Affiliate Disclosure: This Old House may be compensated if you purchase through links on our website. Our Reviews Team is committed to delivering honest, objective, and independent reviews on home products and services. ... Affiliate Disclosure: This Old House may be compensated if you purchase through links on our website. Our Reviews Team is committed to delivering honest, objective, and independent reviews on home products and services.

Best 5 Roofers in Amherst, NY

Get a personalized quote in just 2 minutes.
Join the 10,601 people who have received a free, no-obligation quote in the last 30 days
Last Updated August 11, 2023

With a weathered roof, you may be considering repairing your roof, or perhaps even replacing it. This article will provide you the details you need to choose the best roofing company for your home in Amherst.

Top Amherst Roofing Companies

OConnor Contracting Logo
Top rated

OConnor Contracting


Services Offered

Shingle Roofs Commercial Roofing Energy Efficient Roofing Metal Roofs Quality Inspection Roof Repair Roof Replacement Roof Cleaning Asphalt Roofs Rubber Roofs


  • Free inspections
  • Customer education
  • Locally owned
106 Hubbardston Pl, Buffalo, NY 716-471-9903
Graves Brothers Home Improvement Logo

Graves Brothers Home Improvement


Services Offered

Commercial Roofing Roof Repair Rubber Roofs Solar Panel Installation Metal Roofs Shingle Roofs Roof Replacement Asphalt Roofs


  • Free inspections
  • Customer education
  • Preventive services
6814 Main St Suite 104, Williamsville, NY 716-875-7663
Lifetime Siding, Roofing and Construction Logo

Lifetime Siding, Roofing and Construction


Services Offered

Energy Efficient Roofing Roof Repair Commercial Roofing Shingle Roofs


  • Honors appointment windows
  • Customer education
  • Quality customer service
5500 N Bailey Ave, Buffalo, NY 716-239-6476 www.lifetimesidingandr...
Dalex Roofing Logo

Dalex Roofing


Services Offered

Roof Replacement Asphalt Roofs Shingle Roofs Commercial Roofing Metal Roofs Quality Inspection Roof Repair


  • Quality customer service
  • Transparent pricing
  • Customer education
1974 Eggert Rd, Buffalo, NY 716-609-2918
M Property Restoration Logo

M Property Restoration


Services Offered

Commercial Roofing Metal Roofs Roof Repair


  • Free inspections
  • Transparent project updates
  • Quality customer service
15 Webster St, North Tonawanda, NY 716-222-9435

More Local Roofing Companies

Gold Construction Roofing Contractor

User Reviews: 4.7/5

4162 Bailey Ave
Amherst, NY 14226

Buffalo Roofing

User Reviews: 4.7/5

5565 Transit Rd
Williamsville, NY 14221

Aerial Roofing

User Reviews: 4.6/5

6700 S Transit Rd
Lockport, NY 14094

WNY Roofing

User Reviews: 4.6/5

44 Delaware St
Tonawanda, NY 14150

Mann Construction & Roofing

User Reviews: 4.6/5

237 Pratt St
Buffalo, NY 14204

Amherst Roofing

User Reviews: 4.6/5

8900 Transit Rd
East Amherst, NY 14051

All Access Builders LLC

User Reviews: 4.6/5

2017 Clinton St
Buffalo, NY 14206

Fiddler Roofing Inc

User Reviews: 4.7/5

2335 Niagara Falls Blvd
Niagara Falls, NY 14304

Schuster Construction LLC

User Reviews: 4.6/5

360 Gould Ave
Depew, NY 14043

Our Ranking Methodology

The This Old House Reviews Team evaluated dozens of roofers in the Amherst area. When selecting the best roofers, we looked at the following criteria:

  • Customer reviews and recommendations
  • Professional experience and specialties
  • Services and guarantees
  • Safety and service methods

For help choosing the right provider for your home, see our guide below.

Get a Quote for Roofing Companies in Amherst

You will receive instant results for free, no phone call required.

