clock menu more-arrow no yes

Best Pest Control Companies on Long Island, NY (2021)

If you need pest control in Long Island, we’ve got you covered. Read about the top companies in your area.

A pest control specialist in a green shirt uses a yellow pest duster on a white garage door of a blue house with black shutters and green lawn. Courtesy Aptive

Common household pests are a nuisance, but many can also spread disease and damage your home. Many pests are notoriously difficult to kill, and if the problem isn’t quickly solved, you could have an infestation on your hands. Hiring a Long Island pest control company is the best way to exterminate unwanted pests in your home, and acting quickly can save you time and money in the long run.

Long Island is known for its beaches and state parks, including Jones Beach State Park, Fire Island, and Montauk Point State Park. It’s the longest and largest island in the contiguous United States and houses nearly 40% of New York’s population. It’s relatively close to Manhattan and the Bronx and comprises four counties—Kings, Queens, Nassau, and Suffolk—all areas that require pest control services.

If you live on Long Island, you have several options for pest control. Every company promises to rid your home safely of pests, but some companies are better than others. In this article, we’ll review some of the best pest control companies in your area.

Top 6 Pest Control Companies in Long Island

  1. Best Overall: Terminix
  2. Best for Urgent Service: Orkin
  3. Most Customizable: Aptive
  4. Long Island Exterminating Co.
  5. Pest Assassins Exterminating
  6. The Bug Bandit, LLC

Best Long Island Pest Control Companies

If you’re looking for the best pest control on Long Island, we recommend Terminix, Orkin, and Aptive. Terminix scored best overall in our review, Orkin is our top pick for quick service, and Aptive is another top provider that provides customizable pest control solutions.

1. Best Overall: Terminix

Address: 45 S Service Road, Plainview, NY 11803

Phone number: 866-569-4035

Terminix is our top overall provider, scoring well in every category of our review. Terminix has served Long Island residents since 1927 and continues to offer cutting-edge pest control services that are safe for the entire family, backed by research from PhD-level entomologists. Terminix’s general pest control consists of a home inspection and initial treatment followed by three additional treatments over the course of a year.

✔ 24/7 customer service

✔ Online account management and automatic payment options

✔ Coverage for termites and bedbugs

Terminix can treat dozens of common pests on Long Island, and it guarantees that your pest problems will be solved. If pests return between services, you’ll receive free re-service until the pests are gone. In addition to pest control, Terminix offers services, such as attic insulation and home disinfection services, to better protect your home.

Areas served: All of Nassau and Suffolk County

Here’s a BBB review from a Terminix customer:

We live in the Hampton Roads area and we’ve had good success with [Terminix]. They took care of our moisture problem and installed our insulation in our attic and underneath our crawl space. They were very professional, cordial, and was about getting the job done! Very nice guys. [A] couple days later, a quality check was done to [ensure] the job was done right, which it was. Thank you, Terminix, for a job well done. Our home feels a lot better inside with our new insulation! I would recommend this business.” — Jennifer N.

If you want world-class pest control at an affordable price, get a quote from Terminix by filling out this form.

2. Best for Urgent Service: Orkin

Addresses: 40-27 Crescent Street, Queens, NY 11101

75 Nassau Terminal Road, New Hyde Park, NY 11040

Phone number: 877-868-1416

If you need quick service on Long Island, consider hiring Orkin for your pest control needs. Since 1901, Orkin has grown to be the largest pest control service in the country. Due to its large network of technicians, Orkin can offer next-day service. If your pest control needs are urgent, you likely can’t afford to wait several days or weeks for an open appointment.

✔ Next-day service option

✔ More than 1.7 million customers

✔ All technicians receive 160 hours of training

All Orkin technicians are highly trained, with 160 hours of training for each specialist. An Orkin technician will be able to identify the source of your pest problem easily and quickly provide a course of action. Orkin’s general pest control service is also seasonal, meaning your home will be treated several times over the course of a year. Once treatments are over, your Orkin specialist will follow up to make sure the pests haven’t returned and make recommendations on how to prevent a future outbreak.

Areas served: All of Nassau and Suffolk County

Here’s a BBB review from an Orkin customer:

Great company to work with. From my phone call to request a service throughout billing, this company is extremely professional. David is very polite and explains what the service will be like and always follows up. The people on the phone are very responsible, as well. We use them for all critter control and bee issues.” — Joni L.

