We may be compensated if you purchase through links on our website. Our Reviews Team is committed to delivering honest, objective, and independent reviews on home products and services.More

LeafFilter vs. Gutter Helmet (2024)

LeafFilter’s micro-mesh gutter guard is our pick over Gutter Helmet’s reverse-curve guard. Read our review to learn which provider is the best fit for your gutter needs.

Advertiser Disclosure

By using, you are leaving This Old House and will be connected with partners of Home Service Quotes. Who, by submitting your information, may contact you with information related to your inquiry. The listings that appear are from companies from which this website receives compensation.

Compare quotes from local gutter pros

Enter details in under 3 minutes

LeafFilter's floor model of a home, gutter, and gutter guard system

Default Author Icon Written by Mike Miller Updated 04/18/2024

LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet are professional gutter guard installers that both provide impressive products, a robust suite of services, and transferable lifetime warranties. After a thorough review of each company, we recommend the LeafFilter product over Gutter Helmet because of its effective micro-mesh guard, higher average customer review scores, and more reliable installation process. 

Gutter Helmet offers a reverse-curve gutter guard, and there are some situations when it could be the better choice for your home. In this article, we’ll cover everything you need to know about both providers to help you pick the best gutter guard for your needs.


LeafFilter vs. Gutter Helmet: Which Costs More?

To determine the cost of gutter guard installation, we read hundreds of customer reviews, noting any responses that mentioned pricing, and surveyed 1,000 gutter guard customers. The only cost data we could find on Gutter Helmet is hosted on a distributor website. Based on our findings, Gutter Helmet costs more per linear foot than LeafFilter. 

You can review our findings in detail below. Note that these pricing figures are estimates, and the cost of installing gutter guards on your home will depend on several factors, such as your total length of guttering, roof pitch, and gutter condition.

LeafFilter Cost

Based on more than a dozen customer reviews that cited pricing figures and our survey of 129 LeafFilter customers, LeafFilter costs between $2,500 and $7,000. Our survey respondents noted an average cost per linear foot of $27.64. You can expect to pay around $4,100 for a 150-linear-foot LeafFilter gutter guard system. 

Some commenters on Trustpilot and Better Business Bureau (BBB) reported prices at or above $10,000. These responses were prevalent enough that we took a closer look and concluded that LeafFilter’s sales tactics were behind the higher cost ranges. Multiple customers said that LeafFilter sales representatives initially presented an inflated price of $8,000 to $10,000 or more. During negotiations, they lowered the cost to a more reasonable range. 

This sales tactic is not uncommon in the home improvement space. Expect an average cost of around $4,100 for a 150-linear-foot system, but don’t be surprised by an initial quote that’s two or more times that. You’ll need to negotiate and be firm with your budget to get a fair price on your LeafFilter system.

Gutter Helmet Cost

We read every available Gutter Helmet customer response on BBB and Trustpilot, but none mentioned cost figures. There were too few respondents who used Gutter Helmet in our survey to create a reliable average. Gutter Helmet doesn’t host any price information on its website. 

The only data we could find is hosted on Lednor Home Solutions, which owns and distributes Gutter Helmet. According to Lednor, you can expect to pay between $35 and $65 or more per linear foot for products such as Gutter Helmet. For a standard-sized gutter system (150 linear feet), this price range will result in a total cost of $5,250 to $9,750 or more.


How Do LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet Compare?

LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet both offer high-end products. LeafFilter’s screen uses surgical-grade stainless steel woven into a 275-micron mesh filter, which is fine enough to block small particles such as shingle grit. This screen is set within a uPVC frame with a tight seal. During our firsthand testing process, we tried to force pine needles between the filter and frame and noted we couldn’t penetrate the seal. The system’s built-in 11-degree pitch forces most debris to roll off. Any remaining debris is easy to clean with a garden hose. 

