Affiliate Disclosure: This Old House's Reviews Team is committed to delivering honest, objective, and independent reviews on home products and services. To support this business model, This Old House may be compensated if you purchase through links on our website. ... Affiliate Disclosure: This Old House's Reviews Team is committed to delivering honest, objective, and independent reviews on home products and services. To support this business model, This Old House may be compensated if you purchase through links on our website.

Best 5 Pest Control Companies in Oyster Bay, NY

Pests ranging from rodents to ants

Low costs without sacrificing quality

Companies with the best reputations

Reviews by This Old House Reviews Team
Last Updated June 02, 2023

There are a number of pests you may encounter living around the Oyster Bay area. If the area around your home is more densely populated, you may be particularly worried about pests like rats and bed bugs.

Whether your pest problem is big or small, our guide to the top pest control professionals in your area can help you take care of it.

Best 5 Oyster Bay Pest Control Companies

Terminix Logo


Top rated

Services Offered

Wasps Mosquitos Spiders Rats Fleas Moths Cockroaches Ticks Ants Termites Bed Bugs Mice


  • Serves more than 2.8 million customers annually
  • Instant online chat 24/7
  • Service guarantees in 46 states
Orkin Logo


Services Offered

Moths Rats Bed Bugs Termites Wasps Fleas Cockroaches Ticks Flies Mice Bees Spiders Ants Beetles


  • Over a century of experience
  • Same-day service if you call before noon local time
  • Technologically advanced solutions
Majestic Pest Control of Hicksville Logo

Majestic Pest Control of Hicksville

108A New South Rd 516-218-6470

Services Offered

Termites Spiders Mice Rats Flies Fleas Cockroaches Bed Bugs Bees Ants


  • Consistently high customer service reviews
  • Lack of hidden fees
  • Free inspections
EcoShield Pest Solutions Logo

EcoShield Pest Solutions

1 Enterprise Pl Unit E 631-274-7022

Services Offered

Spiders Bees Termites Fleas Wasps Ants Ticks Mosquitos Cockroaches Rats Bed Bugs Mice


  • Consistently high customer service reviews
  • Educational web content
  • Free inspections
Mosquito Joe of North Shore Long Island NY Logo

Mosquito Joe of North Shore Long Island NY

130 Newtown Rd 631-458-5810

Services Offered

Ticks Ants Fleas Mosquitos


  • Timeliness of service
  • Commitment to customer education
  • Reviews praise customer service

More Local Pest Control Companies

Long Island Exterminating Company

User Reviews: 4.7/5

675 W Jericho Turnpike
Huntington, NY 11743

National Pest Experts

User Reviews: 4.8/5

218 Broadway
Bethpage, NY 11714

Knockout Pest Control

User Reviews: 4.9/5

1009 Front St
Uniondale, NY 11553

Rest Easy Pest Control

User Reviews: 4.9/5

40 Glen St suite b
Glen Cove, NY 11542

Top Quality Exterminating Pest

User Reviews: 4.6/5

55 Broadway
Amityville, NY 11701

Select Exterminating

User Reviews: 4.8/5

149 New Hyde Park Rd
Franklin Square, NY 11010

Mosquito Joe of South Shore Long Island NY

User Reviews: 4.8/5

80 W Industry Ct
Deer Park, NY 11729

Mosquito Squad of Long Island

User Reviews: 4.9/5

3 Saxwood St #3c
Deer Park, NY 11729

Fox Pest Control

User Reviews: 4.8/5

66 S 2nd St Unit D
Bay Shore, NY 11706

Our Ranking Methodology

Learn More

The This Old House Reviews Team evaluated dozens of pest control companies in the Oyster Bay area. When selecting the best pest control companies, we looked at the following criteria:

  • Customer reviews and recommendations
  • Professional experience and specialties
  • Services and guarantees
  • Safety and treatment methods

For help choosing the right pest control company for your home, see our guide below.

Get a Quote for Pest Companies in Oyster Bay

You will receive instant results for free, no phone call required.

Facts about Oyster Bay
Average Max Temp: 58°F
Average Min Temp: 46°F
Average Daily Sunlight: 59%
Average Annual Snowfall: 24"
Average Monthly Precipitation: 3.76"
Average Monthly Pest Visit: $55

How To Choose a Pest Control Company

The most important step is selecting the best pest control company for the job. Important decision-making factors include a company's qualifications, its treatment methods, experience and reviews, and of course the cost of services.

Below, we explore the details of each of these factors.

  • Does the company have a valid license and permits to perform pest control?

    While the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has established minimum standards of competency for pesticide application, licensing is handled at the state level. All pesticide applicators (and those who supervise them) in New York need to be licensed by all the necessary state regulatory agencies.

  • Is the company a member of any professional organizations?

    A pest control company can optionally apply for certifications from trade organizations like QualityPro to back up its standards and methods. One particular certification is the GreenPro Service Certification, which is awarded to any company that can demonstrate that its methods are more environmentally friendly. A company that receives this certification also needs to maintain certain training standards for employees.

