Affiliate Disclosure:This Old House’s Reviews Team is committed to delivering honest, objective, and independent reviews on home products and services. To support this business model, This Old House may be compensated if you purchase through links on our website.
No matter if the flies are in your kitchen, basement, or screened-in porch, they can be a nuisance to get rid of. As opposed to a swatter that requires you to chase them around your home, a trap does the work for you after being set, helping you fix your fly problem.
To help you select the right trap for your home, the This Old House Reviews Team researched the best fly traps on the market today.
Here are our top recommendations.
Top 6 Fly Traps
- Best For Windows: Catchmaster Clear Window Fly Traps
- Best For Plants: Gideal Dual-Sided Yellow Sticky Traps
- Best For Outdoor Use: Flies Be Gone Fly Traps
- Best Reusable Trap: Safer Reusable Fly Traps
- Best For Indoor Use: Katchy Indoor Insect Trap
- Best Plug-In Trap: Safer Indoor Plug-In Fly Trap
Compare Top Fly Traps
| Product | Type | Number of Traps | Bait | Indoor/Outdoor |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Catchmaster Clear Window Fly Traps | Adhesive surface | 12 | None | Indoor |
| Gideal Dual-Sided Yellow Sticky Traps | Adhesive surface | 20 | None | Both |
| Flies Be Gone Fly Traps | Covered chamber filled with water and bait | 2 | Non-toxic | Outdoor |
| Safer Reusable Fly Traps | Covered chamber filled with water and bait | 2 | Non-toxic | Outdoor |
| Katchy Indoor Insect Trap | UV light attracent with adhesive board | 1 reusable | None | Indoor |
| Safer Indoor Plug-In Fly Trap | UV light attracent with adhesive board | 1 reusable | None | Indoor |
| Product | Type | Number of Traps | Bait | Indoor/Outdoor |
Best For Windows: Catchmaster Clear Window Fly Traps
Catchmaster Clear Window Fly Traps
- $16.1
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Pros and Cons
✔ Nontoxic formula free from harsh chemicals
✔ Small, transparent design makes it barely visible
✔ Comes in a pack of 12
✘ Can be difficult to remove from surfaces
✘ Accumulation of flies over time can be unappealing
What Customers Are Saying
Those who liked these traps said that they stuck well to windows and caught a large number of flies. However, those who were unhappy claimed that it was tough to remove the traps from windows once they were full. Others wished that the traps had bait to more effectively lure insects.
Best For Plants: Gideal Dual-Sided Yellow Sticky Traps
Gideal Dual-Sided Yellow Sticky Traps
- $15.99
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Pros and Cons
✔ Waterproof and heat-resistant
✔ Safe for both indoor and outdoor use
✔ Includes 20 twist ties and two stands
✘ Bright color that makes it difficult to hide
✘ Not reusable
What Customers Are Saying
Many customers said that these traps were easy to use, worked quickly, and didn’t have an overpowering scent. However, those who left negative reviews pointed out that they sometimes caught bees, wasps, or birds. Others claimed that they didn’t work effectively without adding apple cider vinegar or another attractant.
Best For Outdoor Use: Flies Be Gone Fly Traps
Flies Be Gone Fly Trap Two-Pack
- $36.99
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Pros and Cons
✔ Features a unique, beehive design
✔ Includes a hanging strap
✔ Snapping lid makes filling process convenient
✘ May give off and unpleasant odor
✘ Not designed for indoor use
What Customers Are Saying
Satisfied customers liked that these bags were easy to set up and caught a large amount of flies in little time. However, those who were unsatisfied claimed that they sometimes spilled or leaked. Others said that the traps were unusable after a rainstorm because they filled with water.
Best Reusable Trap: Safer Reusable Fly Traps
Safer Brand Reusable Fly Traps
- $22.95
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Pros and Cons
✔ Nontoxic bait is child- and pet-safe
✔ Stands or hangs from a hook
✔ Attracts a variety of common flies
✘ Requires replacement bait to reuse it
✘ Drowns flies, which may not be ideal for squeamish users
What Customers Are Saying
Customers liked that the bait was effective at trapping flies within days and was easy to dispose of. However, some customers who left negative reviews claimed that it had an overwhelming scent. Others said that the bait was too effective because it drew more flies to the area than were previously there.
Best For Indoor Use: Katchy Indoor Insect Trap
Katchy Indoor Insect Trap
- $44.99
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Pros and Cons
✔ Also kills mosquitoes, moths, gnats, and other flying insects
✔ Uses easy-to-remove, replaceable glue boards
✔ Features multiple fan-speed settings
✘ Is considerably more expensive than many other trap types
✘ Not very effective for large bugs
What Customers Are Saying
Most customers felt that this trap was easy to use, quiet, and also effective at eliminating mosquitoes. However, those who weren’t happy said that some flies were able to fly away instead of being sucked in because the fan wasn’t powerful enough.
