Most homeowners will need to replace their roof at some point. This is an expensive project, but a good quality roof has a lifespan of a few decades, making it a great investment in your home.
Our guide details the different types of roofing available, how much new roofs cost, and other essential information.
The 9 Best Types of Roofs
These are the best types of roofing materials available according to our research. We’ll go into more detail about each below:
- Asphalt Shingles
- Built-Up Roofing (BUR)
- Clay Tiles
- Concrete Roofing
- Green Roofing
- Metal Roofing
- Slate Roofing
- Solar Roofing
- Wood Roofing
Asphalt shingles are one of the most affordable and common roofing materials, costing $2.08–$3.56 per square foot. Evan Greene, Sales Manager of NE Exteriors for the New England Branch of Long Home Products says, “Asphalt roofing is the best choice in most normal circumstances because it is a healthy balance of cost and quality.”
Asphalt shingles can be made from a variety of materials. Fiberglass shingles are less expensive, while composite shingles made from recycled material are costlier. Higher-priced materials offer longer durability. Asphalt roofs typically last up to 10 years. Asphalt shingle roofs also come in a range of styles, from basic three-tab shingles to high-quality architectural shingles.
Pros and Cons of Asphalt Shingles
✔ Extremely affordable
✔ Lightweight and easy to install
✔ Various options
✘ Not all options have long-term durability
✘ Sensitive to extreme temperature changes
Built-up Roofing (BUR)
Built-up roofing, or BUR roofing, is used primarily for flat roofs. It’s made from multiple layers of asphalt, ply sheets, aggregate, and other materials. BUR roofing protects from ultraviolet damage and has great waterproofing qualities.
The average cost of a BUR roofing system is $3.42–$4.90 per square foot. Most BUR roofs last between 15 and 30 years.
Pros and Cons of Built-Up Roofing (BUR)
✔ Fire-resistant due to aggregate layer
✔ Provides good waterproofing
✘ Long installation process
✘ Relatively short lifespan of 15–30 years
Clay tile roofing, also known as terracotta, is one of the oldest roofing materials. It’s eco-friendly and extremely durable. It’s also fire-resistant and has great thermal properties, making it common in hot climates or areas with wildfires.
Clay roofing can be very expensive, costing an average of $5.90–$14.68 per square foot. However, clay tile roofs are extremely long-lasting, with lifespans of 50–100 years.
Pros and Cons of Clay Tiles
✔ Durable and long-lasting with great curb appeal
✔ Eco-friendly material with insulating qualities that maximize energy efficiency
✔ Low-maintenance with fire and rot resistance
✘ Heavy material that may require additional structural support
Concrete roofing has a long lifespan and generally lasts about 50 years. Concrete tiles also have great thermal properties: They slowly absorb and emit heat, helping you to increase your energy efficiency and save on electricity bills. However, if concrete roofing is not installed or maintained properly, it can leave the underlayment of your roof susceptible to water damage.
Concrete tiles cost an average of $5.16–$8.60 per square foot. Although they’re expensive and require some maintenance, concrete tiles can offer a great return on investment (ROI) and add property value.
Pros and Cons of Concrete Roofing
✔ Eco-friendly material that can be recycled
✔ Long lifespan and durable in many climates
✔ Wide range of styles and colors
✘ Requires maintenance to prevent mildew and algae
✘ Weight can require additional structural support
Green roofing is relatively new to the United States, but it’s growing in popularity. Green roofs are made from plants and other vegetation. They offer a variety of benefits to homeowners.
Green roofs cost $10–$28 per square foot. Though this is on the high end of the cost spectrum, green roofs are made to increase energy efficiency. The savings on your electricity bill can offset the initial costs.
Pros and Cons of Green Roofing
✔ Environmental pollutants are absorbed before entering your home
✔ Improved energy efficiency and reduced utility costs
✔ Noise reducing properties can filter out unwanted environmental noise
✘ Regular maintenance required for optimum performance
✘ Susceptible to water damage
Metal roofs have a life expectancy of 30–50 years, making them a great investment. These roofs come in many styles and materials. All options promise durability, easy maintenance, and fire and weather resistance. Metal roofs also help lower your utility costs. “Metal roofing is the most energy-efficient type of roofing. Reflection of sunlight will lower surface temperatures on a roof and subsequently reduce attic temperatures, lowering energy costs,” says John Foley, New England Branch Manager, Long Home Products. Metal roofs cost $9–$14.60 per square foot.