To learn more about Orkin and get a free quote, fill out this form.

3. Most Customizable: Aptive

Address: 100 E Jefryn Boulevard #Q, Deer Park, NY 11729

Phone number: 855-697-0130

Aptive was founded in 2015 by Vess Pearson, who had already worked in the pest control industry for several years. Aptive is already the eighth-largest pest control provider in the country, due to its high quality of service and customizable plans.

✔ Uses products derived from chrysanthemums

✔ Aptive regularly donates money to fight malaria

✔ Offers free re-services when necessary

Aptive’s pest control plans feature a home inspection and initial treatment followed by four additional treatments throughout the year. If you have any returning pests after treatments are performed, Aptive will re-treat your home at no additional cost.

Areas served: All of Nassau and Suffolk County

Here’s a BBB review from an Aptive customer:

We just started using Aptive and have been extremely satisfied with our service thus far. The representatives have been pleasant to deal with and [are] very knowledgeable. Miguel set us up and Justin completed our first service today. I’m thrilled with the contract regarding services and pricing. Both representatives were polite, professional and committed. We’re looking forward to having this much needed service for our home. Thank you, Aptive!” — Renea T.

If you want to customize your pest control plan, we recommend getting a free quote from Aptive by filling out this easy online form.

4. Long Island Exterminating Co.

Address: 675 W Jericho Turnpike, Huntington, NY 11743

Phone number: 631-271-9811

Long Island Exterminating Co. has been family owned and operated since 1958 and serves Long Island as well as all five boroughs of New York City. Even though Long Island Exterminating Co. is a local company, it is able to offer 24/7 service. You can sign up for a free home inspection through Long Island Exterminating Co. if you’re unsure about which pests are in your home.

Long Island Exterminating Co. uses an Integrated Pest Management approach to pest control, meaning it utilizes non-toxic traps and eco-friendly materials when treating your home. This keeps your family’s safety as the highest priority. In addition to general pest control, Long Island Exterminating Co. offers specialized termite, rodent, and bedbug treatments.

Here’s a Yelp review from a Long Island Exterminating Co. customer:

Steve / Long Island Exterminating responded to an emergency situation on a Sunday morning. He was at our house within an hour and handled the situation in a very professional manner. We are very fortunate to Steve, especially for responding on a Sunday morning and HIGHLY recommend him to anyone needing services. Thank you!” — Steven S.

Quotes are not available through This Old House.

5. Pest Assassins Exterminating

Address: 3 Larson Avenue, Smithtown, NY 11787

Phone number: 631-305-8989

Pest Assassins Exterminating is another locally owned and family operated pest control service on Long Island. Pest Assassins employs several licensed and highly trained technicians who are committed to providing excellent customer service. All appointments are set around your schedule for maximum convenience, and all prices can be adjusted to match your budget.

Pest Assassins practices eco-friendly Integrated Pest Management techniques to best protect you and your family. There are a wide range of pest control services available through Pest Assassins, including termite control, wildlife control, bedbug control, and rodent control. Its website also contains a full list of products used when servicing homes, so you can be sure you will stay protected.

Here’s a Yelp review from a Pest Assassins Exterminating customer:

Don’t fall for other ‘professionals’ who scare you into purchasing services that aren’t necessary. Corey is by far the most honest, knowledgeable, and thorough I’ve come across. He walked me through everything I needed to know, what to look for, and how to best remedy the situation. I wouldn’t hesitate to contact him again if ever needed in the future and will absolutely recommend him over anyone else. Thanks for all the help!” — Shiraz Z.

Quotes are not available through This Old House.

6. The Bug Bandit, LLC

Address: 5 Van Buren Avenue, Centereach, NY 11720

Phone number: 631-405-9255

The Bug Bandit, LLC, founded by Craig Levy, is a local pest control company on Long Island that is accredited by the National Pest Management Association. The Bug Bandit can eliminate pests that already exist in your home, but it also offers a Bug Blockade service, which secures the perimeter of your home to guard against any future infestations.

