clock menu more-arrow no yes

The 5 Best Gift Baskets (2022 Review)

Gift baskets are an easy way to tell someone you’re thinking about them. In this review, the This Old House Reviews Team researched the five best gift baskets on Amazon to help you find the product that’s right for your loved one. The products included in this article are available at various retail stores, local home centers, and online retailers like Amazon.

Gift basket Courtesy Amazon

Whether you need a last-minute gift, aren’t sure what to get someone, or want to surprise a loved one, a gift basket is a versatile present. To help you select a basket that’s right for the occasion, the This Old House Reviews Team researched the best gift baskets on Amazon. Here are our top five recommendations.

Best Non-Food Gift Basket: Burt’s Bees Classics Gift Set

This gift basket is a solid choice if you’re buying for someone who would prefer beauty products over food. It contains several Burt’s Bees’ skincare items, including hand repair cream, foot cream, lip balm, and cuticle cream.

Key Features

  • Includes hand repair cream, foot cream, hand salve, lip balm, cuticle cream, and Res-Q ointment
  • Comes in a tin box
  • Features paper strips in the box for padding

What Customers Are Saying

This gift basket has over 47,000 reviews on Amazon and holds an overall rating of 4.7 stars out of 5 stars. Among reviewers, 93% left a 4- or 5-star rating, while 2% left a 1- or 2-star rating.

Those happy with this gift basket said that the products worked well on sensitive skin and had a pleasant scent. Customers also liked that the products came in small sizes because they could travel with them. However, some customers said that the basket arrived with missing items or that it wasn’t well-packaged.

Best Chocolate Gift Basket: Bonnie and Pop Chocolate Gift Basket

This gift basket set will satisfy the sweet tooth of anyone on your shopping list. It features a wide variety of chocolates ranging from white and dark chocolate truffles to sea salt caramels. The tin the chocolates come in has compartments to separate the different treats.

Key Features

  • Includes pretzel clouds, peanut butter squares, peppermint patties, double dark silk chocolates, English toffees, peanut clusters, chocolate haystacks, butter pecan clusters, dark chocolate pretzels, sea salt caramels, cashew clusters, and pecan clusters
  • Comes in a tin box
  • Features compartments in the box

What Customers Are Saying

Out of nearly 5,000 reviews, this product holds an average rating of 4.6 stars out of 5 stars. Reviewers on Amazon left 4- or 5-star reviews 91% of the time and 1- or 2-star reviews 4% of the time.

Customers liked that this gift basket had a wide variety of chocolates and that the chocolates arrived fresh. They also appreciated that the chocolates came labeled. However, some customers said that the basket came with fewer items than expected and that some of the items were overly sweet.

Best Fruit and Nut Gift Basket: Oh! Nuts Holiday Nut and Dried Fruit Gift Basket

Some people aren’t fans of sweets, so this gift basket provides a healthier alternative. This basket includes dried fruits, such as kiwi, papaya, apricot, and pistachio and almond nuts.

Key Features

  • Includes dates, papayas, peaches, apples, apricots, cranberries, pineapple, kiwis, pears, plums, pistachios, and almonds
  • Comes in a paper box
  • Features compartments in the box

What Customers Are Saying

This gift basket has over 7,400 reviews on Amazon with an overall rating of 4.5 stars out of 5 stars. It received 4- or 5-star reviews 86% of the time and 1- or 2-star reviews 7% of the time.

Happy customers liked this gift basket’s wide variety of vegan-friendly items and reusable box. Those who didn’t like it said that the fruit sometimes arrived stale and that the box sometimes had an unpleasant smell.

Best Coffee Gift Basket: California Delicious Starbucks Daybreak Gourmet Coffee Gift Basket

Coffee lovers will thank you for this gift basket that comes with various Starbucks coffee blends and a Starbucks mug. It also includes tea to keep your loved ones caffeinated for days to come.

Key Features

  • Includes Starbucks Cafe Verona coffee, Starbucks House Blend coffee, Starbucks Sumatra coffee, a coffee mug, biscotti cookies, shortbread cookies, and Tazo or Teavana tea
  • Comes in a basket
  • Features a decorative ribbon on the basket

What Customers Are Saying

This product has nearly 1,500 reviews with an average rating of 4.5 stars out of 5 stars. Customers left 4- or 5-star reviews 88% of the time, while 6% of reviewers gave it 1- or 2-star ratings.

Those who were happy with this gift basket liked its variety of coffee flavors, tight packaging, and included ceramic mug. However, those who didn’t like this product said that it sometimes arrived with fewer items than expected. They also felt like the box that held the items was cheap.

Best Cheese Gift Basket: Wisconsin Cheese Company Deluxe Cheese and Crackers Gift Basket

With two four-ounce blocks of cheddar and pepper jack cheeses each, a box of wafer crackers, and a box of savory garlic and herb crackers, this basket makes a delightful gift for any foodie in your life. It also comes with other snack items, such as spreadable mustard and dippable pretzels.

Key Features

  • Includes cheddar cheese, pepper jack cheese, mustard, pretzels, and crackers
  • Comes in a basket
  • Features paper strips in the basket for padding

What Customers Are Saying

This gift basket has an overall rating of 4.4 stars out of 5 stars from over 200 Amazon customers. Reviewers rated this product 4 or 5 stars 83% of the time and 1 or 2 stars 9% of the time.

Satisfied customers were impressed by the mustards and the fact that the box arrived quickly and well-packaged. However, some customers claimed that this gift basket was overpriced for the amount of food it provided. Many were also unhappy that the cheese was pasteurized.

Buyer’s Guide

When deciding on which gift basket is best for your family member or friend, consider some of the following factors.

Type

Although gift baskets can include a variety of items, some of the most popular themes are:

Non-Food

Gift baskets that don’t come with food typically have flowers, plants, stuffed animals, bath products, beauty products, or candles in them.

Chocolate

Chocolate gift bags typically come with various chocolate-themed sweets, such as chocolate-covered strawberries and caramel candies.

Charcuterie

These baskets typically come with snacks that you would put on charcuterie or cheese boards, such as crackers, cheese, and meat.

Fruit and Nut

Fruit and nut baskets are a healthier alternative to other food-related gift baskets. They typically contained roasted or flavored nuts and dried fruits.

Size

Once you’ve determined which type of basket is best for your loved one, you’ll need to decide how big you want it to be. If you’re buying for one person, you won’t want to overwhelm them with too many items, especially if the basket is food-related. However, if you’re buying for a group, be sure to get enough for everyone to try each item.

Variety

Some gift baskets specialize in a certain item, such as chocolate. This can be a great choice if you know what the person you’re buying for likes. However, if you’re getting a gift basket for someone you don’t know as well or for multiple people, you may be better off with one that has a variety of items. This makes it more likely that there will be something for everyone to enjoy.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are gift baskets customizable?

Gift baskets usually contain a specific assortment of items curated by the company making them. However, some companies allow you to fully customize the basket, switch out a few items, or add personalized messages.

Can gift baskets be delivered to hospitals and hotels?

Gift baskets can usually ship anywhere. However, if you’re shipping one to a hospital, hotel, or dorm room, be sure to leave specific instructions about how to deliver it. Depending on the establishment, they may deliver it directly to the intended recipient or hold it at the front desk for pickup.

How do you make a DIY gift basket?

If you want to give someone a gift basket but can’t find one that matches what you’re looking for, try making one yourself. To build your own gift basket, start by purchasing a basket, box, or bag to hold the items. Then, add items to the container that match the interests of the recipient. You can either stick with a particular theme or mix and match items.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.