Gutter Helmet offers a different take on gutter protection. It uses a reverse-curve design atop a raised platform. This platform features horizontal stiffening ribs, scratch-proof paint, and a rough texture to slow the flow of water. These elements work together to counteract overflow problems prevalent in reverse-curve systems. 

Customer reviews back up the effective performance of each system. However, we believe LeafFilter is a better choice for homeowners. LeafFilter offers a more generous warranty and has higher customer review scores. While Gutter Helmet offers a unique reverse-curve design and a lifetime transferable warranty, customer reviews express dissatisfaction with the dispatch fee that accompanies services, even those covered under the warranty.

Review the table below to compare the two providers at a glance.

FactorLeafFilterGutter Helmet
Gutter guard optionsThree-piece system, including micro-mesh filter, uPVC frame, and structural hangersReverse-curve aluminum guard with raised frame, heavy-gauge metal supports, and PermaLife scratch-proof coating
State availability47 states30 states
BBB ratingA+NR
WarrantyLifetime, transferableLifetime performance, transferable
Average customer review score4.2 out of 5 stars3 out of 5 stars
Good forBlocking small debris; filtering heavy rainfall; easy cleaningSelf-cleaning; blocking oak leaves and other medium or large debris

LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet Fast Facts

LeafFilter

Best Filtration
4.7
BBB Rating : A+

LeafFilter’s gutter guard consists of a stainless steel micro-mesh screen, uPVC frame, and structural hangers. We recommend LeafFilter for homeowners who want to keep small debris, including pine needles, seedpods, and shingle grit, out of their gutters. LeafFilter’s three-piece design can be added to existing gutters or installed with its custom-fit seamless aluminum gutters. 

  • Materials: Unplasticized polyvinyl chloride (uPVC), stainless steel
  • Design: Micro-mesh
  • Multiple color options: No; however, multiple colors available for new gutter installation
  • Financing available: Yes
  • Warranty: Lifetime, transferable

How We Scored LeafFilter

We awarded LeafFilter 4.8 out of 5 stars in our ratings. Here’s how we scored LeafFilter in the categories most important to homeowners:

  • Design (4.3 out of 5): LeafFilter earned points in this category thanks to its micro-mesh screen and high-quality stainless steel filter material. It lost some points for its frame material, which isn’t stainless steel.
  • Customer support (5 out of 5): LeafFilter offers a lifetime, transferable warranty and numerous methods of customer communication, earning it full points in this category. 
  • Quote process (5 out of 5): LeafFilter earned full points in this category thanks to its free inspections, generous discounts, and available financing options.
  • Services (5 out of 5): LeafFilter earned full points for offering additional services, such as gutter and downspout installation, when purchasing its gutter guards.

What To Expect

Contact LeafFilter for a free, no-obligation quote. You can call its toll-free number or fill out an online contact form. LeafFilter’s quotes are good for one year, so you can shop around with other providers. The inspection and installation process for LeafFilter is as follows:

  1. A LeafFilter sales representative will arrive at your home, inspect your gutters, and generate a free quote. They’ll measure your home’s total linear feet of guttering, check for damage to your fascia, and look for other factors that could impact your installation cost. Don’t hesitate to negotiate. If you agree to the quote, the sales representative will schedule a date for an installation team to arrive at your home. 
  2. The installers will clean and repair (if needed) your gutter system and install new LeafFilter gutter guards. If you purchase a new gutter system alongside your guards, they’ll disassemble the existing gutters, dispose of them, and install the new ones.
  3. Once your new system is installed, register your warranty on LeafFilter’s website.

Testing Takeaways

We tested LeafFilter’s gutter guard firsthand with a floor model of its system. We discovered the following insights about its performance:

  • It has a durable design and a tight screen.
  • Its screen blocks more than 90% of debris, including pine needles, deciduous tree leaves, and shingle grit.
  • Its filter allows water passage without overflowing, even in heavy rainfall simulations.
  • Its design resists clogging and has a built-in pitch, making it easy to clean.

