Metal roofs offer significant durability, but their sleek surfaces create water runoff that can overwhelm your gutter system. LeafFilter is our pick for the best gutter guards for metal roofs, with a stainless steel micromesh screen that prevents debris as small as pollen from entering gutters while handling heavy water flow. For a more budget-conscious approach, All American Gutter Protection’s micro-mesh guard delivers professional-grade filtration.
Our team evaluated 16 major gutter guard manufacturers to identify the best gutter guards for metal roofs. We tested 12 brands hands-on, reviewed customer feedback, spoke with installers, and consulted roofing experts to assess how each system manages water flow and prevents clogs. Through our extensive testing and research, we found that micromesh guards consistently outperform and provide better functionality than other styles on metal roofs.
Top Gutter Guard Providers for Metal Roofs
Here’s the list of our top picks for gutter guards specifically designed for metal roofs, ranked by overall performance and customer satisfaction. Each company offers unique benefits, from advanced filtration technology to comprehensive service packages.
- LeafFilter: Best Overall
- Gutter Guards America: Best Customer Review Scores
- Leafguard: Best for Self-Cleaning
- HomeCraft Gutter Protection: Best Add-On Services
- All American Gutter Protection: Best Deals and Discounts
Comparing The Best Gutter Guard Providers
Compare how these leading gutter cover providers stack up across key factors such as our team’s rating, Better Business Bureau (BBB) ratings, average installation costs, and types of gutter guards offered. Each company earned a spot on our list based on our team’s brand research, product testing, and customer feedback analysis.
| Provider | Star Rating (Out of 5) | BBB Rating* | Price Range** | Filter Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
A+ | $16.80 per linear foot | Micromesh with uPVC frame | ||
A+ | $16.25 per linear foot | Micromesh | ||
A+ | $16.31 per linear foot | Integrated with gutters, micromesh | ||
A+ | $15.68 per linear foot | Micromesh | ||
A | $15.77 per linear foot | Micromesh |
*The Better Business Bureau (BBB) is an independent organization that evaluates businesses’ credibility and responsiveness to customers. Ratings are accurate as of February 2025.
**Price ranges based on responses to our 2025 survey of nearly 1,500 homeowners with gutter guard protection systems.
Our Reviews of Top Gutter Guards for Metal Roofs
After extensive hands-on testing, we ranked gutter guards based on their ability to handle heavy water flow off metal roofs while preventing debris buildups. Our ranking prioritizes systems with superior water management and corrosion-resistant materials, particularly favoring micromesh designs that can withstand the increased runoff of typical metal roofing.
LeafFilter
LeafFilter’s 275-micron stainless steel mesh screen effectively manages the intense water flow from metal roofs while blocking the smallest debris. Our testing showed this system prevented 99% of particles from entering gutters without overflowing, even during downpours.
Provider Overview
- Uses surgical-grade stainless steel micromesh paired with a patented three-piece system for maximum filtration
- Includes professional measurement, custom cutting, and installation by certified technicians
- Offers a transferable lifetime warranty that promises a complete refund or replacement if the system fails
Keep in Mind
- May charge higher prices than some competitors, according to our survey data
- Sales representatives may quote high initial prices before offering discounts, based on several customer reviews
Our Review
LeafFilter offers a three-piece system that sets it apart from standard gutter guards. The micromesh screen sits on a reinforced internal support frame, while a unplasticized polyvinyl chloride (uPVC) frame provides structural stability without risking corrosion against metal roofing materials. This design prevents sagging and creates proper water flow angles, particularly important for handling increased runoff from metal roofs.
The company’s installation process involves careful measurement and custom-cutting of materials to fit each home’s specific gutter dimensions. Technicians also perform a thorough gutter cleaning and structural inspection before installation, replacing any damaged sections to ensure optimal performance. However, LeafFilter’s focus solely on gutter guards means homeowners need separate contractors for other gutter services.
