In This Guide: Top Window Brands | Factors to Consider | Finding a Local Installer | Conclusion | FAQs | Methodology

Choosing the right windows is about more than style. You need to consider durability, energy efficiency, glass type, frame materials, warranty options, and more. This is a lot of information to juggle, making it challenging to compare window brands closely.

The This Old House Reviews Team has researched top replacement window companies in the United States to make the decision easier. We analyzed costs, services, and products using a rigorous methodology to narrow down our 9 best window brands.

 


 

Top 9 Window Brands

These are the top replacement window brands based on our extensive research:

Find A Window Replacement Company in Your State

 


 

Champion Windows: Best for Sunrooms

  • Our Rating: 88 out of 100
  • Warranty: Limited lifetime warranty
  • Price range: $350–$800

Champion Windows started in 1953 and now provides multiple window lines in 17 states. The company’s ColorBond aluminum window line uses nontoxic heat reflective materials to maintain cool temperatures in your home. The TimberBond line offers custom wood grain finishes, including cherrywood, dark oak, and English oak. This line also uses technology that prevents blistering, peeling, and chipping.

Champion Windows provides complete sunroom and patio services. The company builds all-season and three-season sunrooms tailored to your home’s architecture with custom-shaped windows and additional features such as fans and lighting.

All of Champion’s offerings include its Energy Star-certified Comfort 365 Window Glass. This glass uses a specialized low-emissivity (Low-E) coating and insulating argon gas to block roughly 94% of ultraviolet (UV) rays. This keeps your home cool during summer and warm in winter without blocking or adding sunlight. 

Pros and Cons of Champion Windows

✔ Custom-builds high-quality sunrooms and enclosed patios

✔ Features Energy Star-certified glass options

✔ Uses nontoxic, heat-reflective materials for aluminum and wooden windows

✘ Limits pricing information online, as prices vary by location 

✘ Only operates in 17 states*

*Available in Alabama, Colorado, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Michigan, New Mexico, North Carolina, Ohio, Tennessee, Texas, South Carolina, and Wisconsin.

Free quote: Get a quote from Champion Windows today

Window Types Available

Champion Windows provides its Comfort 365 Glass in the following window types and doors: 

  • Basement hoppers
  • Bay windows
  • Bow windows
  • Casement windows
  • Double-hung windows
  • Entry doors
  • Garden windows
  • Glass block windows
  • Patio doors
  • Picture windows
  • Screen doors
  • Screen rooms
  • Shaped windows
  • Sliding doors
  • Storm doors

The company also provides the following sunroom and patio services: 

  • All-season sunrooms
  • Three-season sunrooms
  • Patio enclosures and covers

Free quote: Get a quote from Champion Windows today

Return to list


 

Castle Windows: Best Warranty

  • Our Rating: 94 out of 100
  • Warranty: Transferable lifetime warranty
  • Price range: $300–$600

Castle Windows—a.k.a. “The Windows People”—has offered high-quality replacement windows, doors, roofing, and siding services since 1977. The company provides accessible windows with double weather-stripping for durability. Its windows also have a tilt-sash—or the part of the window that opens—for easy cleaning. Castle creates made-to-order windows rather than offering specific lines. It has wood, fiberglass, and aluminum window options. 

Castle Windows includes a transferable lifetime warranty covering all window parts, including glass, screens, and other components. The warranty also covers workmanship with free labor on all services—a standout compared to the standard manufacturer warranties other window replacement companies offer. 

Pros and Cons of Castle Windows

✔ Customizes specialty windows, such as deadlite and transom windows

✔ Offers a top-of-the-line transferable lifetime warranty 

✔ Provides vinyl siding services for a comprehensive window replacement experience 

✘ Offers less window variety than some competitors 

✘ Operates in only 11 states*

*Available in Connecticut, Indiana, Maryland, Michigan, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Virginia, and West Virginia.

