Home>Discussions>INSULATION & HVAC>Replacement of WBV Oil-Fired Boiler
2 posts / 0 new
Last post
Replacement of WBV Oil-Fired Boiler

I have a cracked Boiler and it still operates but I need to replace it. Quotes to furnish and install a new WBV-3 has ranged from 5k to 8k. I can get a unit pretty inexpensively and I was wondering how difficult it is to replace by myself. I am somewhat handy and I am not changing the type of system and or number of zones.

My question, is a boiler replacement a job for a weekend warrior or just leave it to the professionals? If it is a job a wkend warrior can take on are there any recommendations and or suggestions?


Re: Replacement of WBV Oil-Fired Boiler


I assume you've already checked to see if there is any partial warranty left on the cracked boiler you have now---sometimes Peerless will give the contractor a break on a cracked heat exchanger if you agree to buy another Peerless---how old is the current boiler???

I would get as many separate estimates for the job as possible---at least 5 or 6---the quote you have now seems too high.

The Peerless WBV is a standard-issue cast iron boiler that is very common & popular in the heating industry---besides Peerless, good ones are made by Crown, Burnham, Dunkirk, Slant/Fin, Utica, Smith, & New Yorker, among others.

This type of boiler if bought at the wholesaler's (or Home Depot in the case of Slant/Fin) will cost you ~$1500 + $1k installation costs & take out the old boiler, & $1k for an indirect HWH & other valves, etc. = $3500 to $4000 as a low-ball, reasonable amount to pay for a replacement.

If you take enough quotes, you should find someone who will do it for closer to $3500-$4000 than $8k.

On the other hand, there are lot's of reasons for not doing it yourself---most towns have an ordinance that allows only licensed heating contractors to install boilers; you would void the warranty on a diy install; these units weigh ~600 lbs & are delivered to your doorstep---it's up to you to get it in the cellar & get the old one out---you risk serious injury or damaging the unit if it slips while going down the cellar stairs ---just renting a dumpster will cost ~$400.

Setting up a burner flame requires expensive combustion analysis tools to minimize soot, smoke, co, co2 & maximize a fuel-efficient flame.

I would recommend a separate indirect hot water heater, if you don't have one now, rather than ordering a boiler with a hot water coil, which is an inefficient way to make hot tap water.

Sponsored Stories

TV Listings

Find TV listings for This Old House and Ask This Old House in your area.