Customer Experiences
LeafFilter maintains thousands of reviews online, with a 3.7 out of 5-star rating on the BBB based on 6,900 reviews, and a 4.3 out of 5-star rating from over 126,000 Trustpilot reviews, as of this writing. Satisfied customers praise the system’s debris-blocking capabilities and professional installation quality, while critical feedback centers on aggressive sales tactics and inconsistent pricing.
“Timeliness of the job and professionalism of the team was 5 stars. They communicated extremely well through the process. Would recommend the product and company.” —Eric J. via Trustpilot, January 2025
“Poor sales tactics of starting at a really high number and working down to make it not seem as bad. High pressure to sign the day of. Not responding to anything after I paid when issues occurred. Lots of grit from the shingles stay[ing] [on] the corners and have not seen much of it wash off. Not sure if the product properly works yet. Had issues with diverters causing tons of grit collecting and asked to remove it and never heard back and had to do it myself.” —Guillaume via Trustpilot, January 2025
Gutter Guards America
Gutter Guards America distinguishes itself with a wave-patterned micro-mesh design that promotes self-cleaning while managing heavy water flow. The surgical-grade stainless steel construction paired with a reinforced substructure makes it particularly suitable for metal roofs and any increased runoff.
Provider Overview
- Uses a patented wave pattern in the mesh to improve water flow and debris removal
- Provides comprehensive services, including gutter installation and roof repair
- Includes military-grade mounting brackets for enhanced stability
- Offers seamless gutter installation in multiple styles and materials
Keep in Mind
- Installation quality varies by location based on customer feedback
- Limited service area compared to national providers, including Georgia, North Carolina, Ohio, and South Carolina
Our Review
Gutter Guards America’s gutter guard system combines durability with innovative design features. The wave-patterned mesh creates multiple channels for water flow while preventing debris accumulation, addressing common issues with metal roof runoff. A reinforced aluminum frame provides structural support without compromising the system’s water management capabilities.
The company’s comprehensive approach also extends beyond guard installation to include full gutter services and roof repairs. This integration is valuable for owners of homes with metal roofs, as proper gutter system alignment and support is important for optimal performance. The installation teams thoroughly inspect your existing gutters and roof’s fascia boards before mounting new gutters to verify proper water flow angles and secure attachment.
Customer Experiences
Though Gutter Guards America has fewer total reviews than some competitors, its ratings remain consistently high. The company maintains a 4.4 out of 5-star rating on Trustpilot from over 700 reviews, as of this writing. About 87% of reviewers left the company with 4 or 5-star ratings, showing that most customers seem satisfied with their systems and performance. However, some customers mentioned issues with communication and installation.
“Would highly recommend—the crew did an amazing job and they kept the area clean. Our roof looks wonderful [and I] can’t wait for them to install gutters. When they left there wasn’t a nail to be found—vvery thorough clean up. Roof looks wonderful” —Alison A. via Trustpilot, January 2025
“The work is not completed to my satisfaction and the service manager tells me one thing and doesn’t follow through. Meanwhile I have a section of gutter holding water and soffit that is falling off the house and multiple other areas of concern. I would appreciate a follow up from someone.” —Adam M. via Trustpilot, August 2024
Leafguard
Leafguard’s one-piece design integrates guards directly into the gutter system, creating a streamlined solution for metal roofs. This built-in approach eliminates installation gaps and prevents debris accumulation at connection points.
Provider Overview
- Features a patented curved hood design that uses surface tension to direct water into gutters
- Manufactures custom-fit gutters on-site to match exact home specifications
- Includes full gutter replacement with every installation, eliminating existing system issues
- Uses thick aluminum construction tested to handle over 32 inches of rain per hour
Keep in Mind
- Requires complete replacement of existing gutters, which can increase initial costs and installation times
- Offers limited color options compared to competitors
Our Review
Leafguard’s integrated gutter system differentiates itself through its curved, one-piece construction. Rather than retrofitting guards onto existing gutters, technicians custom-manufacture new gutters with built-in protection at each installation site. This method creates a seamless barrier against debris while maintaining proper water flow.
