TruGreen and Weed Man are two of the most popular lawn care companies in the country. Each company has been around since the 1970s, and over the decades they have built their expertise and expanded their plan offerings. At first glance, they may seem very similar. But which one is right for you?
Ultimately, This Old House Reviews Team recommends TruGreen over Weed Man for its greater availability, ease of customer service, and number of plans. Weed Man is a solid choice, but it can’t match TruGreen’s plans and services. We always recommend reaching out for multiple quotes before making your final decision.
TruGreen vs. Weed Man: Breakdown
|Get Quote||Visit Site||Not available|
|State Availability||49 states||37 states|
TruGreen vs. Weed Man: Overview
TruGreen and Weed Man are both established names in the lawn care industry with decades of experience under their belts.
TruGreen is This Old House Reviews Team’s top recommendation, with five annual plans and a la carte services including pest control, along with bonus customer service offerings like an online chat function and mobile app. TruGreen boasts an extensive FAQs page and lots of information on its site.
TruGreen stands out because unlike its competitors, it offers a variety of annual plans covering everything from soil amendments to aeration in every state except for Alaska. All plans are backed by TruGreen’s Healthy Lawn Guarantee® for full-program customers. That means a TruExpert℠ Certified Specialist, who has undergone an intensive 10-day course, will return to your lawn as many times as needed between treatments to ensure that treatments are effective.
Weed Man Overview
Weed Man began in Ontario before spreading to the UK and America, where it now has over 150 locations in 37 states. While the lawn care company began as a weed control provider, it has grown to cover many services.
In addition to traditional services like fertilization—using a signature granular product—Weed Man offers all kinds of specialized weed control, protecting against everything from nutsedge to dallisgrass. Most lawn care companies offer just basic pre-emergent and targeted weed control.
TruGreen vs. Weed Man: Plans & Services
TruGreen and Weed Man each offer an array of plans. TruGreen offers five distinct annual plans in addition to a la carte services, while Weed Man offers many different independent services as opposed to several comprehensive plans.
|Plans||TruHealth Lawn Care Plan||TruComplete Lawn Care Plan||TruSignature Lawn Care Plan|
|Plans||TruHealth Lawn Care Plan||TruComplete Lawn Care Plan||TruSignature Lawn Care Plan|
|Lime soil amendment||✓||✓||✓|
|Pre-emergent and targeted weed control||✓||✓||✓|
|Tree and shrub services||✓|
TruGreen offers three core annual plans, called the TruHealth℠ Lawn Care Plan, TruComplete℠ Lawn Care Plan, and TruSignature℠ Lawn Care Plan.
In addition, TruGreen offers a standard yearly TruMaintenance℠ Lawn Care Plan, which covers fertilization and pre-emergent and targeted weed control. Homeowners interested in going green may look into the TruNatural℠ Lawn Care Plan. With this plan, specialists use natural fertilizer. You can add weed control to this program at no extra cost.
TruGreen’s a la carte services include:
- Soil Amendment & Analysis
- Tick & Flea Control
- Grub Control & Prevention
- Mosquito Control & Defense Treatment
Weed Man Plans
Weed Man offers tailored plans to homeowners depending on their needs and where they are in the country. Some past include fertilizer, pest management, or weed control, and more. Homeowners with different needs will get different full program treatments.
Weed Man’s lawn services include:
- Weed control
- Moss and unwanted grass control
- Surface insect control
- Core aeration
- White grub treatment and prevention
- Pest control
- Soil care
TruGreen vs. Weed Man: Availability
TruGreen is available in every state except for Alaska.
Weed Man Availability
Weed Man has less availability and currently services 37 different states. The only states where services are not available include:
- New Hampshire
- Rhode Island
- New Mexico
- South Dakota
TruGreen vs. Weed Man: Customer Reviews
TruGreen and Weed Man both have multiple Better Business Bureau (BBB) profiles, each for different locations. BBB-accreditations and ratings vary.
