14 posts / 0 new
Last post
GLR
3-Way...ish Question

I'm the new head trustee at our church. We have two switches controlling lights in one room. Both switches must be turned on in order for the lights to operate. Is this OK, or do we need someone to fix it? Wondering what to check at each switch to determine the remedy. We have had in-house volunteer help over the years and we are in an area with no code enforcement.

GLR

GLR
Re: 3-Way...ish Question

Thanks,

That gives me an idea. They probably used a regular switch instead of 3way's. I've done several, so I know what to look for in that case. Thanks for the idea. I've got a pretty simple book on wiring, but I never thought that the switch might be wrong. Yes, both switches must be on in order for the lights to work.

glr

canuk
Re: 3-Way...ish Question
YukYuk wrote:

Might be two regular switches in series. I've seen this in older structures intentionally done, especially churches (sacristy areas)and old private schools, and private office/study or otherwise remote areas not part of the regular public areas and not an emergency exit path. Keeps curious explorers out of darkened areas when their first location switch flip didn't produce a lit room or hall, when they're supposed to be going elsewhere in the building, and the area isn't locked. Usually just those responsible for shutting off lights and locking up know the secret series of switches that must be in the ON position to light up a room. Makes locking up after a remote activity much faster, and keeps the kids out.

Are you serious ?

goldhiller
Re: 3-Way...ish Question
canuk wrote:

Are you serious ?

LOL :D

Verily, I say unto thee....let us look for the most obscure reasons/possibilities imaginable.

Off the cuff, I'd say some well-meaning volunteer didn't pay quite enough attention and consequently flipped the common with one of the travelers.

canuk
Re: 3-Way...ish Question
Quote:

Verily, I say unto thee....let us look for the most obscure reasons/possibilities imaginable.

Geez .... I really was begining to think this was a Fellini film :eek::D

goldhiller
Re: 3-Way...ish Question
canuk wrote:

Geez .... I really was begining to think this was a Fellini film :eek::D

Evidently.......your imagination exceeds mine by a wide margin. :D

Then again, I don't know if I've ever seen a Fellini film. I might change my mind. :D

canuk
Re: 3-Way...ish Question
Quote:

Then again, I don't know if I've ever seen a Fellini film. I might change my mind. :D

No ... you don't ... trust me .... besides we're in one now.;):eek::D

JLMCDANIEL
Re: 3-Way...ish Question
GLR wrote:

I'm the new head trustee at our church. We have two switches controlling lights in one room. Both switches must be turned on in order for the lights to operate. Is this OK, or do we need someone to fix it? Wondering what to check at each switch to determine the remedy. We have had in-house volunteer help over the years and we are in an area with no code enforcement.

GLR

If they are 3-way switches one possibility is that half of one switch is bad, in that case the light would only be on if both switches are in the right position and off in all other configurations.
Jack

JLMCDANIEL
Re: 3-Way...ish Question
canuk wrote:

Geez .... I really was begining to think this was a Fellini film :eek::D

Wow, I didn't know you were into that artsy stuff. I though you were a regular guy.:D
Jack

canuk
Re: 3-Way...ish Question
YukYuk wrote:

Yes seriously, older churches not uncommon to find his type of set up, especially where no one has done work since the 60s. Not all that different then having a pull chain fixture supplied via a wall switch, or security lighting controlled by a photo eye, also with a wall switch. Think of it as a poor man's stage lighting or security lighting control panel.

Interesting.
You learn something new everyday.

canuk
Re: 3-Way...ish Question
JLMCDANIEL wrote:

Wow, I didn't know you were into that artsy stuff. I though you were a regular guy.:D
Jack

Yep .... that's me .... a reno-sance man. :D

Pages

TV Listings

Find TV listings for This Old House and Ask This Old House in your area.