Gutter Helmet

4

Gutter Helmet’s gutter protection system uses a reverse-curve design. These types of gutter guards employ the scientific principles of liquid adhesion and surface tension to push debris to the ground while still allowing water to pass through your gutters. What makes Gutter Helmet’s design unique is its raised surface. It features a series of heavy-gauge aluminum supports to lift the guard above the first few shingle layers. This position makes it flat against your roofline, creating a horizontal surface that slows down water before filtering it through.

  • Materials: Aluminum
  • Design: Raised reverse-curve
  • Multiple color options: No
  • Financing available: Yes
  • Warranty: Lifetime, transferable

How We Scored Gutter Helmet

We gave Gutter Helmet a score of 4.1 out of 5 stars. Here’s how it performed in key categories:

  • Design (3.5 out of 5): Gutter Helmet’s durable, heavy-duty, and unique system earned it points in this category. However, it lost some points because reverse-curve guards don’t perform as well as micro-mesh systems.
  • Customer support (5 out of 5): Gutter Helmet’s lifetime warranty and multiple means of customer communication earned it full points in this category.
  • Quote process (4 out of 5): Gutter Helmet performed well in this category thanks to its financing options and available discounts. It lost some points because its quotes aren’t good for a year.
  • Service (5 out of 5): Gutter Helmet operates out of franchise locations. Each branch offers different services, from gutter repair and cleaning to downspout installation. We considered multiple Gutter Helmet franchises, and most had a wide service selection, earning the company full points in this category.

What To Expect

To obtain a Gutter Helmet quote, find a local installer who offers its products. Gutter Helmet can connect you with a franchise branch location. Contact Gutter Helmet by filling out an online form, calling its toll-free number, or using its live chat. A customer service representative will direct you to a verified local installer. Each location’s installation process is different, but a typical experience looks like the following:

  1. A company sales representative will come to your property and inspect your existing gutter system. They’ll look for anything that could impact the cost of your gutter guard installation, such as total linear feet of guttering, roof pitch, and gutter condition. They’ll use this information to generate an on-site quote, present the system and services they offer, and negotiate a price. If you agree to the quote, they’ll schedule an installation date.
  2. On that day, a trained technician crew will arrive at your home and complete the services. Most companies clean and repair your rain gutters as part of the gutter guard installation. Once the job is complete, the crew will clean up the job site, dispose of any debris, and show you pictures of the completed installation. They’ll answer any questions you have before departing.
  3. Once your product is installed, you can register any applicable warranties through the company’s website.

What Are the Pros and Cons of LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet? 

While LeafFilter is our top pick, each company has strengths and weaknesses. Here’s a quick look at where each company succeeds and where it could improve.

LeafFilter Pros and Cons

Pros
Blocks debris as small as pine needles, seedpods, and shingle grit
Offers a lifetime transferable warranty
Has high average customer reviews on BBB and Trustpilot
Cons
Uses aggressive sales tactics that some customers compare to buying a used car
Doesn’t offer its additional services outside of gutter guard installations

Gutter Helmet Pros and Cons

Pros
Self-cleans with runoff from the roof system
Features raised platform with stiff ridges and a textured surface to prevent overflows
Has PermaLife scratch-proof pain to improve corrosion resistance and longevity
Cons
Costs more than the industry standard
Charges a dispatch fee for any services 

LeafFilter vs. Gutter Helmet: What Services Do They Offer?

LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet offer impressive gutter guards and additional services such as gutter installation and cleaning. LeafFilter only provides additional services with its gutter guard installations. Gutter Helmet’s available services depend on the franchise location but aren’t limited to guard installations. Below, we’ll discuss the service offerings provided by each company. 