While the initial cost runs higher because of the full gutter replacement, the system provides comprehensive protection against both small and large debris. The reverse-curve design proves particularly effective at managing pine needles and leaves, though its water intake capacity may require adjustment for the increased flow from metal roofs. Each installation includes removing your old gutters, inspecting fascia boards, and securing the new system with internal hangers spaced every two feet for maximum stability.
Customer Experiences
Leafguard has mixed customer ratings on the BBB and Trustpilot, with varying feedback about its performance and service. Reviews suggest similar patterns, with customers particularly noting the systems’ durability and appearance, while some mention concerns about water leakage and high pricing.
“My experience with Leafguard was one of the best ones that I’ve had in a while. The presentation made by [a representative] was very thorough. He was extremely personable and knowledgeable. My husband and I felt like we were making a worthy investment with all of that the product offers. … Right from the get go he asked us questions to get to know our needs and see what we were looking for before speaking about the sale. … They are also very quick with installation.” —Tiffanie S. via Trustpilot, December 2024
“Leafguard says that if you purchase their gutter system, you are protected for life—don’t believe their sales pitch. I made the mistake of purchasing their overpriced gutters four years ago and I have suffered for it ever since. Due to the water leaking behind and from the bottom of their gutters, the landscaping bricks next to my foundation are sinking. Therefore anything sitting on the bricks is sinking too, like my propane tan and front steps. I have contacted them several times. They came out a couple times with a caulking gun, [but] it did not resolve the issue. They blamed it on my roof and said I needed to get a new roof. I did not have this sinking problem before, only when I got their gutters that are supposed to protect your foundation, and all it has done is damage mine…” —Sharon O. via the BBB, January 2025
HomeCraft Gutter Protection
HomeCraft pairs its gutter protection system with comprehensive maintenance services, making it ideal for homeowners seeking complete gutter solutions. Its 304-marine-grade stainless steel mesh with a raised diamond pattern handles metal roof runoff while providing structural durability.
Provider Overview
- Uses medical-grade stainless steel with a powder-coated aluminum frame
- Provides full-service gutter solutions, including cleaning, repair, and installation
- Features built-in pitch for improved debris shedding and reinforcing hangers for added stability
Keep in Mind
- Some customers see higher average cost compared to similar systems, based on customer reviews
- Only available in 12 U.S. states
Our Review
HomeCraft’s gutter guard design incorporates multiple elements to manage water flow from metal roofs. The raised diamond pattern creates channels for water passage while promoting debris removal, though our team’s testing suggests this feature provides a minimal advantage over standard micro-mesh design. The marine-grade stainless steel construction resists corrosion and withstands constant moisture exposure.
The company’s comprehensive service approach distinguishes it from competitors. Beyond guard installation, HomeCraft handles gutter cleaning, repairs, and full system replacements. Company technicians evaluate existing gutters and downspouts during the installation, addressing potential issues that could affect your system performance. This integrated approach helps prevent common problems associated with metal roof drainage systems.
Customer Experiences
HomeCraft holds a 4.2 out of 5-star rating on Trustpilot with over 250 reviews, as of this writing. Customers frequently mention the company’s sales team’s knowledge and installation quality, though some report difficulties with post-installation communication.
“Great experience and product. [The] team did a great job working through some steep slopes and around a shed to complete the installation. Nothing could have stopped them from finishing the job. Appreciate their hard work and follow up call to confirm the install went well.” —Sean S. via Trustpilot, March 2022
“Nice presentation but poor customer service. Guards were installed under the shingle, making them curl up and voiding my roof warranty. [They were] installed at such an angle that rain water runs over and looks terrible from the street. Heavy winds blew one guard partially out. [I] question whether gutters were ever cleaned before install—had to clean [them] because they were not draining properly.” —William L. via Trustpilot, June 2023
All American Gutter Protection
All American Gutter Protection combines solid performance with competitive pricing and multiple discount programs. The company’s reinforced micro-mesh design can suit metal roofs in regions with moderate rainfall, though capacity limits may affect homes in areas with frequent heavy storms.
