We may be compensated if you purchase through links on our website. Our Reviews Team is committed to delivering honest, objective, and independent reviews on home products and services. More
Exterminator and customer

Best 5 Pest Control Companies in Brookhaven, NY

Get matched with a top local pro
Join the 6,755 people who have received a free, no-obligation quote in the last 30 days
  1. Home
  2. Local Pros
  3. Pest Control
  4. NY
  5. Brookhaven
Written By Jessica Hurtault|Last Updated: May 18, 2024

When Brookhaven's rainy months start, residents must prepare for battle against damaging pests such as mosquitos and silverfish. Licensed and experienced exterminators can help you control infestations and prevent them from starting in the future.

Whether your pest problem is large or small, our list of pest control companies in Brookhaven can help you choose the right team to resolve it.

Best Overall
  • Serves more than 2.8 million customers annually
  • Nearly 100 years in business
  • Service guarantees in 46 states
Best for Urgent Service
  • Over a century of experience
  • Same-day service if you call before noon local time
  • 30-day money-back guarantee

Best 5 Brookhaven Pest Control Companies

Orkin Logo


Based on 1,289 customer reviews.

Services Offered

MiceBed BugsWaspsAntsBeetlesSpidersFumigationMosquitosTermitesCockroachesWildlifeBeesFliesGreen Pest ControlGeneral Pest ControlBaiting


  • Educational web content
  • Positive customer service reviews
  • Free inspections
200 Main St Ste C, Monroe, CT 475-298-4469 orkin.comRead More: Orkin Review
Quest Pest Control Logo

Quest Pest Control

Based on 292 customer reviews.

Services Offered

SilverfishCockroachesTicksAntsSpidersPreventionBed BugsFliesGeneral Pest ControlFleasGreen Pest ControlMiceWaspsBeesTermitesWildlifeMosquitos


  • Lack of hidden fees
  • Free inspection policy
  • Continuous highly praised customer service reports
8586, 514 Rte 25a #2, Rocky Point, NY 631-228-4498 questpest.net
NoFo Tick & Mosquito Control Logo

NoFo Tick & Mosquito Control

Based on 17 customer reviews.

Services Offered

PreventionMosquitosGeneral Pest ControlGreen Pest ControlTicksFleas


  • Positive customer service reviews
  • Commitment to customer education
  • No-cost inspections
58 Blydenburgh Rd, Centereach, NY 631-888-6636 nofotickcontrol.com
General Exterminating Logo

General Exterminating

Based on 21 customer reviews.

Services Offered

WaspsMiceAntsSpidersBed BugsCockroachesFleasTermitesWildlifeGeneral Pest Control


  • Educational web content
  • Lack of hidden fees
  • Free inspection policy
311 Bristol Ct, Holbrook, NY 631-319-8840 generalexterminating.net

More Local Pest Control Companies

EcoTech Pest Control Inc.

User Reviews: 4.7/5 

650 Montauk Hwy #15
Bayport, NY 11705

All Care Pest Control, Inc.

User Reviews: 4.6/5 

4 Trout St
East Patchogue, NY 11772

Regal Exterminators

User Reviews: 4.7/5 

200 Smithtown Blvd
Nesconset, NY 11767

Mr. Mosquito

User Reviews: 4.5/5 

1484 Broadway Ave
Holbrook, NY 11741

Emerald Magic Lawn Care

User Reviews: 4.4/5 

194 Morris Ave Suite 4
Holtsville, NY 11742

Precision Exterminating Services, Inc.

User Reviews: 4.3/5 

1493 Church St
Holbrook, NY 11741

JP McHale Pest Management

User Reviews: 4.6/5 

30 Pond Rd
Oakdale, NY 11769

Suburban Exterminating

User Reviews: 5/5 

879 W Jericho Turnpike
Smithtown, NY 11787

Alternative Earthcare

User Reviews: 5/5 

240 S Fehr Way
Bay Shore, NY 11706

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviewsteam@thisoldhousereviews.com.

Exterminator and customer

Get Your Pest Control Project Quote Today

Get matched with a top local pro

Please enter a valid 5-digit zip code!

Facts about Brookhaven
Average Max Temp:55°F
Average Min Temp:49°F
Average Daily Sunlight:58%
Average Annual Snowfall:27.7"
Average Monthly Precipitation:3.90"
Average Monthly Pest Visit:$237

Expert Tips By

This Old House empowers homeowners with the knowledge and tools they need to tackle various projects and navigate the complexities of homeownership.

How To Choose a Pest Control Company

It's important to choose the right pest control professionalfor you. A company's qualifications and pest treatment methods are important to consider, as well as its years of experience and what other customers have said. Of course, you also want to think about cost.

Below, we explore the details of each of these factors.

  • Does the company have a valid license and permits to perform pest control?

    The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) sets minimum standards of competency for pesticide applicators, but licensing is handled at the state level. All pesticide applicators and supervisors in New York must be licensed through the proper state regulatory agencies.