The Bug Bandit employs a three-step method for eliminating pests: investigate and identify, deploy and destroy, and monitor and maintain. Service begins with a 36-point inspection of your home to determine the source of your pest problems. Once a plan of action is formed, your home will be treated. The Bug Bandit will follow up with you at a later date to ensure that the pests have stayed out of your home.

Note: There are currently no customer reviews for The Bug Bandit, LLC.

Quotes are not available through This Old House.

Compare Pest Control Companies

Provider Terminix Orkin Aptive
Provider Terminix Orkin Aptive
Get a Quote terminix.com orkin.com aptive.com
Our Overall Score out of 100 92 94 91
Superlative Best Customer Service Best for Urgent Service Most Customizable
States Available 47 47 23
Annual Cost for General Pest Control $445–$700 $575 (average) $560–620
BBB Rating* C+ A+ A-
Online chat Yes No No

Our Recommendation

If you suspect that your home contains pests, consider reaching out to a professional pest control service for a consultation or home inspection. A licensed technician can quickly diagnose the problem. If you’re in need of pest control, we recommend getting a quote from Terminix, Orkin, and Aptive. All three companies are available on Long Island and are proven, reputable providers.

Common Pests in Long Island

Long Island is home to a wide variety of household pests and rodents. Most professional pest control companies in Long Island are equipped to handle these common pests:

  • Termites
  • Bedbugs
  • Cockroaches
  • Rats and mice
  • Fleas
  • Ticks
  • Mosquitoes
  • Stinging insects
  • Ants
  • Spiders
  • Houseflies
  • Gnats
  • Crickets
  • Moths
  • Beetles

Why You Should Hire Exterminators in Long Island

An extermination service can save you time and money in the long run. Many common household pests are difficult to exterminate without proper knowledge and training, so many homeowners who attempt to do it themselves don’t fully solve the problem. Some pests, such as termites and wood-boring beetles, can cause structural damage to your home that ends up costing much more than the price of a professional pest control service. If you’re in need of pest control, we recommend starting with quotes from Terminix, Orkin, and Aptive.

How To Choose Pest Control in Long Island

If you’re searching for the right pest control company, consider the following factors.

  • Type of pest — If you know what type of pests are present in your home, make sure a provider offers treatment for those pests before ordering service. If you are uncertain, a licensed technician will be able to quickly identify the pest.
  • Cost — Pest control is important, but it must be affordable. Getting a quote from a provider online or over the phone is recommended so you can budget accordingly.
  • Schedules — Find out how frequently your provider performs service. Many yearly pest control plans feature four or five seasonal treatments over the course of a year, while some providers offer one-time service.
  • Reputation — We recommend reading customer reviews before making any purchases. If your provider is consistently receiving negative reviews, you may want to consider another company.

Pest Control Companies Methodology

In our independent review, our team analyzed and reviewed dozens of pest control companies across the country. Each company was given a score out of 100 based on these factors.

  • Plan options (35): Every home and every pest problem has its specific needs when it comes to prevention and remediation. Companies with multiple plans and service offerings were given higher scores than those without.
  • State Availability (5): Where you live determines which providers are available. Companies available in more states were rated higher than those with less.
  • Trustworthiness (15): We consider companies that offer service guarantees and others more trustworthy and therefore scored higher.
  • Customer Service (35): This factor is based on our own research from calling providers, as well as their availability and guarantees for responses.
  • Additional Benefits (10): Companies who offer things like information about the products they use, have an app for customers, and other benefits were given higher ratings.

Long Island Pest Control Frequently Asked Questions

Is Aptive a legit company?

We have found Aptive to be an effective provider of pest control services for Long Island residents. Despite being founded in 2015, Aptive’s quality of service is on par with its more experienced competitors, and Aptive is the eighth-largest provider of pest control in the United States.

Are there termites on Long Island?

Long Island is home to subterranean termites, which can cause severe damage to the structure of your home, often costing thousands of dollars in repairs. If you suspect you have a termite infestation, you should immediately call a pest control company that is equipped to exterminate termites.

How much does pest control on Long Island cost?

It will ultimately depend on the type of pest you need exterminated and the severity of your infestation. Pests such as termites and bedbugs are more difficult to kill and will inevitably cost more. The size of your home will often affect your quoted rate, since a bigger house will require more chemicals and manpower for an adequate treatment.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.