Facts about Amherst
Average Max Temp: 54°F
Average Min Temp: 40°F
Average Daily Sunlight: 49%
Average Annual Snowfall: 89.2"
Average Monthly Precipitation: 3.42"
Most Popular Roofing Material: Asphalt

Roofing Materials in Amherst

Roofers can repair or replace many common roof types. The graphic below shows the typical replacement cost, life span, and energy-efficiency rating (represented by the lighting bolts) for each roofing material.

Roofing Replacement


$3.00 - $7.00 Per Sq Ft.

Life Span: 15-20 years

Roofing Replacement

Concrete (faux clay tile)

$8.00 - $19.00 Per Sq Ft.

Life Span: 50 years

Roofing Replacement


$5.00 - $14.00 Per Sq Ft.

Life Span: 40-60 years

Roofing Replacement


$15.00 - $40.00 Per Sq Ft.

Life Span: 60-125 years

Want to learn more?

Speak with an expert today.

Get Quote

Experts Ready to Help

Roofing Replacement


$12.00 - $25.00 Per Sq Ft.

Life Span: 80-100 years

Want to learn more?

Speak with an expert today.

Get Quote

Experts Ready to Help

How To Find the Right Roofing Company

There are some things you should think about to find the best roofer for your project, such as:

  • Availability and service area: Before you decide on a roofer, verify that it services your area. Scheduling can vary in the industry because it's largely weather-dependent. Ask about scheduling when you call for an estimate to make sure it aligns with your needs.
  • Licensing and certification: Verify that the roofing company has the proper licensing and can procure the right permits to carry out roofing work in your state.
  • Warranties: Contractors will often offer workmanship warranties to protect their work quality and protect against any issues from the repairs or roof replacement. Shingle companies may also offer a manufacturers' warranty, which usually covers the cost of replacing defective materials.
  • Cost and financing: You should always get a cost estimate for the work, and you may also want to check if the roofer has any financing options to help make the cost more affordable.

Amherst Roofing Buyers Guide

Below, we'll discuss the services roofers typically offer, how to know when to replace your roof, and some tips on choosing the best company for you.

  • What Services Are Offered by Amherst Roofers?

    Roofers in Amherst specialize in a range of services, from roof repair and replacement to roof cleaning. Some even provide extra services like solar panel installation.

  • Roof Repair

    It is important to have a trustworthy roofer who can provide expert services for roof repair and replacement for your home. The severe storms in Amherst can cause extensive damage to roofs, and prompt repairs are necessary to avoid worse damage.

  • Roof Cleaning

    Another service that's needed in Amherst sometimes is roof cleaning. Moss can cause damage to your roof by pulling up shingles, which decreases your home's energy efficiency and exposes your underlayment to water. It's also a good idea to get your roof cleaned to increase the curb appeal of your home if you're planning on selling.

When Should I Replace My Roof in Amherst?

Replacing your roof in Amherst is a major task. There are some clear signs that can help you when it's time to replace your roof. A sign that you may need to replace your roof is multiple leaks or extensive damage that's too severe to be repaired.

A roof not only shields your home from the elements, but also can be a base for solar panels. Amherst homeowners who plan on putting on solar panels in the near future may want to plan on replacing their roof first. Otherwise, you may need to take down the panels later to replace your roof.

The final sign to take note of is if your roof has reached the end of its lifespan. Each type of roofing material lasts for a certain amount of time, generally between 20 and 30 years. The table below details the typical life expectancy of each roofing material.

Amherst Roofing Services FAQ

Which company is the best for roofing services in Amherst?

The Amherst roofing company with the best reputation is OConnor Contracting. In addition to having a wide range of services including roof repair and replacement, they boast a reputation for quality work and reliable customer service.

How can I tell if the roofer installed or repaired my roof properly?

Look at the roof for indications of good installation, such as clearly fastened shingles and no sagging or curling shingles. The roofer should remove any leftover debris and materials from the installation process. The roofer may use magnets to gather stray nails from your lawn.

Why should I use a professional roofing company?

The benefits of hiring a professional roofer include the chance to get a warranty for your roof and the promise that all the work is done according to local and state codes.

When should I replace my roof?

Roofers are busier during the summer. Booking during the colder may get you an off-season discount.

What are the signs of a roof in need of repair or replacement?

You likely need to repair or replace your roof if it is leaking or has visible damage.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at