Home>Discussions>PLUMBING>Hot Water Heater Recirculating?
7 posts / 0 new
Last post
stevealex
Hot Water Heater Recirculating?

My 6.5 year-old gas hot water heater (50 gallon A.O. Smith) has started running out of hot water after 15 minutes or so. My plumber (from a large company in NY) came out and just turned the temp up. When that didn't work, I spoke to the owner of the company, who told me it was probably recirculating warm water at the top and not heating the whole tank. He said it would probably just be better to replace it than repair it. And, of course my parts warranty expired 4 months ago (tank warranty is still ative)

Does this sound like an accurate diagnosis? What can I do to confirm the problem?

Thanks for any help,
Steve

johnjh2o
Re: Hot Water Heater Recirculating?

It sounds like you have a bad dip tube. This would cause the cold water entering the tank to go out he hot side rather then going to the bottom of the tank.

John

JLMCDANIEL
Re: Hot Water Heater Recirculating?

The most likely cause is that the bottom element has blown out. Turn off the electricity and water to the WH, drain the tank. remove the old element, take it to a hardware or big box store and get a new one identical to the old. Re install, turn the water on , do not turn the electricity on until the tank is full and water comes out of a hot water faucet.

Jack

johnjh2o
Re: Hot Water Heater Recirculating?
JLMCDANIEL wrote:

The most likely cause is that the bottom element has blown out. Turn off the electricity and water to the WH, drain the tank. remove the old element, take it to a hardware or big box store and get a new one identical to the old. Re install, turn the water on , do not turn the electricity on until the tank is full and water comes out of a hot water faucet.

Jack

Jack it's a gas water heater.

John

JLMCDANIEL
Re: Hot Water Heater Recirculating?

Ooops, my bad!:o

Jack

Fencepost
Re: Hot Water Heater Recirculating?

Do you have a lot of sediment in your water? If so, it could be that the tank is full of dirt, and the capacity has been severely reduced.

Open the drain valve at the bottom. If nothing comes out, suspect the above... but poke a wire into the valve just to see if maybe there's just a chunk of something blocking it.

Water heaters should be flushed annually to remove sediment by opening the drain valve at the bottom.

The dip tube is easy to replace, sounds like you've got a lazy plumber. Remove the nipple on the cold side. If the dip tube's not attached, look inside the water heater, you may be able to pull it out of the inlet. If you still can't find it, it probably fell inside and you just need to get a new one from the hardware store.

hvhehcca
Dip Tube

I like the dop tube idea. 15 min x 2gpm draw - 30 gallons which means the tank is likely trying to recover. Depending on the water conditions, ie hardness, it may not be worth investing the money. The tank is 6.5 yrs old. The avg lifespan of a water heater is 6-10 years. Best investment may be to replace it.

TV Listings

Find TV listings for This Old House and Ask This Old House in your area.