Free quote: Get a quote from Castle Windows today

Types of Windows Available

Here are the doors and windows Castle Windows offers:

  • Awning windows
  • Basement hoppers 
  • Bay windows 
  • Bow windows
  • Casement windows
  • Double-hung windows
  • Exterior doors 
  • Garden windows
  • Patio sliders 
  • Slider windows
  • Specialty windows 

Free quote: Get a quote from Castle Windows today

Return to list


 

Renewal by Andersen: Best White-glove Service

  • Our Rating: 94 out of 100
  • Warranty: Limited and limited lifetime warranties 
  • Price range: $500–$3,000

Andersen is one of the most recognizable names in the windows industry. Its subsidiary, Renewal by Andersen, offers customized replacement windows with white-glove service. You can schedule a free consultation with a windows specialist to determine your window needs and specifications. 

Renewal has 35 different window styles (including specialty shapes). You can select from various exterior colors, interior colors, glass types, hardware colors, grille patterns, and an optional Truscreen insect screen. Those who want more standard Andersen windows can find the brand at popular retailers like The Home Depot. Andersen backs its products with a limited or limited lifetime warranty, depending on the product.

Pros and Cons of Renewal by Andersen

✔ Has one of the largest selections of window types

✔ Offers a customizable, white-glove window replacement service

✔ Warranty options include 20 years of coverage for glass and 10 years for non-glass

✘ Availability may vary by  ZIP code

✘ Charges a premium price

Free quote: Get a quote from Andersen Windows today

Types of Windows Available

Below are the door and window types Andersen supplies: 

  • Awning windows 
  • Bay windows 
  • Bow windows 
  • Casement windows 
  • Double-hung windows 
  • Entry doors 
  • Gliding windows 
  • Hinged French patio doors 
  • Pass-through windows 
  • Picture windows 
  • Screen doors 
  • Sliding doors 
  • Specialty windows 
  • Storm doors 

Free quote: Get a quote from Andersen Windows today

Return to list


 

Milgard: Best Support

  • Our Rating: 91 out of 100
  • Warranty: Limited lifetime and full warranties
  • Price range: $300–$600

Milgard Windows and Doors started in 1962. The company understands that the windows industry can be confusing for the average homeowner, so it focuses on providing support and assistance throughout the window replacement process. It also offers easy access to online resources on its website’s support tab, such as a do-it-yourself (DIY) service library, videos for ongoing care, and an online chat feature. 

The company has five window lines with fiberglass, vinyl, and aluminum frames. Milgard’s Thermally Improved Aluminum A250 Windows use polyurethane to create a thermal barrier between your home and the outdoors, creating energy-efficient, durable windows with contemporary style. Milgard’s Style Line Series is an excellent vinyl window option. 

Pros and Cons of Milgard

✔ Creates simple yet stylish patio doors with its AX550 Moving Glass line

✔ Offers easy access to support tools and online resources 

✔ Provides SmartTouch Hardware for easy locking and unlocking

✘ Doesn’t include online pricing information 

✘ Only available in 16 states*

*Available in Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Hawaii, Idaho, Kansas, Missouri, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Oregon, Texas, Utah, and Washington.

Types of Windows Available

Milgard customers can select from the following window and door options:

  • Awning windows 
  • Bay windows
  • Bi-fold glass walls
  • Bow windows
  • Casement windows
  • Double-hung windows
  • French-style sliding doors
  • Garden windows
  • Horizontal slider windows
  • In-swing French doors
  • Out-swing French doors
  • Picture windows
  • Pocket glass walls
  • Radius windows
  • Single-hung windows
  • Sliding patio doors
  • Stacking glass walls

Return to list


 

Marvin: Best for Skylights

  • Our Rating: 89 out of 100
  • Warranty: Limited warranties 
  • Price range: $250–$1,000

Marvin Windows is a Minnesota-based company with an impressive 100 years of experience in the windows and doors industry. It manufactures wooden, aluminum, and fiberglass windows from eight American-operated factories across the country. Marvin’s Essential Collection provides strong fiberglass exterior and interior windows at an affordable price. 

