We may be compensated if you purchase through links on our website. Our Reviews Team is committed to delivering honest, objective, and independent reviews on home products and services. More

5 Best Flooring Companies in Oyster Bay, NY

Get matched with a top local pro
Join the 6,755 people who have received a free, no-obligation quote in the last 30 days
  1. Home
  2. Find Local Pros
  3. Flooring Near Me
  4. New York
  5. Oyster Bay
  6. Oyster Bay Flooring
Written By Max Peterson | Last Updated: February 05, 2024

Many Oyster Bay residents work to preserve their older homes' character. Whether you're dealing with worn-out carpet or antique wood flooring, a local flooring contractor can help unleash your existing floors' historic charm or install a timeless new solution. These Oyster Bay, NY flooring installers offer excellent value, a knowledgeable team, and a comprehensive selection.

Best for Eco-Friendly Options
4.5
  • International product catalog
  • In-home consultations
  • Highly positive reputation among customers
Most Convenient
4.5
  • Complementary in-home consultations
  • Wide variety of product choices
  • Products for every budget/style/need
Best for Hardwood
4.5
  • Hundreds of locations across U.S. and Canada
  • DIY-friendly
  • Affordable prices and special financing options

5 Best Flooring Companies in Oyster Bay

LL Flooring (Lumber Liquidators) Logo

LL Flooring (Lumber Liquidators)

GET QUOTE
4.5/5
Based on 63 customer reviews.

Services Offered

Laminate Flooring Commercial Flooring Waterproofing Engineered Hardwood Hardwood Flooring Tiles Vinyl

Highlights

  • Informative resources
  • Accessible customer support team
  • Free quote
24 Kinkel St, Westbury, NY 516-874-2033 llflooring.com
Pagano Tile And Remodeling Logo

Pagano Tile And Remodeling

4.7/5
Based on 21 customer reviews.

Services Offered

Commercial Flooring Repair Floor Cleaning Vinyl Residential Flooring Natural Stone Tiles

Highlights

  • Free quote
  • Clear pricing policy
  • Informative resources
78 Honeysuckle Rd, Levittown, NY 516-454-7998 paganotileny.com
TILES UP Logo

TILES UP

4.7/5
Based on 45 customer reviews.

Services Offered

Residential Flooring Tiles Natural Stone

Highlights

  • Accessible customer support team
  • Free quote
  • Clear pricing policy
620 Walt Whitman Rd, Melville, NY 631-944-3444 tiles-up.business.site
Luxury Carpet Logo

Luxury Carpet

4.7/5
Based on 58 customer reviews.

Services Offered

Carpets Tiles Commercial Flooring Residential Flooring

Highlights

  • Accessible customer support team
  • Clear pricing policy
10 Central Ave, Westbury, NY 516-997-1155 luxurycarpet.com

More Local Flooring Companies

Balaji flooring solutions

User Reviews: 4.6/5 

12 Newtown Plaza
Plainview, NY 11803

Euro Floors LLC

User Reviews: 4.6/5 

83 Hickory Ln
Levittown, NY 11756

Class Carpet Floor & Home

User Reviews: 4.6/5 

29 Jerusalem Ave
Levittown, NY 11756

Wood Flooring Long Island - K.O Floors | Vinyl Flooring | Wooden Floors

User Reviews: 4.6/5 

14 Craig Dr
Huntington Station, NY 11746

Oldfield Flooring

User Reviews: 4.6/5 

620 Pulaski Rd
Greenlawn, NY 11740

Long Island Tile Company (formerly Ideal Tile)

User Reviews: 4.6/5 

2091 Jericho Turnpike
East Northport, NY 11731

Long Island Paneling, Ceilings & Floors

User Reviews: 4.5/5 

669 Old Country Rd
Westbury, NY 11590

Gold Coast Flooring Supply Nassau & Suffolk

User Reviews: 4.5/5 

870 S Oyster Bay Rd
Hicksville, NY 11801

Old Country Ceramic Tile Inc

User Reviews: 4.5/5 

27 Urban Ave
Westbury, NY 11590

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviewsteam@thisoldhousereviews.com.

Get Your Flooring Project Quote Today

Get matched with a top local pro

Please enter a valid 5-digit zip code!

Facts about Oyster Bay
Average Max Temp: 59°F
Average Min Temp: 46°F
Average Monthly Precipitation: 3.76"
Median Home Size: 2007 sqft
Homeownership Rate: 81%
Most Popular Flooring Type: Hardwood

Expert Tips By

This Old House empowers homeowners with the knowledge and tools they need to tackle various projects and navigate the complexities of homeownership.

Popular Types of Flooring

Whether you're looking for something elegant and subtle or lively and bold, there's a floor for you. Discover the most essential details about each type to guide your decision making.

Hardwood Flooring

Homebuyers across Oyster Bay seek out hardwood flooring for its beauty and durability. It's available in several varieties to accommodate different designs, from oak and maple to cherry and walnut. Despite its charm, hardwood comes with a higher price tag. You also need to stick to a consistent refinishing schedule every few years, filling in the gaps with specialty cleaners. The more time you invest in maintenance, the longer your floors will last.

