clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

The 5 Best Mailboxes (2023 Review)

If you’re looking to replace your current mailbox with one that has a large capacity, includes more security features, or abides by federal standards, we’re here to help. In this review, the This Old House Reviews Team researched the best mailboxes on Amazon to help you find the product that’s right for you.

Mail Boss Mailbox and Polar Aurora Mailbox against a beige graph-paper background Courtesy Amazon

Mailboxes are something everyone needs, but maybe not something everyone thinks about. Whether your current one is too small or starting to rust, it’s time for an upgrade.

To help you decide on a model, the This Old House Reviews Team researched the best mailboxes on Amazon. Here are our top picks.

Compare Top Mailboxes

Product Materials Weight Compartments Accessories
Product Materials Weight Compartments Accessories
Mail Boss Mailbox Steel 22 pounds 2 Mail clip and three keys
Architectural Mailboxes Mailbox Steel 8.7 pounds 2 Mail clip and two keys
Polar Aurora Mailbox Aluminum and iron 18.3 pounds 1 Two keys
Architectural Mailboxes Parcel Mailbox Steel and aluminum 11.3 pounds 2 Mail clip and four keys
Gibraltar Mailboxes Mailbox Steel 2 pounds 1 Not included

Top 5 Mailboxes


Most Customizable: Mail Boss Mailbox

Mail Boss Mailbox

Mail Boss Mailbox

  • $110

Prices taken at time of publishing.

This locking mailbox features a galvanized steel body and an anti-pry latch to prevent your personal mail from ending up in the wrong hands. It contains two storage areas that hold several weeks’ worth of mail. It also comes with the screws necessary for installation and can also be purchased with a bar or mounting post.

Courtesy Amazon

Pros and Cons

✔ Includes three keys
✔ Contains two storage areas to hold a lot of mail
✔ Comes with an outgoing mail clip

✘ Doesn’t look decorative
✘ Weighs over 20 pounds, making lifting it for installation more difficult

What Customers Are Saying

Many customers liked that this mailbox was durable. One homeowner even said that it held up after being hit by a truck. Others liked that it had security features and was easy to install. However, some customers said that the storage compartments retained too much water after rainstorms and that the mail drop area was too small.


Best Oversized: Architectural Mailboxes Mailbox

Architectural Mailboxes Mailbox

Architectural Mailboxes Mailbox

  • $124

Prices taken at time of publishing.

When security and practicality are priorities, consider this mailbox. Not only is it roomy, but it’s constructed to be tamperproof, durable, and water-resistant. This model is an excellent choice for business owners who receive a lot of business mail at their home address.

Courtesy Amazon

Pros and Cons

✔ Comes fully assembled
✔ Built to be tamper-resistant with a stainless-steel lock
✔ Is weather-resistant against extreme conditions

✘ Doesn’t come with the mounting post
✘ Has a bulky design

What Customers Are Saying

Customers who left positive reviews for this mailbox said that it was sturdy, had useful security features, and kept mail dry. However, those who left negative reviews claimed that mail sometimes stuck out of the bottom of it. Other customers didn’t receive all of the hardware needed for installation.


Most Decorative: Polar Aurora Mailbox

Polar Aurora Mailbox

Polar Aurora Mailbox

  • $166

Prices taken at time of publishing.

This stylish mailbox contains a rust-resistant base that can withstand precipitation. It also comes with mounting bolt holes to secure it in concrete to protect it from high winds and other extreme weather conditions. This mailbox also has a locking door that unlocks with two keys, so multiple people can have access.

Courtesy Amazon

Pros and Cons

✔ Has a rust-proof base that can withstand precipitation
✔ Comes with mounting bolts
✔ Has a carved scene with a man on a horse

✘ Doesn’t have an outgoing mail flag
✘ Has to be bolted to concrete

What Customers Are Saying

Amazon customers said that this mailbox was sturdy, had an attractive design, and offered a roomy storage area. However, those who gave this product negative reviews had issues replacing the keys when they got lost.


Best Accessories: Architectural Mailboxes Parcel Mailbox

Architectural Mailboxes Parcel Mailbox

Architectural Mailboxes Parcel Mailbox

  • $160

Prices taken at time of publishing.

This galvanized steel mailbox comes in multiple pewter (pictured), black, rubbed bronze, or white finished, contains accessible front- and rear-locking doors, and has pre-drilled mounting holes. It also has a magnetic door that keeps mail secure.

Courtesy Amazon

Pros and Cons

✔ Includes a concealed outgoing mail clip
✔ Has a powder-coated exterior for durability and longevity
✔ Can hold small packages and thick envelopes

✘ Has a weak locking mechanism that could be pried open
✘ Doesn’t come with mounting hardware

What Customers Are Saying

Positive reviews said that this mailbox was secure because it was made from durable materials. Customers also liked that it came with four keys for large households. However, those who gave it negative reviews claimed that determined thieves could get in through the rear door. Others said that the locks were flimsy.


Best Wall-Mounted: Gibraltar Mailboxes Mailbox

Gibraltar Mailboxes Mailbox

Gibraltar Mailboxes Mailbox

  • $20

Prices taken at time of publishing.

This convenient mailbox features an easy-lift tab for depositing mail and a concealed lock for securing its contents. This model can hold low-volume letters and magazines, making it great for small households. In addition to its protective design, it has a lightweight, two-pound frame.

Courtesy Amazon

Pros and Cons

✔ Has an easy-lift tab for depositing mail
✔ Comes with a concealed lock
✔ Has a lightweight 2-pound frame

✘ Makes the mail carrier’s job harder for package delivery
✘ Can’t hold more than a few pieces of mail

What Customers Are Saying

Most customers liked this mailbox’s easy access and compact size. However, some customers left negative reviews, claiming that its poor design made it difficult to install next to their front door.