TruGreen’s headquarters page is accredited and holds an A+ rating. Here’s what some customers had to say about TruGreen:
“Great customer service. Totally worth [it] to check out.” –Kryptonitechic
“I have had a great experience with TruGreen. Everyone from the people who answer the phones to the technicians have been very helpful and polite. When I call with a problem, they are eager to do what needs to be done and respond quickly. They have been treating my lawn for buttonweed, which is very hard to get rid of. I have tried unsuccessfully for 10 years to do this on my own with help from garden center supplies, and it only got worse. I am pleased to say that after less than 5 months, they have almost completely eradicated these weeds from my lawn and when I find any coming up again, they send a technician to treat any new seedlings that arise. My lawn is really looking good and I recommend TruGreen for lawn service.” –Dorothy R.
“We were promised a service with applications every 5 weeks with additional applications for weed control at no extra charge. We never got the in between weed control and most recently we were charged 117 rather than 58 for our service then told there was a grub application even though we told them we didn’t want any insect control, just weeds. The call center was very rude when inquiring about the charges, their line was we did a service and charged you for it.” –Brian S.
Weed Man Reviews
Here’s what some customers had to say about Weed Man:
“This is the first year I have used a lawn service since buying my home. I always thought it would cost too much. Weed Man had many plans and I was able to find one that worked in my budget. Before they came out, my lawn was just ugly and I was losing hope. I spoke with a CSR at Weed Man after watching videos on their website and he said they could fix me up. After just a few weeks it looks 100% better. Thanks Weed Man.” –Jason H.
“We were very happy with our lawn care from Weed Man. I think they did a wonderful job. My lawn is beautiful!” –Lorna M.
“This business rings our doorbell multiple times every year no matter how many times we tell them that we do not want their services. They have now begun doing it after 7:30 p.m., when our children are asleep. Their people are clearly uniformed with bright yellow Weed Man logo safety outfits. They hire such young and cheap labor to canvass our neighborhoods that I cannot expect that they desire or expect any sort of quality feedback or performance from them.” –Kevin G.
Ultimately, This Old House Reviews Team believes that TruGreen is the superior option. TruGreen lays out its five annual plans clearly on its site, so customers know exactly what they’re getting. Instead of one basic plan, TruGreen offers multiple, along with numerous a la carte services. TruGreen’s broad national reach gives the company extra appeal, along with the commitment to customer service, including an online chat function and mobile app. If you are dealing with specific weeds like dallisgrass or nutsedge, it may be worth it to call Weed Man.
Our Rating Methodology
To provide readers with the most objective, accurate, and detailed recommendations, the This Old House Reviews Team continually researches lawn care service companies on the market. We take the following steps to obtain up-to-date information about the industry and each company we review:
- Analyze more than 100 customer reviews from third-party review sites, such as Yelp, the Better Business Bureau (BBB), and Google Reviews, for each company
- Secret-shop for lawn care plans and packages to get a sense of cost, offered services, and the overall shopping experience for prospective customers
- Speak with representatives on the phone to simulate the customer service experience from each provider
- Update information on a regular basis to ensure the most accurate information when plans or services change with each company
We use the data from our research to build an in-depth rating system that allows us to score lawn care providers on a 100-point scale. Here are the factors in our evaluation and their designated scores:
- Plan options (30): As one of the most important factors for homeowners shopping for a lawn care service, this one is weighted heavily based on each company’s lawn coverage. Companies that offer more options, such as irrigation, weed control, seeding, and aeration services in addition to a general plan, score higher than others.
- Trustworthiness (30): Each company’s reputation is another significant factor for homeowners to consider before signing up for a plan. We scored providers based on their BBB score, accreditation, and offered guarantees available with each purchase.
- Additional Benefits (20): We gave extra points to companies that provide a few additional services and benefits with their offered plans, such as organic treatments, pest control services, and a mobile app for digital communication and plan management.
- Customer Service (10): In this rating category, we awarded points to customer-focused lawn care service providers who offer weekend availability and easy communication through phones, online chats, and online resources.
- Availability (10): We also scored companies based on their overall availability, rewarding those that are nationally available over local companies only operating in select cities or ZIP codes.
To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at email@example.com.