Home>Discussions>INSULATION & HVAC>Has Anyone Replaced an "Octopus"?
7 posts / 0 new
Last post
Shaina Stavem
Has Anyone Replaced an "Octopus"?

My husband and I have put an offer on a small, old house in Minneapolis with a giant "octopus" gravity heating system. There is a good chance that asbestos is present on both the furnace and ducts. My problem is that we would love to have an idea of how much we are looking to spend to a) remove the asbestos, b) remove all ductwork and the furnace, and c) replace it with either a forced air or radiant floor heating system. I have tried to call and get a ballpark estimate, but contractors aren't willing to give me an idea without looking at it first. I understand why, but I do not own the house and would love to know before there's no looking back.

SO, has anyone out there had any similar work done, and would you be willing to give me an idea of how much it cost you?

Rick
Re: Has Anyone Replaced an "Octopus"?

Yes I have had a similar unit replaced. Cost will depend on the individual unit and your local area. You need to have an experienced contractor inspect and give you a bid before you buy. Most good contractors can give you a price range after a quick inspection.

Fencepost
Re: Has Anyone Replaced an "Octopus"?

Make an offer contingent upon an inspection by a reputable asbestos abatement contractor. If there's no asbestos, the offer is valid; if there is asbestos then the offer is void.

If the seller acknowledges there is asbestos, then make the offer contingent upon a removal/replacement estimate less than some dollar amount.

Seller should pay for the inspection.

MLBSF
Re: Has Anyone Replaced an "Octopus"?

fencepost is right, if you suspect that there's asbestos there, then make your offer contingent on the seller having it removed at their cost. also, as part of your offer (and this is the beauty of the real estate market now) make your offer contingent on getting a satisfactory estimate on replacing the heating system. you can call more shots now than you ever could before. sellers, in general, will be extremely accomodating if they have a buyer on the hook so take advantage of it. you should be able to have them remove the asbestos and allow you to get a few estimates on a new heating system......and if you don't like what you see, you can back out of the deal. i'm also a real estate agent and i've seen some buyers and sellers do some quirky things in order to make a sale go through. you'll never know how much you can get until you ask and the answer never get's worse than a "no".

michael

Bob Gabrilson
Re: Has Anyone Replaced an "Octopus"?
Shaina Stavem wrote:

My husband and I have put an offer on a small, old house in Minneapolis with a giant "octopus" gravity heating system. There is a good chance that asbestos is present on both the furnace and ducts. My problem is that we would love to have an idea of how much we are looking to spend to a) remove the asbestos, b) remove all ductwork and the furnace, and c) replace it with either a forced air or radiant floor heating system. I have tried to call and get a ballpark estimate, but contractors aren't willing to give me an idea without looking at it first. I understand why, but I do not own the house and would love to know before there's no looking back.

SO, has anyone out there had any similar work done, and would you be willing to give me an idea of how much it cost you?

Costs vary with the equipment you choose but most people will go with a 95% furnace, 2-stage, variable-speed.
The furnace installed with the ductwork, wiring and gas piping will be approx. $5,000. Furnace and asbestos removal approx. $800. It's a two day job.

Sten
Re: Has Anyone Replaced an "Octopus"?

I agree with Fencepost, costs will vary depending on your location so an offer contingent on the removal or cost of the removal of the asbestos is the way to go. Good Luck!!! :)

Bob Gabrilson
Re: Has Anyone Replaced an "Octopus"?

She asked for just an "idea of a cost". $6,000-8,000 should be enough for them to decide if they want to take it further. I don't think we need to waste a salesman's time quite yet. Just me. :)

TV Listings

Find TV listings for This Old House and Ask This Old House in your area.