30 posts / 0 new
Last post
b_r
Knob & Tube meets NM

I have a wall switch box with 3 switches, each controlling a different light fixture. The box is powered by one hot that is pig-tailed off and connected to each of the 3 switches. The wiring is all K&T.

I am replacing 2 of the 3 fixtures including wiring 12/2 from the fixtures back to the switch. Also, I am running 12/2 from the service panel (15 amp breaker) to the switch box. This means that for 2 of the 3 fixtures, they will be brand new Romex from service panel all the way through the switches to fixtures. What I'm left with is the third fixture, which I am not touching. Which leads me to my question:

Can I run 12/2 from service panel (15 amp breaker) to a switch and then leave the K&T wiring from the switch to the existing fixture? If so, do I have to be concerned with the old K&T neutral in any way?

Ernie_Fergler
Re: Knob & Tube meets NM

I would be surprised to find a neutral wire in the wall switch box. As with knob and tube wiring the neutral never had to go to the switch box to begin with.
Is one present in the box, or are you able to locate it somewhere else?
That may be your biggest problem.:mad:

Blue RidgeParkway
Re: Knob & Tube meets NM
b_r wrote:

I have a wall switch box with 3 switches, each controlling a different light fixture. The box is powered by one hot that is pig-tailed off and connected to each of the 3 switches. The wiring is all K&T.

I am replacing 2 of the 3 fixtures including wiring 12/2 from the fixtures back to the switch. Also, I am running 12/2 from the service panel (15 amp breaker) to the switch box. This means that for 2 of the 3 fixtures, they will be brand new Romex from service panel all the way through the switches to fixtures. What I'm left with is the third fixture, which I am not touching. Which leads me to my question:

Can I run 12/2 from service panel (15 amp breaker) to a switch and then leave the K&T wiring from the switch to the existing fixture? If so, do I have to be concerned with the old K&T neutral in any way?

connecting it is the concern. K&T has to be soldered connections in junction boxes. How are you planning on connecting it to the NM? Wire nuts are out.

If you are rewiring a circuit do the whole thing.

JLMCDANIEL
Re: Knob & Tube meets NM

Why run a separate circuit for the third switch? Just cap and tape the K&T power wire or disconnect it at the source, then jumper the new black from one other other switches. You could then leave the top of the switch and the fixture wired as is.
Jack

JLMCDANIEL
Re: Knob & Tube meets NM
Blue RidgeParkway wrote:

connecting it is the concern. K&T has to be soldered connections in junction boxes. How are you planning on connecting it to the NM? Wire nuts are out.

If you are rewiring a circuit do the whole thing.

I have to ask, on what foundation do you base your first statement?
Jack

b_r
Re: Knob & Tube meets NM
Ernie_Fergler wrote:

I would be surprised to find a neutral wire in the wall switch box. As with knob and tube wiring the neutral never had to go to the switch box to begin with.
Is one present in the box, or are you able to locate it somewhere else?
That may be your biggest problem.:mad:

Yes, there is no neutral in the switch box, but what I was actually referring to was the neutral at the fixture. I would be supplying a new NM hot to the switch box, the hot would be pig-tailed to three switches with one of those switches still connected to K&T from switch to fixture.

b_r
Re: Knob & Tube meets NM
JLMCDANIEL wrote:

Why run a separate circuit for the third switch? Just cap and tape the K&T power wire or disconnect it at the source, then jumper the new black from one other other switches. You could then leave the top of the switch and the fixture wired as is.
Jack

Exactly. This is what I intended to to -- I just wanted to make sure that I could have one end of the switch (from power to switch) NM, while the other half of the switch (from switch to fixture) be K&T.

-Brad

Blue RidgeParkway
Re: Knob & Tube meets NM

http://www.markhellerelectric.com/wusplice.pdf

How-to's with citations diagrams. Local rules vary greatly even from towns to towns, and personalities of individual inspectors in the same office! Your homeowners insurance may have an opinion also. Ours voided coverage if any K&T circuit was modified, and defined repairs differently (more restrictive then the NEC), and required entire circuit be removed and replaced if any alteration other than specific defined repairs of the original circuit was made. When we replaced panels we were required to decommission ALL of the K&T.

havanagranite
Re: Knob & Tube meets NM

hummmmmm interesting. I don't think I have ever heard of insurance companies doing an inspection on a remodel unless it was due to fire damage or other insurance claim.

Ernie_Fergler
Re: Knob & Tube meets NM
Blue RidgeParkway wrote:

connecting it is the concern. K&T has to be soldered connections in junction boxes. How are you planning on connecting it to the NM? Wire nuts are out.

If you are rewiring a circuit do the whole thing.

Inaccurate information provided here. Please Google again.:D
Of course you can wire nut K&T and Romex, in any approved J-box.

canuk
Re: Knob & Tube meets NM

Here we go again.:rolleyes:

Pages

TV Listings

Find TV listings for This Old House and Ask This Old House in your area.