The Awaken Skylight and Marvin Skylight windows are two of Marvin’s most notable offerings. Skylight windows are notoriously challenging to install, requiring a lot of specialization and knowledge. The Marvin Awaken Skylight uses dimmable LED lighting, which you can adjust to the ideal color temperature of natural light. This feature supports circadian rhythm, eases day-to-night transitions, and allows you to control natural lighting no matter where you live, what time of year it is, or which direction your home faces.

Pros and Cons of Marvin

✔ Allows customers to add custom design options to its window lines 

✔ Has a solutions tab on its website that suggests products based on your needs

✔ Provides high-tech skylights that sync with Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant

✘ Availability may vary by ZIP code

✘ Offers limited warranties

Types of Windows Available

Here are Marvin Windows’ available window and door options: 

  • Bay windows 
  • Bi-fold doors 
  • Bow windows 
  • Casement windows 
  • Corner windows 
  • Double-hung windows 
  • Entry doors 
  • Garage doors 
  • Interior doors 
  • Lift and slide doors 
  • Multi-slide doors 
  • Picture windows 
  • Pivot doors 
  • Skylights
  • Specialty windows 
  • Sliding windows 
  • Sliding doors 
  • Swinging doors

Return to list


 

Harvey Windows and Doors: Best for Durability

  • Our Rating: 85 out of 100
  • Warranty: 10-year and lifetime warranties 
  • Price range: $500–$1,350

Harvey Windows and Doors provides durable and long-lasting windows with heavy-duty hardware. It uses sturdy, Energy Star-certified glass and offers options for dual-action locks, limit latches, and multiple glass panes. These features allow Harvey’s windows to withstand the elements more effectively than other window brands. 

Harvey’s Classic Vinyl collection is great for homeowners looking to balance strength with affordability. The line includes UV Tough black and bronze vinyl windows with a paint coat 10 times stronger than the industry standard. You can select from five BetterGrain interior finishes that mimic the look of natural wood windows for an elevated but affordable look. The Classic Vinyl line comes with a lifetime warranty.  

Pros and Cons of Harvey

✔ Allows customers to add custom hardware for improved durability

✔ Has an inspiration tab on its website to generate home improvement ideas  

✔ Offers UV Tough coats for long-lasting windows 

✘ Only services 16 states*

✘ Wooden windows only include a 10-year warranty 

*Available in Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, and West Virginia.

Types of Windows Available

Below is Harvey’s window and doors catalog:

  • Awning windows
  • Bay windows
  • Bow windows
  • Casement windows
  • Custom shaped windows 
  • Double-hung windows
  • Entry doors
  • Garden windows
  • Gliding patio doors
  • Gliding windows
  • Hoppers
  • Majesty hinged patio doors
  • Picture windows
  • Single-hung windows
  • Rolling windows

Return to list


 

Simonton Windows: Best for Vinyl Products

  • Our Rating: 74 out of 100 
  • Warranty: 20-year limited and limited lifetime warranties 
  • Price range: $200–$450

Simonton Windows began producing exterior aluminum windows in Pennsboro, West Virginia, in 1946 but noticed the need for more energy-efficient vinyl windows in the 1980s. It now produces some of the best vinyl windows on the market, focusing on creating weather-resistant and low-maintenance products. The company also adds insulation and energy-efficient glass to reduce heating and cooling costs. It backs all of its windows with a limited lifetime warranty. 

Simonton offers an impressive 10 window lines. The company works with The Home Depot and local dealers and distributors to supply and install its windows. If you prefer a DIY approach, you can also access installation instructions and how-to-videos on Simonton’s website. 

Pros and Cons of Simonton Windows

✔ Available at big-box retailers such as The Home Depot

✔ Offers high-quality vinyl windows with a lifetime warranty 

✔ Tailors its window lines to different regions and adjusts window performance by climate 

✘ Offers a 20-year warranty on hardware components

✘ The warranty doesn’t cover installation

Types of Windows Available

Below are the window types and doors Simonton Windows supplies: 

  • Awning windows
  • Bay windows
  • Bow windows
  • Casement windows
  • Double-hung windows
  • Garden windows 
  • Geometric windows 
  • Picture windows 
  • Single-hung windows 
  • Slider windows 
  • Sliding patio doors 
  • Swinging patio doors

Return to list


 

Pella: Best for Energy Efficiency

  • Our Rating: 72 out of 100
  • Warranty: Limited warranties 
  • Price range: $400–$2,000

Pella is one of the largest and most noteworthy window manufacturers in the United States. It focuses on eco-friendly and energy-efficient products, ensuring its offerings meet Energy Star performance standards and working with wood vendors who practice responsible harvest and replenishment. The company also uses a patented EnduraGuard wood protection formula that guards your windows against water damage, termites, and decay.