Provider Overview
- Offers aluminum gutters in over 30 color options to match various home aesthetics
- Uses military-grade aluminum frames with reinforced support brackets
- Provides several discount programs, including military, senior, and seasonal offers
- Includes full measurement and inspection services before installation
Keep in Mind
- Limited service area compared to larger national brands, which includes 20 states
- Does not offer additional services such as gutter cleaning or repairs
Our Review
All American’s gutter guard system features a reinforced substructure that adds stability and impact resistance. The micromesh screen effectively filters debris while allowing water passage, though its design may restrict flow during peak rainfall compared to other systems. This limitation can make these products better suited for regions with moderate rain.
The company sets itself apart through competitive pricing and extensive customization options. With more than 30 colors available for both guards and gutters, homeowners can maintain their architectural aesthetics while protecting their investment. The mourning system uses heavy-duty brackets positioned every 18–24 inches, providing reliable support without risking damage to metal roofing materials or fascia boards.
Customer Experiences
All American has limited reviews on the BBB and Trustpilot but has received generally positive feedback from customers. Note that the company has not been reviewed since 2023 on the BBB, and only had one review on Trustpilot at this time of this writing. While several customers commented on the company’s overall quality of work and service, some reviewers noted installation issues.
“Did job as described and installed product backed by a warranty. Excited to see how it works!” —Josh E. via the BBB, October 2023
“Irresponsible installers [were] late to the job [and caused] damage to my awning. Trying to avoid replacing it. Terrible people to deal with—this has been since August and it’s almost November.” —Beverly B. via the BBB, October 2023
How To Choose the Right Gutter Guard Provider
Selecting a gutter guard provider requires careful consideration of your home’s specific needs and local weather conditions. Metal roofs create unique challenges, producing faster water flow and requiring guards that can handle increased runoff without overflow. The right gutter system balances water management with debris protection while avoiding metal-on-metal corrosion issues.
Several key factors influence which type of gutter guard system will work best for your home:
- Material quality: Stainless steel micromesh screens offer superior filtration and durability, while powder-coated aluminum frames prevent corrosion. We recommend avoiding plastic components that degrade quickly under sun exposure.
- Water management: If you have a home with a metal roof, look for designs that maintain proper flow angles and include overflow protection.
- Installation method: Professional installation often provides better results than do-it-yourself (DIY) options for rain gutters, particularly for metal roofs where proper pitch and secure mounting prevent water bypass issues.
- Warranty coverage: We recommend looking for providers offering lifetime transferable warranties for both material defects and performance issues. With transferable warranties, you can transfer coverage if you sell your home after installing gutter guards. You can check the product’s warranty documentation for exclusions and transfer terms.
- Services package: Consider whether you need additional services such as gutter cleaning or repairs. Some companies specialize solely in guard installation, while others provide comprehensive maintenance.
- Cost structure: To find the best deal, compare total project costs from multiple installers, including materials, labor, and any necessary gutter modifications. Watch out for high-pressure sales tactics or dramatic price reductions during consultations.
How Much Does Gutter Guard Installation Cost?
Installing gutter guards on a typical 2,000-square-foot home costs between $3,136 and $3,361, depending on the material quality and installation method. The total linear foot of gutter guards you need determines your final price. For example, most two-story homes that are 1,500–2,000 square feet in size require around 200 linear feet of gutters. Here’s a breakdown of the typical gutter guard costs for each of our top-rated providers based on 200 linear feet of material.
| Provider | Average Installation Cost |
|---|---|
| LeafFilter | $3,262 |
| Gutter Guards America | $3,164 |
| Leafguard | $3,361 |
| HomeCraft | $3,136 |
| All American Gutter Protection | $3,154 |
*Cost figures sourced from our 2025 gutter guard survey of nearly 1,500 homeowners with gutter guard protection systems.