  • Is the company a member of any professional organizations?

    One optional certification that could be worth looking for is the GreenPro Service Certification. In order to obtain this certification, a pest control company must both demonstrate that its practices are more environmentally friendly and uphold certain training standards for its technicians. Companies can obtain other certifications from trade organizations like QualityPro to further support their work.

    Pest control companies can also be members of certain professional organizations. Being a member of organizations like the National Pest Management Association (NPMA) or state-level organizations is not required, but helps show that a company is reputable. Membership in the NPMA gives companies access to resources, education, and a network of professionals with whom to discuss methods and practices.

Professional Experience and Specialties

You can gain some insight into a pest company's experience level by finding out how many years it has been in business. Local reviews and the company's own website can also inform you whether a company has experience dealing with the specific species of pests that are afflicting your home. You can reach out to a representative directly to learn this information if you can't find it online.

  • Reviews and Recommendations

    You can browse reviews and recommendations on local review sites or social media, look up a company's rating on the Better Business Bureau (BBB), or check the status of its license through the New York licensing board.

  • Cost of Services and Guarantees

    Cost is important when choosing a pest control company. Cost may be determined by the type of pest being treated, your location, the size of your house, and other factors.

    Certain pest control companies offer a free on-site estimate to help you match services to your budget. You can also check to see if it offers a satisfaction guarantee.

Safety and Treatment Methods

Safety is an important consideration when choosing a pest control company. You might also prefer a provider who uses more natural, environmentally friendly pest control services.

  • Safety

    Be sure to ask your pest control provider if the chemicals they're using are low toxicity or non-toxic, and if not, what kind of precautionary measures they plan to take. Any pesticides that are not minimum-risk chemicals need to be registered with the EPA. Your pest technician should be able to provide information about all pesticides that they plan to use.

  • Treatment Methods

    Many companies are making the switch to using more natural and eco-friendly treatment methods before, or instead of, harsh chemical pesticides. Some utilize a program called Integrated Pest Management (IPM). The steps of IPM are as follows:

    1. Identify the source of the pest problem and determine if immediate action is required.
    2. Determine the best and safest course of action.
    3. Use a combination of physical, cultural, biological, and mechanical controls to manage the pest problem.
    4. Use chemical controls only when required, and always along with other methods for effective long-term pest management.
    5. Evaluate outcomes and continue with additional pest control as needed.

Common Household Pests in Brookhaven

You might run into some pests more frequently in Brookhaven. Some pests to keep an eye out for include these:

  • Mosquitoes: On top of being a nuisance, a mosquito infestation can result in itchy bites and possibly even put you and your family at risk of diseases. Mosquitoes are most common in wetter climates (like Brookhaven) and at warmer times of the year.
  • Ants: Ants can be found in just about every part of New York. Large carpenter ants can be an even bigger problem than normal soil ants, as they can cause structural damage to your house.
  • Spiders: These pests prefer dark and damp places and are commonly found in basements or attics.
  • Bed bugs: Bed bug infestations are often very difficult to eliminate, so we recommend calling a professional as soon as possible. Bed bugs are found throughout New York, and can infest not only your bedsheets, but also other furniture and even your wallpaper.
  • Mice: If your home has a mouse infestation, you might notice droppings or things like chewed wires. Frequently, mice are found in attics or in places where food is stored.

Ready to Get a Quote on Your Pest Control Project?

Get matched with a top local pro

Please enter a valid 5-digit zip code!

Frequently Asked Questions About Pest Control in Brookhaven

What causes pest infestations?

Pest infestations happen when pests enter your home looking for something, normally food, water, or shelter. Pests might seek out and eat food or trash that is left out. Some may also be drawn by standing water collecting outside (from rain collecting in a particular spot) or inside (from leaky pipes). They might also enter your home simply looking for shelter and get in through weak spots such as broken screens or foundation cracks.

How can I prevent pest infestations?

One thing you can do to prevent pest infestations is seal off possible entrances into your home. This includes things like cracks in your siding or foundation. Second, avoid leaving out food for pests. This includes keeping food in sealed containers as well as not leaving trash out. Lastly, eliminate standing water in and around your home. Try to reduce places where water can collect outside, and fix leaks inside.

When should I hire a pest control professional?

When you notice signs of pest activity in your Brookhaven home—such as droppings, nests, signs of damage, or the pests themselves—you should call an exterminator. If your home has had seasonal or recurrent pest infestations, we suggest reaching out to a local pest control company to set up annual pest management services.

Do pests come out after a technician sprays for them?

It's normal to feel as though you're seeing more pests in the days or weeks following pest control. The process tends to flush pests out of their hiding places, making them more visible; you might also see more dead pests around your home. If this uptick in pests sightings doesn't start to decrease after a week or two, reach out to your Brookhaven pest professional. Further treatment may be required.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviewsteam@thisoldhousereviews.com.