clock menu more-arrow no yes

Nationwide Renters Insurance Review (2021)

Nationwide offers coverage beyond standard renters insurance, with credit card coverage, ordinance protection, and building alteration coverage. To see what else this provider has to offer, read our in-depth Nationwide renters insurance review.

Cottage protected by a Nationwide renters insurance policy Adobe

Nationwide is a trusted insurance company in the industry and has close to 95 years of experience. Nationwide renters insurance offered is just as popular as its other types of insurance policies with coverage for credit cards, building alterations, and ordinances, on top of personal liability, personal property, loss of use, and medical payments to others.

With a variety of renters insurance providers available, the This Old House Reviews Team did the research for you to help you find the right policy for your home and budget. Keep reading to learn if Nationwide offers the best renters insurance for your home.

Pros & Cons of Nationwide

Pros Cons
Pros Cons
✔ Offers coverage for unauthorized charges on your credit card ✘ Customers can only talk to a sales or customer service representative during certain hours
✔ Has a variety of additional coverage options, like loss of refrigerated food and personal injury ✘ Expensive premiums are higher than the national average of $15 a month
✔ Has a claims center that’s open 24/7

Nationwide Renters Insurance Coverage

A Nationwide renters insurance policy protects you from the following events:

Nationwide renters insurance policies will not cover the following:

  • Valuables
  • Home business
  • Motorized vehicles

With Nationwide, you get coverage in seven areas of renters insurance:

1. Personal Property

This protects the items that you own inside of your rental. Nationwide allows you to choose between replacement cash value (RCV) and the actual cash value (ACV). RCV is more expensive than ACV, but it covers replacement costs as if your damaged belongings were new. ACV only covers the cost of the items as they are now, which means you’re given less money because of depreciation. Nationwide has an estimation tool in their online quote form to help you determine your property’s value.

In the quote we received from Nationwide, it covered $25,000 for personal property.

2. Loss of Use

This portion covers additional living expenses that are accrued when you have to temporarily leave your home after an event damages the property.

In the quote we received, Nationwide covered $5,000 for loss of use.

3. Liability

If you’re found liable for an incident that harms someone else or their property, your policy will cover the costs. An example of this would be if water reaches the floor below you and damages your neighbor’s belongings.

In our quote, Nationwide covered $100,000 for liability coverage.

4. Medical Payments to Others

If a guest in your home is injured, you can pay for their medical bills through this policy.

In the quote we received, Nationwide covered $1,000 per person for medical payments to others.

5. Ordinance or Law

This coverage pays to bring your home up to code and only comes into play if an event requires repairs to your home, and the repair technician finds a code violation.

Nationwide covered 10% of building additions and alterations for ordinance or law coverage in the quote we received.

6. Building Additions and Alterations

If you make small alterations to your rental, like changing the light fixtures, your policy will cover damage to these changes. A portion of your personal property amount is set aside for this coverage.

Nationwide covered $2,500 for building additions and alterations in the quote we received.

7. Credit Card

This pays for a certain amount of unauthorized charges to your credit card or bank account.

Nationwide covered $500 for credit cards in the quote we received.

Here’s how much you can purchase for each type of coverage based on North Carolina data:

Nationwide Coverage Breakdown

Area of Coverage Amount Range
Area of Coverage Amount Range
Personal property No limit
Loss of use 20% of personal property
Liability $100,000, $200,000, $300,000, $400,000, or $500,000
Medical payments to others $1,000, $2,000, $3,000, $4,000, or $5,000
Ordinance or law 10%, 25%, or 50% of building additions and alterations
Building additions and alterations 10% of personal property
Credit card $500, $1,000, $2,500, $5,000, $7,500 or $10,000
Deductible $500, $1,000, or $2,500

Nationwide Additional Coverage

Nationwide has an extensive list of additional coverage options to customize your renters insurance policy:

  • Personal injury
  • Limited water backup
  • Increased building additions and alterations
  • Refrigerated property
  • Earthquake
  • Scheduled personal property
  • Flood insurance
  • Personal liability umbrella coverage
  • Additional insureds

How Much Does Nationwide Cost?

Nationwide renters insurance costs about $20 per month, according to the company’s website. To see how much an actual policy would cost, we used Nationwide’s online tool to get a quote for a single woman living in a one-bedroom apartment in Raleigh, North Carolina:

Nationwide Cost Breakdown

Area of Coverage Coverage Amount
Area of Coverage Coverage Amount
Deductible $500
Monthly cost $21.50

Note: This quote is for an RCV policy.

When requesting a free quote, you’ll have to provide Nationwide with the following information:

  • Name
  • Address
  • Date of birth
  • Marital status
  • Gender
  • Phone number
  • Email address
  • Size of building
  • Number of pets

Customer Service and Claims Support

The best way to manage your policy and file a claim is by using the customer portal or the mobile app. If you would prefer to talk to a customer representative, you can call 800-421-3535 for the claims center or 877-669-6877 for sales and general customer support.

The sales department operates Monday through Friday, from 8 am–10 pm and on Saturday, from 9 am–7:30 pm. General customer service is only available Monday through Friday, from 8 am–9 pm.

Our Conclusion

The base renters insurance policy from Nationwide offers coverage in more areas than just personal property, loss of use, liability, and medical payments to others. You’ll receive ordinance or law, building addition and alteration, and credit card protection and the option of nine more additional coverages. However, this higher amount of coverage comes at a cost—Nationwide monthly premiums are more expensive than the national average.

Before deciding if Nationwide is right for you, get quotes from at least three companies so that you can compare their renters insurance coverage options and premiums:

Compare Renters Insurance Companies

Companies Nationwide Assurant Lemonade
Companies Nationwide Assurant Lemonade
Get a free quote Not available through This Old House Not available through This Old House Visit site
Known for Credit card coverage in the basic policy Rent protection add-on Giveback program
Monthly price About $20 About $12 As low as $5
Customer service 24/7 for claims; limited for sales and service 24/7 for claims; 8 am–8 pm for everything else Online
BBB rating A+ A+ B+

Company Overview

  • CEO: Kirt Walker
  • Years in business: 94
  • State availability: 48
  • Address: 1 Nationwide Plaza
  • City/State: Columbus, OH
  • Zipcode: 43215
  • A.M. Best financial strength rating: A+

Frequently Asked Questions About Nationwide

Does Nationwide renters insurance cover dog bites?

Most of the time, Nationwide covers dog bites under liability coverage. However, if you have a certain breed or your dog has a history of violence, you may have to purchase extra coverage to cover your pet.

Does Nationwide renters insurance cover car damage?

No. Your auto insurance will cover damage to your car, while the personal property portion of your renters insurance policy will cover damage to belongings inside your car.

Can you cover firearms with Nationwide renters insurance?

Yes. Firearms and their accessories are considered personal property. If you have an antique firearm that’s worth more money, you may have to purchase extra protection using the scheduled personal property add-on.

Can you get a discount for bundling a Nationwide renters insurance policy with another policy?

Yes. Nationwide gives you a discount for bundling renters insurance with another type of insurance, like auto insurance or life insurance. You can also get discounts for having fire alarms, smoke detectors, and burglar alarms and for being claim-free.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.