family in remodeled farmhouse kitchen
Photo: Tria Giovan
« »

The Game Plan

Kelly and I closed on the farm three months after we married. Everyone thought we were nuts, but we had a strategy. First, we'd renovate the carriage house, since it needed less work, and move in. Then we'd take on the big house. We wanted a large home because we planned to have kids—we just didn't expect to have two of them before the main house was move-in ready.

The first phase was an unexpected, tedious one. Because of municipal confusion, I spent nearly a year doing research and writing letters to prove that our property comprised two legal houses. This had to be resolved: Once we finished the big house's renovation, we wanted to rent out the carriage house for extra income. In the meantime, we were lucky to be able to live in a house nearby that my father owned.

Shown: Kelly and Todd Tuttle, with daughters Gretchen, 2, and Claudia, 4, use the kitchen island for dinner prep and casual meals.
Ask TOH users about Befores and Afters

Contribute to This Story Below