Engineered Wood Flooring

Engineered wood gives you the aesthetic of hardwood without the strict maintenance. They use a plywood foundation with a layer of real hardwood on top – ultimately saving you money. Despite the lower retail cost, it might feel more hollow to walk on, and the slender hardwood layer can only be refinished one time. That said, its lower propensity to warp could still make it a worthy investment.

Laminate Flooring

Laminate floors come in wood and tile finishes, but they all have a particle board base. A strong plastic coating gives them resilience against scratches and simplifies cleaning. However, it's more susceptible to water damage and chipping.

Vinyl Flooring

Maintenance with vinyl floors is uncomplicated. You can purchase them in luxury vinyl tile (LVT) or luxury vinyl plank (LVP) styles, with each option equally durable. They also come at a reasonable price point, somewhere between laminate and engineered wood.

Tile Flooring

Tile flooring is another timeless-looking, robust option. Like vinyl, it requires minimal maintenance and is simple to clean. As such, it's an ideal choice for areas prone to moisture like bathrooms and kitchens. However, it requires intensive prep work before installation and can be cool and slippery to walk on. Pricing depends on the material you pick, with porcelain being more expensive than ceramic.

Stone Flooring

Granite, sandstone, travertine, and marble aren't just for the outdoors. Inside, they can give you a bold look and unparalleled water resistance. However, like hardwood, it can be expensive and difficult to clean.

Linoleum Flooring

With attentive maintenance, linoleum floors can last for years. It is a cost-effective choice with various alternatives for adaptation. However, it can readily get dented or scratched and has been known to fade when exposed to direct sunlight. The sun's rays also lead linoleum to fade over time, and it may not be suitable for areas with excess moisture.

Carpet

Carpet is the most affordable flooring option. It can make a space feel more homey and is great for muffling sound. You don’t have to worry about scratches or dents, and the cushioning makes it a safer choice for kids. However, the fibrous material easily retains stains, moisture, and odors, which isn't ideal for pet owners or allergy sufferers.

How to Choose a Oyster Bay Flooring Company

Choosing the right installer makes all the difference for your new floor's longevity. We recommend screening different companies using the following criteria.

Reputation and Reviews

The first thing to note is whether a company is known for good service and high-quality work. Check review sites like Google, Yelp, Trustpilot, and the Better Business Bureau (BBB) to see what previous clients have to say. Even the most reliable flooring installers will have both positive and negative reviews. Look for how a business responds to complaints and interacts with others. If it works toward a satisfactory resolution and acts in good faith, that's a good sign. However, if it's argumentative or has a high negative-to-positive review ratio, it's best to avoid working with it.

Portfolio and References

Most floor installers keep portfolios of their past projects. We recommend requesting a copy so you can examine the crew's workmanship. Portfolios might also include references from past customers. Request their contact information so you can discuss their experiences and thoughts about the company.

Specialization and Services

Look for a business that specializes in the type of flooring you're interested in. For example, a crew might be experienced with carpet but not hardwood. An installer's service offerings can also make a difference. At the very least, you should choose a provider that will dispose of your old flooring materials. However, providers can also offer refinishing services or design consultations.

Cost

Cost is crucial to consider, but it should be less important than quality in your selection process. We recommend getting three to five different quotes for your flooring job to compare pricing and workmanship. Many companies offer on-site and online estimates to streamline the process.

Warranties and Guarantees

Flooring services typically come with a pair of warranties. The first one, issued by the manufacturer, covers the materials. The second backs the installation crew's workmanship. While some manufacturers and contractors have lifetime warranties, most are still restricted to a specific time period (often ten years.) If you'd like additional coverage, you might be able to pay extra for an extended warranty.

Estimated Timeline

You don't want your flooring project to last longer than expected. Get an estimated timeline up-front and ask about potential delays. Express your expectations clearly and secure any guarantees in writing.

Ready to Get a Quote on Your Flooring Project?

Get matched with a top local pro

Please enter a valid 5-digit zip code!

Frequently Asked Questions About Flooring in Oyster Bay

How much will it cost to install a new floor in Oyster Bay?

Generally, flooring installation costs in Oyster Bay range from $0.60 to $4.00 per square foot. An estimate will factor in your space's size, the type of floor you'd like, and the job's complexity. You can find the best price by getting multiple estimates and comparing them side by side.

See our guides to how much each flooring type typically costs:

What are some of the most popular types of flooring in Oyster Bay?

According to local data, most Oyster Bay homes use more than one flooring material. However, hardwood is ultimately the most popular choice.

Do Oyster Bay flooring companies need to be licensed?

New York doesn't require flooring companies to get a state license, but cities often choose to require licenses of their own. We encourage you to contact your local government office for more information on contractor licensing. If your city doesn't require licensure, ask each company about its private certifications, each of which can demonstrate professionalism and skill in the trade.

If I'm replacing a kitchen floor, what material should I buy?

For kitchen floors, you'll want to purchase a material that holds up well to moisture. Some options to consider include vinyl and tile.

Are there environmentally friendly flooring options in Oyster Bay?

Many, but not all, Oyster Bay flooring companies offer eco-friendly options. Your estimator can point you toward sustainably harvested, reclaimed and recycled coverings. They can also discuss options to recycle your old flooring.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviewsteam@thisoldhousereviews.com.

Other Flooring Resources

Sources