LeafFilter Services

LeafFilter offers additional services such as gutter installation, cleaning, and repair and downspout installation. However, it doesn’t offer these services outside of gutter guard installation. If you want your gutters repaired or to install an all-new gutter system, you’ll need to purchase LeafFilter gutter guards. LeafFilter doesn’t offer post-installation servicing outside of what’s outlined in its warranty and guarantee. 

Gutter Helmet Services

Gutter Helmet works with franchise and branch locations, so its services vary depending on your local office. Lednor Home Solutions, the company that owns Gutter Helmet, offers the following services in addition to gutter guard installations: 

  • Fascia and soffit repair 
  • Gutter cleaning 
  • Gutter repair
  • Roof replacement 
  • Seamless gutter installation 
  • Sectional gutter installation

The table below breaks down the key factors of each brand and how they compare.

FactorLeafFilterGutter Helmet
Blocks small debris
Uses high-quality materials
Provides a lifetime warranty
Offers a performance guarantee
Offers free quote
Provides financing options
Has quotes good for 1 year
Offers gutter installations
Offers gutter cleaning and repair
Has an average customer review score of 4 out of 5 stars or higher

What Type of Gutter Guard Performs the Best?

Micro-mesh guards are the most effective type of gutter guard. These guards block the most debris, are effective in most climates, and promote water flow. Our firsthand testing process involved testing every type of gutter guard, and micro-mesh systems performed the best by a wide margin. Micro-mesh screens are also the easiest to clean because they offer a smooth surface from which debris slides off. LeafFilter’s micro-mesh system is one of the best we’ve reviewed. Its guard is expertly built and performed as advertised during testing. 

Reverse-curve gutter guards, like Gutter Helmet, can keep most debris out of a gutter system. Reverse-curve guards use a solid helmet-like cap that blocks debris but has a small opening along the front where water can pass through. As the water rolls off your roof shingles onto the guard, it carries debris and pushes it to the ground. This design makes reverse-curve guards among the most efficient for self-cleaning and preventing debris buildup. However, we tested two DIY reverse-curve gutter guards and noted this type can be prone to overflowing. Also, small debris, such as pine needles, can get caught inside the opening.


For this review, we read hundreds of customer reviews on independent review sites, including Better Business Bureau and Trustpilot. Analyzing customer reviews gave us greater insight into how these companies treat their customers and what you can expect when working with them. 

LeafFilter Reviews

LeafFilter has positive reviews across the board. Its BBB page boasts more than 6,000 reviews with an average rating of 3.95 out of 5 stars. It has more than 123,000 reviews on Trustpilot, with an average rating of 4.4 stars. Most customers praise the professionalism of LeafFilter sales representatives, installation crews, and customer service. Other positive reviews praise the effectiveness of LeafFilter’s product and how easy it is to clean. The following review highlights customer satisfaction with the product and installation crew: 

LeafFilter’s technology is superior to all other gutter covers I’ve dealt with in 50 years. The secret is the surgical steel micro mesh that lets water through, but almost nothing else. The LeafFilter representative knows his product very well, is proud of it, and knows that LeafFilter has the installation teams to install them properly. I’ve tried many other brands over the years, but I wish I’d started with LeafFilter.” —John Haueisen, Jan. 30, 2024, on Trustpilot

Negative reviews mention LeafFilter’s high-pressure sales tactics, its tendency to freeze over in winter, and occasional installation errors such as uncleaned debris after installation, as shown in the following review: 

Everything that was promised wasn’t done. Downspouts were not cleaned out, loose downspouts was not secured, and all trash was not removed. Reported problems to salesman, but nothing was done to correct the problems.” —Bill, Dec. 21, 2023, on Trustpilot

After reading hundreds of comments, we believe LeafFilter’s gutter guards function as advertised. Reviews also indicate that LeafFilter’s installation crew quality can vary between branch locations. To help ensure a positive experience with LeafFilter, we recommend reading the reviews of your region’s branch location before reaching out. To get the best price for your LeafFilter gutter guard, be firm with your sales representative and negotiate on price.