    Pest control companies can also obtain membership in professional organizations. Pest control companies can obtain membership in state-level organizations in addition to national organizations such as the National Pest Management Association (NPMA). By being a member of these optional organizations, a company helps support its reputability and gains access to education, resources, and a network of professionals to compare best practices with.

Professional Experience and Specialties

How long a company has been in business can tell you something about its experience dealing with the pests that live in Oyster Bay. Online reviews or the company's own website can also help you figure out whether it has the skills and experience necessary to handle your specific pest problem. If the answers to your questions aren't available online, calling a representative is an easy way to learn about the company's areas of expertise.

  • Reviews and Recommendations

    You can view a company's reviews and rating on the Better Business Bureau (BBB), read local review sites and social media to see what others in your area have to say, or verify its license standing via the New York licensing board.

  • Cost of Services and Guarantees

    For many people, cost is one of the most important factors when looking for pest control. Cost can be affected by factors like your location, the type of pest being treated, and the size of your house.

    You can consider whether a company offers free on-site estimates (to determine if it fits your budget), and what sort of guarantees it provides. Often, a company will guarantee that if its treatment doesn't resolve your pest problem, it will continue to come back until it does.

Safety and Treatment Methods

It's important to consider safety when choosing a pest control provider, and you might prefer a provider who employs more natural, environmentally-friendly methods.

  • Safety

    Your pest control provider should be able to explain the safety precautions of any and all pesticides that they're going to use. They should be able to explain whether the pesticides are low toxicity or non-toxic; if they are not, they should explain what safety precautions will be in place to protect your family, your pets, and you. Any pesticides that pose greater than a minimum risk are required to be registered with the EPA.

  • Treatment Methods

    You can ask if your technician will start with lower-toxicity, more natural options before trying harsher chemicals.

    Many companies are now using Integrated Pest Management (IPM) to eliminate pests while reducing personal and environmental risks. The steps of IPM are as follows:

    1. Identify the source of the pest problem and determine whether immediate action is needed.
    2. Determine the best and safest course of action.
    3. Manage the pest problem using a combination of biological, cultural, mechanical, and physical controls.
    4. Employ chemical controls only when required, and always along with other techniques for effective long-term pest management.
    5. Observe the results and implement additional pest control as needed.

Common Household Pests in Oyster Bay

Some pests are seen more commonly in Oyster Bay, and these pests are the ones you should keep an eye out for. Some of these include the following:

  • Beetles: In Oyster Bay and across the U.S., there are a number of species of beetles that could cause problems. Many beetles are harmless, but others can cause damage to your home by eating carpeting, wood, and more.
  • Mice: Some common signs of mice include chewed wires and droppings around your home. Mice tend to frequent attics or areas where food is stored.
  • Bed bugs: Bed bugs are found throughout New York, and they can cause big problems if left untreated. Because infestations of bed bugs can be tricky to get rid of, we recommend getting professional extermination as soon as you discover the problem. These pests can infest bedsheets, wallpaper, furniture, and more.

Oyster Bay Pest Control FAQ

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at

Pest infestations occur when pests come into your house looking for something, normally food, water, or shelter. Pests might be looking to eat food or trash left sitting out. Some might also be drawn to standing water outside (from rain collecting in one spot) or inside (from leaky pipes). Pests might also enter your house simply looking for shelter and get in through places such as foundation cracks or broken screens.

There are several steps you can take to help prevent pest infestations. First, avoid leaving food out. Keep your food stored in sealed containers, and avoid leaving trash sitting around.

Second, try not to have standing water in or around your home. Fix leaks indoors and eliminate places where standing water collects outdoors. Lastly, seal off any potential pest entrances into your home, including siding or foundation cracks.

Any time you notice signs of pest activity in your Oyster Bay home--which could include nests, droppings, signs of damage, or the pests themselves--you should reach out to an exterminator. If your home has had seasonal or recurrent pest infestations, we recommend getting in touch with a local pest control company to request annual pest management services.

We strongly suggest that you ask your pest technician if they want you to clean around your home. This can help them find, identify, and treat all pests present. However, some providers may want to see your home as-is.

If you are asked to clean, focus on getting paper goods and trash out of affected areas, as some pests like to hide in these items. Also be sure to put all food away so that it does not get contaminated by pesticides. Remove any plants in the area to avoid chemical contamination. Lastly, if necessary, block off areas that you anticipate will be treated so that pets and children do not enter until it is safe. If a more intensive process like fumigation is required, make sure you closely follow the instructions of your pest professional.

It's normal to feel like you're seeing more pests in the first few days or weeks after pest control. Pest control tends to flush pests from their hiding places, making them more visible; you might also find more dead pests around your house. If this uptick in pests sightings doesn't begin to decrease after one to two weeks, contact your Oyster Bay pest professional. Further treatment may be required.