Pella’s windows are top-performing, affordable, and stylish. The company offers free in-home consultations and has more than 200 showrooms nationwide. It’s easy to find at popular retailers such as The Home Depot and Lowe’s.

Pros and Cons of Pella

✔ Available in all 50 states

✔ Eco-friendly and energy-efficient products

✔ Custom window services for unique accent windows 

✘ Certain products, such as specialty windows, may be more expensive than competitors 

✘ No lifetime warranty

Types of Windows Available

Here are the window types Pella offers:

  • Awning windows
  • Bay windows
  • Bow windows
  • Casement windows
  • Custom options
  • Double-hung windows
  • Front doors 
  • Patio doors 
  • Picture windows
  • Single-hung windows
  • Sliding window
  • Specialty windows

Return to list


 

Jeld-Wen: Best User Experience

  • Our Rating: 71 out of 100
  • Warranty: Limited warranties 
  • Price range: $200–$800

Jeld-Wen is a Charlotte, North Carolina-based company that offers full-service window replacement, from manufacturing to installation. It has more than 117 manufacturing facilities and provides new and replacement windows in various styles, from budget-friendly aluminum and DF Hybrid vinyl windows to custom wood options.

Notably, Jeld-Wen has a user-friendly website. The company provides buying guides for each window line, allowing homeowners to view products based on their budget and needs through the categories “good,” “better,” and “best.” This makes it easy to locate what you need, whether you want cheap replacement vinyl windows or beautiful, high-quality wood windows. You can also mix and match colors and grille options in one spot. 

Pros and Cons of Jeld-Wen

✔ Has multiple window lines of vinyl, aluminum, and wood windows at competitive prices

✔ Offers an augmented reality visualizer to see what windows look like in your home

✔ Provides a user-friendly online experience for replacement window shopping 

✘ Doesn’t offer a lifetime warranty

✘ The company’s large size may lead to difficult communication at times

Types of Windows Available

Jeld-Wen offers the below window types on its website and at big-box retailers: 

  • Awning windows
  • Casement windows
  • Custom windows
  • Double-hung windows
  • Single-hung windows
  • Shaped windows
  • Sliding window

Return to list


 

Factors to Consider When Choosing Replacement Windows

Replacement window shopping can be overwhelming given the many different components and materials to consider. We’ve broken down the key things to keep in mind to help make the process easier. Additionally, we’ve included a breakdown of window parts below, as illustrated in our How to Replace a Window article. 

Diagram of parts of a window. Credit: Robert Hardin

Window Types

You’ll want window styles that complement your home’s architecture. Many contemporary homes have casement or sliding windows. Historic homes often feature double-hung and awning windows, while farmhouse-style homes have bay or bow windows.

Read about popular window types below and search for companies that provide windows that match the look of the room(s) you’re upgrading.

  • Awning windows: These windows have hinges at the top of the frame and swing outward from the bottom. They often have a crank or a type of glide hardware. 
  • Basement hoppers: These are small windows in your basement that increase natural light and airflow. They run across the top of your home’s foundation and are hinged at the bottom to open at the top.
  • Bay and bow windows: These windows have a 3D shape that curves outward from your home. Adding a box seat or ledge can transform them into a bookshelf or an additional seating area. Bay windows are angular, while bow windows are more curved. 
  • Casement windows: This popular window style has a hinge on the side and swings open to the left or right via a crank. Casement windows are often placed in hard-to-reach areas, such as over a kitchen sink or in a bathroom. 
  • Double-hung windows: These windows have two locks and open at the top and bottom. They’re often found on high floors.
  • Garden windows: Garden windows protrude from your home, creating a space to grow plants and herbs. They’re ideal for a kitchen window. 
  • Glass block windows: These windows are translucent, thick blocks of glass. They allow light into the room but obscure the view, which makes them a popular option for bathrooms and basements. 
  • Picture windows: These oversized windows are floor-to-ceiling accents. They cannot be opened and provide a lot of natural lighting.
  • Shaped windows: Sometimes called geometric windows, shaped windows provide an accent that lets light in where standard windows might not work. Popular shapes include half-round, round, eclipse, triangles, and trapezoids. 
  • Single-hung windows: These windows function similarly to double-hung windows, but they have one lock in the center. They also tend to be smaller than double-hung windows. 