Gutter Helmet Reviews

As a smaller company, Gutter Helmet has far fewer reviews than LeafFilter. Across Trustpilot and BBB, Gutter Helmet has 54 reviews as of the time of writing this article. It has 3 out of 5 stars across its BBB reviews and 3.8 out of 5 stars on Trustpilot. Customers praise Gutter Helmet for the professionalism of its sales representatives and for the promptness of its installation crews, as seen in the following review: 

From estimating to repair, the Gutter Helmet team was very professional. They showed-up when scheduled and replaced four panels damaged by high winds. The price was right and the work was done quickly, while respecting our property.” —Harold W., June 7, 2023, on BBB

Critical reviews highlight leaking and clogging issues, including clogs caused by pine needles and tree leaves. Another consistent complaint refers to a “dispatch fee” that customers have to pay when Gutter Helmet comes out to service their property, as shown in the following review:

I called Lednor Home Solutions – Gutter Helmet November 21, 2023 to conduct annual review of Gutter Helmet gutter guards after the leaves dropped from the trees at my Arlington, Va. home. Lisa informed me that they have implemented a new policy in July 2023 which includes a $50 Dispatch Fee for any inspection. As I have never paid for this fee in the past, I asked them when were customers notified and could they send me the documentation. They informed me that they are informing customers as they call in and there is no documentation. She said that the system is guaranteed for life but any inspection without cause would have to include a dispatch fee. I was informed when I purchased the system that the system was guaranteed for life and that any inspection would be free. Isn’t this a breach of contract?” —William W., Nov. 21, 2023, on BBB

After reading available Gutter Helmet customer reviews, we believe it offers a well-built product that performs better than the DIY reverse-curve guards we’ve tested. However, customer reviews indicate it clogs with pine and tree leaves. 

The “dispatch fee” it charges customers isn’t standard practice in the gutter guard industry, especially if the damage is covered under the warranty. Most gutter guard providers offer “no clog guarantees” that promise to fix issues at no cost to the customer.


Our Final Thoughts on LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet

While LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet are both reliable gutter guard installers offering high-end gutter protection systems, LeafFilter comes out on top. Based on our research and firsthand testing, LeafFilter’s gutter protection system blocks more debris than Gutter Helmet. LeafFilter offers a more generous warranty and has higher average customer review scores than Gutter Helmet. The major benefit of Gutter Helmet is its additional service offerings, which can be purchased independently from a professional installation, unlike LeafFilter.


FAQ About LeafFilter vs. Gutter Helmet

Is LeafFilter better than Gutter Helmet for pine needles?

LeafFilter is better than Gutter Helmet for pine needles. During our firsthand testing, we found that LeafFilter’s guard blocked 100% of the pine needles we applied. Reverse-curve systems like those used by Gutter Helmet typically have difficulty protecting against pine needles. 

Can LeafFilter handle heavy rain? 

Yes, LeafFilter can handle heavy downpours without overflowing. We applied water at varying speeds during our testing to determine how well LeafFilter performed in heavy rain. We found that it withstood heavy downpour conditions before overflowing. 

What are the downsides of LeafFilter?

The downsides of LeafFilter are its high price, pushy sales tactics, and tendency to freeze over in the winter. While ice dams are a common problem for micro-mesh gutter guards, installing heat tape can counteract this issue. 

What are the downsides of Gutter Helmet?

The downsides of Gutter Helmet are its inability to stop small debris, its high price tag, and its non-standard service fee for warranty-covered repairs. 


Our Rating Methodology 

We back up our gutter guard recommendations with a detailed rating methodology to objectively score each gutter guard product and provider. We conduct research by reviewing product specifications and provider website information, speaking with customer representatives, and analyzing customer reviews. We then score each provider against our review standards for gutter guard design, customer support, the quote process, services, and reviews to arrive at a final score on a 5-point rating scale.  

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.