Buyer’s Guide

Before purchasing a mailbox, consider the following factors.

Type

There are a wide variety of mailbox designs, including curbside, wall-mounted, and combo models. Curbside mailboxes mount to wooden or steel posts and are positioned at the front of your yard for simple mail drop-off. These mailboxes require an additional purchase for a post and sometimes offer unique features, such as locking or rear-facing doors.

Wall-mounted mailboxes are selected over curbside models because of their convenience and protection. Since they’re installed on the front of your home, they are less likely to be damaged by passing cars and are easier to access. This type of mailbox requires hardware and a mounting plate for installation.

Combo models include a curbside mailbox and an accompanying post. The two are packaged together to prevent you from needing to purchase a separate post, ultimately saving you time and money.

Material

Mailboxes are constructed from several materials, with steel and plastic being the most common. Steel is a durable heavy-duty material that protects your mail from the elements. Plastic mailboxes, while less durable than steel, are more affordable and have long-lasting properties. There are also high-quality metal mailboxes or cast aluminum mailboxes available.

Safety Features

Many mailboxes include safety features that prevent people from stealing your mail. The most common feature is a locking door that requires a key for access.

Rear Access

This optional feature is convenient for homeowners who live on a busy street. Rear access gives you the option to safely pick up your mail without having to reach around to the street-facing side of the mailbox.

Color and Design

Mailboxes are designed to be practical, but they can also serve as a decorative accent in the front of your home. With respect to local rules and regulations, the color and styling of your mailbox should complement your home’s exterior. Since your mailbox is one of the first elements that visitors and passersby notice about your home, a nicely designed and well-maintained mailbox sends the message that you take care of your house.

Most mailboxes come in natural colors like white, black, gray, or brown. However, a solid red, blue, yellow, or green mailbox to match your house may also look good.

Height

Mailboxes should be positioned so that they are easily accessible for both you and the mail carrier. The USPS recommends positioning your mailbox 41 to 45 inches from the road surface to the bottom of the box or point of mail entry.


Figuring Out The Right Mailbox Size

Having a correctly sized mailbox for your needs is important. If your mailbox is too small, you’ll find it has minimal functionality and you may need to travel to your local post office for anything larger than a standard envelope. However, an overly large mailbox could make your home a potential target for thieves or vandals. In any case, you’ll also need to conform to the United States Postal Service (USPS) and homeowner association (if applicable) standards.

The good news is that there are several size options available that check most of these boxes. At the minimum, your mailbox should be large enough to fit a standard flat-rate envelope with the door closed without bending it. The USPS standard flat-rate envelope measures 9.5 inches by 12.5 inches. Below are some other size guidelines:

Wall-Mounted Mailboxes

Most sufficiently sized wall-mounted mailboxes are four to five inches deep. The height of these mailboxes varies anywhere from nine to 15 inches with a width of nine to 18 inches.

Curbside Mailboxes

The minimum size for a standard curbside mailbox is 18.5 inches in length, six inches in width, and eight inches in height. We recommend opting for a curbside mailbox that’s at least slightly larger than this, however, because this minimum size isn’t big enough to accommodate a flat-rate envelope without bending it.


Frequently Asked Questions

Can I install a mailbox on my house?

According to the USPS, if you want to use a wall-mounted mailbox, you must first get a postmaster’s permission to relocate your current curbside mailbox. Once the new mailbox is approved, install it in plain sight near your home’s main entrance.

How do I secure my mailbox?

The best way to ensure that your mail is safe is by purchasing a locking mailbox or other high-security mailbox. Locking mailboxes have pry-resistant locking doors that can only be accessed with a personalized key.

Is my mailbox owned by the USPS?

You’re responsible for your mailbox’s maintenance if it’s installed on personal property. However, some mailboxes, such as those in a centralized location of a neighborhood, are owned and maintained by the USPS. To find out whether or not your mailbox is owned by the postal service, contact your local post office.

What do I do if my mailbox is vandalized?

Mailbox vandalism is a federal crime—violators are subject to a $250,000 fine and up to three years in prison. If you’ve discovered damage to your mailbox, immediately report it to the United States Postal Inspection Service.

Is it necessary to clean my mailbox?

Generally, no. Unless something spills or makes a mess in or on your mailbox, you’re not expected to regularly clean it. However, mailboxes do collect dust and dirt, so it’s worth occasionally wiping a damp rag across all of the surfaces of your mailbox when it’s empty. You can dampen the rag with soap and water or a mild all-purpose spray cleaner.


Why Trust The This Old House Reviews Team

This Old House has empowered homeowners for more than four decades with top-notch home improvement content in the form of television programs, print media, and digital content on its website and social media platforms. The This Old House Reviews Team focuses on creating in-depth product and service review content to help inform your purchasing decision for just about any item or resource that you might need for your home. The This Old House Reviews Team has written over 1,000 reviews on products in the home space, from cordless drills to kitchen trash cans, lawn mowers, and dining room decorations.

We recommend products in each review using an intensive research process, spending hours combing through the best available models on Amazon. For a product to make our list of top picks, it must hold a solid sales record on Amazon, have consistently positive customer reviews, and offer unique features, among other factors. After narrowing down our list of recommendations, we conduct additional research and sometimes in-person testing to ensure that the products meet our standards. Once we conclude the research phase, we craft a well-rounded, user-friendly article that includes our recommended products and additional information to help homeowners like you make the right purchase.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.