Best Plug-In Trap: Safer Indoor Plug-In Fly Trap
Safer Indoor Plug-In Fly Trap
- $17.97
Prices taken at time of publishing.
Pros and Cons
✔ Easy to use and refillable
✔ Naturally attracts insects with a UV LED light
✔ Rotates to fit any indoor outlet
✘ Capacity limited compared to other fly traps
✘ Not highly effective against larger, heavier flies
What Customers Are Saying
The majority of customers who revived this two-in-one indoor fly trap reported that it was easy to use and effective. Happy customers also liked that the fly trap gave off a subtle but pleasant glow, functioning as a night light. On the other hand, critical feedback included a lack of effectiveness against particularly large insect infestations, and that the trap worked better at night rather than in the daytime.
Buying Guide for Fly Traps
Whether you have one stray housefly or a fruit fly infestation, you could benefit from a fly trap. To decide which fly trap is best for your needs, consider the following factors.
Type
There are several types of fly traps, with some of the most popular being:
Adhesive
These traps have a sticky surface. Once flies come into contact with the adhesive, they can’t escape. Eventually, they die from starvation.
Container
Container traps lure flies in with bait and kill them with either poisoning, drowning, or dehydration.
Zap
Bug zappers electrocute the fly once it makes contact with the electric grid. This kills the bug instantly.
Location
Traps are designed for inside, outside, or both. For example, zap traps typically can’t be used outside because precipitation and electricity don’t mix. On the other hand, container traps typically have a hook to hang on a post. Choose a trap that works wherever you’re seeing a large number of flies.
Safety
Most fly traps use either bait or UV light to attract flies. While UV light is harmless, bait may be made from chemicals. If you have pets or children, keep these traps out of reach, or opt for a pesticide-free bait. Zap traps also pose a safety risk if kids or pets touch them.
Price
Most fly traps are inexpensive and will catch a large number of flies before they need to be replaced. Reusable traps may be more expensive but will provide good value since you don’t need to be constantly shopping for a replacement. Electric traps will be the most expensive type of trap but are effective at killing a high number of flies and can last for months or even years if well-maintained.
Capacity
Consider the capacity of the fly trap, especially if you’re using it in a commercial or high-traffic area. A larger trap will be able to hold more flies and require less frequent emptying.
Durability
Look for a fly trap that is durable and made from high-quality materials. A well-made trap will last longer and be more effective at catching flies.
Care
Another factor to consider is how easy the traps will be to care for and maintain. Most traps require some form of disposal, which may not be ideal if you don’t like being near dead flies. Adhesive-type traps typically need to be unpeeled and thrown away, while water traps should be cleaned after being dumped out.
Tips and Tricks for Using a Fly Trap
Most fly traps should automatically attract and trap flies when they venture too close. However, knowing exactly where to place the trap helps yield the best possible results. Here are a few tips to help maximize the effectiveness of your new fly trap.
- Place your fly trap in an area where flies are most likely to be found, such as near doors or windows. Keep the trap away from your kitchen or other food preparation areas.
- Flies are attracted to sweet or decaying odors, so use bait that mimics those smells. This may include sugar water, rotting fruit, or fruit juice.
- Change the bait regularly, ideally every few days. As the bait in the trap starts to decompose, it will become less effective over time.
- Use multiple fly traps for the best results. Place them strategically to cover the entire area and maximize their effectiveness.
- Be patient. It may take some time for the trap to start working, so give it a few days to start attracting and collecting flies.
Frequently Asked Questions About Fly Traps
How long do fly traps take to work?
If your trap has light or fly bait, flies should come buzzing over within minutes. However, if you have a zap or a sticky glue trap, it may take a little longer for flies to find their way over.
Where should I put a fly trap?
It depends largely on where you’re having the biggest issue. If you have flies inside your home, set up traps where they’re most likely to congregate, such as near windows and in the kitchen. If you want to prevent flies from getting inside, consider on the porch or deck, in the garden, or on a tree.
Are there home remedies that kill flies?
Yes. There are alternative ways to get rid of flies if you want a natural remedy or traps aren’t doing the trick. A mixture of vinegar and dish soap is a popular way to attract flies and poison or drown them. Having basil plants around your home or yard is another way to repel flies, as they don’t like the scent.
Why Trust The This Old House Reviews Team
This Old House has empowered homeowners and DIY-ers for more than four decades with top-notch home improvement advice in the form of television programs, print media, and digital content.
The This Old House Reviews Team focuses on creating in-depth product and service review content. To date, we’ve published over 1,600 reviews on products in the home space, from fertilizer and pruning shears to patio furniture and snow blowers.
Once we conclude our research [and testing phases], we craft a comprehensive, user-friendly article of recommended products and additional information to help our readers make the right purchase.
Questions or Comments?
To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.