Pros and Cons of Metal Roofing
✔ Lightweight and doesn’t require additional support
✔ Maintenance is straightforward and simple
✔ Reflects heat and can lower cooling costs
✘ Expansion and contraction from environmental factors can stress the material
✘ Installation can be difficult and require a specialist
Natural slate roofing lasts more than 100 years and is generally known as the highest quality roofing material. However, slate tiles are also one of the most expensive options, costing $7.56–$18.70 per square foot.
Pros and Cons of Slate Roofing
✔ Beautiful aesthetic
✔ Extremely long lifespan of 100+ years
✔ Natural, eco-friendly material
✘ Exceptionally fragile if handled improperly
✘ Requires specialty knowledge for proper installation
Solar roofing is a great option for homeowners converting to solar power who want to maintain their home’s aesthetics. This roofing mimics traditional roofing design but generates energy like traditional solar panels. It costs $16.10–$20.85 per square foot and is available from some of the best and most reputable solar companies.
Pros and Cons of Solar Roofing
✔ Energy generating and eco-friendly
✔ Great aesthetic alternative to solar panels
✔ Won’t break if stepped on
✘ Installation requires a trained specialist
✘ New technology with little information regarding longevity
There are two main types of wooden roofing material: wooden shingles and wooden shakes. Wood shingles are typically thinner than wood shakes and are sawed by a machine on both sides. A shake is hand split on only one side. Shakes are better in certain weather conditions, such as high wind.
Cedar shakes are some of the most common types of wooden roofing material. Wood shingles and shakes can also be made from spruce, redwood, pine, or other coniferous trees. Regardless of which option you choose, wooden roofs cost $6.53–$9.90 per square foot.
Pros and Cons of Wood Roofing
✔ Easy to install and transport
✔ Extremely resistant to high winds, rot, and mold
✔ Naturally insulating, lowering heating and cooling costs
✘ Can be prone to wood-loving insect infestations
✘ Susceptible to fire damage, which can make them hard to insure
Free Quote: Get your roofing quote today
Compare Roof Types
Each type of roofing ranges in price and durability. Compare the costs and lifespan of each roofing type below.
|Asphalt Shingles||$2.08–$3.50||20–30 years|
|Built-up Roofing (BUR)||$3.42–$4.90||15–30 years|
|Clay Tiles||$5.90–$14.68||50–100 years|
|Concrete Roofing||$5.16–$8.60||50 years|
|Green Roofing||$10–$28||40 years|
|Metal Roofing||$9–$14.60||40–70 years|
|Slate Roofing||$7.56–$18.70||75–200 years|
|Solar Roofing||$16.10–$20.85||25–30 years*|
|Wood Roofing||$6.53–$9.90||15–30 years|
*Solar roofing lifespan is a general estimate. Solar roofing is a technology that is only 10 years old.
Your roof’s lifespan can vary depending on how well you maintain it. Some roofing materials require more maintenance than others. If not maintained properly, your roof may need replacement sooner rather than later.
When To Replace Your Roof
It’s best to repair or replace your roof promptly to prevent further damage. Here are some signs of roof damage:
- Active leaks or water stains in your attic or ceiling
- Asphalt shingle granules in your gutters
- Ice dams or ridges that prevent proper runoff
- Increased energy bills unrelated to an HVAC issue
- Mildew or moss in any area where sections of your roof meet
- Pools of water on your roof
- Visible holes, tears, cracks, or other damage to your shingles
- Visible sagging of your roofline
It’s a good idea to call a professional to inspect your roof if you notice any of these signs.
DIY vs. Professional Replacement
You may be able to do some roof repairs yourself, depending on which type you have. However, it’s best to leave total roof replacement up to the professionals. Roofing contractors have specialized equipment, such as scaffolding and pulleys. They also have the knowledge and experience to do the job properly. Some roof types must be installed by approved contractors to maintain the product warranty.
An improperly installed roof can cause major problems in the future. For example, water could get into the roof deck and internal structure and cause mold, rot, or other damage. Installing a roof on your own may even compromise your home insurance policy. Though labor costs can be expensive, having a professional roofer do the job is worth it.
See a breakdown of different roof types and parts below, as illustrated in our Learn the Basics of Roof Systems article.
Roof replacement can be expensive, but it’s imperative that it’s done correctly or you could face major problems down the road. There are plenty of roofing types available to fit your budget and needs. Choosing the right kind and hiring a professional installer will provide you with the peace of mind that your home is protected for years to come.
Free Quote: Get your roofing quote today