can lead to savings with these hourly rates. For example, your bill will likely be lower if you schedule exterior and interior painting together rather than separately.

Ready to Get a Quote on Your Painting Project?

Get matched with a top local pro

Please enter a valid 5-digit zip code!

Frequently Asked Questions About Painting in Lancaster

How long does it take to paint a room/house?

It takes an average of four to six hours to paint one 12-foot-by-12-foot room, which means you can multiply this by the number of rooms you're painting to figure out how long the job will take. The total time includes prep work, priming, painting, and cleanup.

Should you tip professional house painters?

Professional house painters don't expect tips, but a small tip or a positive review is often welcomed. Providing the crew with a simple breakfast or lunch is also worth considering to show your appreciation.

Can you negotiate with professional painters?

Some painters may be open to negotiation, particularly if you have quotes from multiple companies or a flexible timeline. Be polite and friendly if you attempt to negotiate.

Is it worth getting a professional painter?

Yes, it's worth it to get a professional painter. While DIY painting can be very straightforward, a professional will get you better results in less time.

What should a painting quote include?

A painting quote should include a list of surfaces that need to be prepared and painted, the approximate dimensions of those surfaces, labor costs, and material costs.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviewsteam@thisoldhousereviews.com.

Sources