Warranties

Window installers include warranties on their products to protect your investment. The length and stipulations of these warranties vary by product. High-end options, such as wood windows, typically come with comprehensive warranties, while vinyl windows may have warranties as short as one to two years. Window warranties are often broken into separate warranties for workmanship and components rather than one warranty for both. 

Unfortunately, lifetime warranties are not standard in the windows industry. In our survey of 1,000 homeowners, 37% said they received only a two to five-year warranty. However, 91% of homeowners said their warranty was fulfilled when they made a claim. An installer that offers lifetime warranties on its windows or doors is a secure investment.

Reviews

Reading reviews on popular sites such as the Better Business Bureau (BBB), Trustpilot, and Google can help you understand customers’ experiences with the companies you’re interested in. Take note of the pros and cons each reviewer shares.

Many customers will mention whether or not a company stands behind its work with its warranties, as well as how helpful customer service reps are. You may want to consider a different installer if you notice many negative reviews.

 


 

Finding a Local Window Installer

Most homeowners we surveyed (46%) opted to hire a local contractor, citing that they were scared to make a mistake, wanted to protect their windows with a warranty, or simply didn’t want to deal with the hassle of installing windows themselves.

Many companies offer window installation. One way to whittle down your options is to look for installers who are certified for the particular window brand you want. You should also confirm which companies service your address.

Use our tool below to quickly connect with reputable, certified window installers that service your ZIP code and schedule in-home assessments.

 


 

Our Conclusion

It’s possible to install replacement windows on your own, but if your project requires more than swapping out one simple window, you may want to consider hiring a professional. Windows are crucial to your home’s appearance, safety, and energy efficiency. Why risk minor mistakes turning into major headaches? 

Champion Windows offers comprehensive window options as well as sunroom and patio services. Castle Windows is an excellent option for durable, affordable windows backed by one of the most robust warranties in the industry. Finally, we recommend Renewal by Andersen for a top-of-the-line white-glove window replacement experience.

We suggest requesting at least three quotes from different window installers before deciding. Use our tool below to obtain free quotes from our top recommendations.

 


 

FAQs About Window Replacement

 


 

Our Rating Methodology

The This Old House Reviews Team is committed to providing comprehensive and unbiased reviews to our readers. This means earning your trust through transparent reviews and data to support our ratings and recommendations. Our rating system for window brands is on a 100-point scale based on five factors:

  • Installation process/provider benefits (15 points): We consider the overall installation process a provider offers, such as in-home consultation and customization options. We also consider whether or not the provider offers other services and is available at easy-to-access retailers like The Home Depot or Lowe’s.
  • Warranty (15 points): We consider whether or not the provider offers a warrant, as well as if that warranty is limited or lifetime. 
  • BBB Rating (10 points): What Better Business Bureau rating does the company feature? Is it A, B, or lower? Companies with a higher score receive more points. 
  • Pricing (10 points): We consider the overall average price range of each provider. Providers with a lower average price range receive more points than those with higher ones. 
  • Customer Service (10 points): Does the company offer helpful customer service tools, such as an online request form or phone number? If a provider offers more of these tools, it receives a higher score. 
  • Window Features (15 points): We consider what features a company provides for its windows, such as Low E coating, customization options, and tilt-in sashes. The more features a company provides, the higher the score. 
  • Window Variety (10 points): The more window types a company offers, the higher the score. 

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.