Advice From a Homeowner
We spoke with John T., a homeowner in Charlotte, North Carolina, who shared his experience managing gutters below a tree-lined property. With regular accumulation of pine needles, seedpods, and leaves, John’s maintenance challenges highlight common issues faced by homeowners with metal roofs.
“If I don’t schedule it or remind myself, it doesn’t get done until damage or issues are happening,” John said about his gutter maintenance routine.
Despite metal roofs having durability, their drainage systems require consistent attention to prevent moisture damage and oxidation. John now works with professional inspectors who help identify potential problems early, saving him from costly repairs. His experience underscores the value of scheduling regular maintenance checks rather than waiting for visible issues to develop.
Are Gutter Guards Worth It on Metal Roofs?
Gutter guards provide value for owners of homes with metal roofs by managing increased water flow while preventing large and small debris accumulation, making them a worthwhile investment. Quality micromesh systems can pay for themselves over time through reduced maintenance costs, prevention of water damage, and protection of your roof’s drainage system. While professional installation adds to your upfront costs, proper mounting and pitch adjustment help ensure optimal performance with metal roofing.
However, it’s important to select the right guard type—stainless steel micromesh systems outperform basic screens and reverse curve designs on metal roofs since they can handle more water flow, based on our research and testing. These guards can handle heavier runoff without overflow while blocking debris as small as pine needles. Though no system eliminates maintenance entirely, well-installed guards can reduce cleaning frequency from multiple times annually to basic surface brushing once per year.
FAQs About Gutter Guards for Metal Roofs
What is the best type of gutter for a metal roof?
K-style gutters work best with metal roofs due to their higher water capacity and durability, based on our team’s research. These gutters handle increased water flow better than half-round styles and provide better mounting options for gutter guards.
Do gutter guards work in heavy rain?
Quality micromesh guards can handle rainfall rates up to 150 inches per hour when you properly install them. However, performance varies based on the design—surface tension systems may struggle with metal roof runoff, while micromesh maintains flow during heavy storms.
How do you slow down rainwater on a metal roof?
Installing snow guards or rain diverters can help break up water flow before it reaches the gutters. Proper gutter sizing and strategic downspout placement also help manage runoff volume from metal roofs.
What maintenance do gutter guards need on metal roofs?
You should brush debris from guard surfaces once or twice per year and inspect for loose fasteners or sagging sections. Check seams between guards and roof edges annually to ensure proper water flow angles remain intact.
How We Evaluated Gutter Guard Providers
Our team evaluated the best gutter guard providers for metal roofs through hands-on testing, expert consultation, and an analysis of customer experiences. We rated each company across seven key categories to generate overall scores on a 5-point scale, including:
- Material and design: We assessed gutter guard construction quality, focusing on corrosion resistance and structural integrity. Providers using premium materials such as stainless steel, which offers significant filtration and durability, scored higher than those using basic aluminum or vinyl.
- Value: Companies earned points for offering competitive pricing, transparent quotes, and additional services. We compared costs across 1,000 customer invoices to determine average price ranges.
- Warranty coverage: We analyzed gutter warranty terms, transferability, and claim processes. Lifetime transferable warranties with clear documentation received top scores in our review.
- Customer reviews: Our team examined BBB ratings, Trustpilot scores, and direct customer feedback to learn more about experiences with each company. Companies with consistent positive reviews across platforms scored higher.
- Services offered: Providers offering comprehensive gutter services beyond guard installation received additional points in our review. We evaluated service quality based on our team’s customer surveys and site visits.
- Effectiveness: We tested each system’s debris filtration and water flow capacity using standardized rain simulation. Guards maintaining flow during heavy water volumes scored the highest.
- Firsthand testing: We tested 12 different gutter guards in real-world conditions, and monitored debris filtration, water flow capacity, durability, and ease of cleaning. Our hands-on evaluations provided direct insights into each system’s performance on metal roofs.
For full details about our process, read our complete gutter guard methodology.
